the religious roots of modern poverty policy: catholic, lutheran, and reformed protestant traditions compared

  title={the religious roots of modern poverty policy: catholic, lutheran, and reformed protestant traditions compared},
  author={Sigrun Kahl},
  journal={European Journal of Sociology},
  pages={91 - 126}
  • S. Kahl
  • Published 1 April 2005
  • Economics
  • European Journal of Sociology
this paper shows that religion is a basic principle that underlies modern poverty policy. however, it has played out in very different ways in societies according to the relative predominance of catholic, lutheran, and calvinist heritages. though religion is but one explanation for why we deal with the poor as we do today, systematically accounting for denominational differences in poor relief traditions can help to answer a series of otherwise perplexing cross-national differences in poverty… 

The return of religion? : the paradox of faith-based welfare provision in a secular age

For centuries, churches were the main institutional providers of welfare in Europe before the state took over this role in the late 19th century. The influence of modernization theory meant that

Protestant Ethics-In-Action

Abstract This article shows how voluntary social work in late 19th/early 20th century Copenhagen emerged as the result of several creative re-interpretations of the cultural schemas of revivalist

Support for Redistribution in Western Europe: Assessing the role of religion

Previous sociological studies have paid little attention to religion as a central determinant of individual preferences for redistribution. In this article we argue that religious individuals, living

Religion and inequality: the lasting impact of religious traditions and institutions on welfare state development

  • J. Jordan
  • Economics
    European Political Science Review
  • 2014
A strong correlation exists between inequality and religion, such that societies marked by high inequality are more religious than those with more egalitarian income distributions. What explains this

What We Talk about When We Talk about Poverty: Culture and Welfare State Development in Britain, Denmark and France

Why did historical anti-poverty programs in Britain, Denmark and France differ so dramatically in their goals, beneficiaries and agents for addressing poverty? Different cultural views of poverty

Compassionate Neoliberalism?: Evangelical Christianity, the Welfare State, and the Politics of the Right

Faith, Government, and Neoliberalism The study of neoliberalism has been a popular theme in political science, geography, and sociology for the past decade. The focus of this vast literature varies

Why Comparative Politics Should Take Religion (More) Seriously

The study of religion holds great promise for the study of identity, institutional origins, the state, and the strategies of institutional actors in comparative politics. Doctrinal differences

The Second Vatican Council, poverty and Irish mentalities

ABSTRACT The role of the Catholic Church as conservative watchdog in the ‘culture wars’ of the 1970s and 1980s, with regards to issues of contraception, abortion and divorce, has perhaps obscured its

Welfare States and Their Inequality as a Result of Cultural Differences Instead of Varieties of Capitalism

Social inequality depends crucially on how welfare states and different types of capitalisms distribute and redistribute income. But why do welfare states and capitalisms differ in a way that brings

Nazi Charity: Giving, Belonging, and Morality in the Third Reich

This dissertation is a cultural history of the practices and ideas that constituted poor relief under the Nazi regime. It argues that Nazis practiced an inward-looking and exclusionary type of



The Decretists and the “Deserving Poor”

  • B. Tierney
  • Economics, History
    Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • 1959
In spite of all the complex controversies concerning the interplay of religious ideas and economic forces at the end of the Middle Ages the investigation of the pre-existing medieval poor law has

Poverty and Political Culture: The Rhetoric of Social Welfare in the Netherlands and France, 1815-1854

Chapter 1 Foreword by Arjo Klamer Chapter 2 Introduction Chapter 3 Similarity and Difference: The Debates about Poor Relief and the Logic of Comparative History Chapter 4 Rhetorical Practices and

Religion and the rise of capitalism : an historical study

In one of the true classics of twentieth-century political economy, R. H. Tawney addresses the question of how religion has affected social and economic practices. He tracks the influence of

The Disciplinary Revolution: Calvinism and the Rise of the State in Early Modern Europe

What explains the rapid growth of state power in early modern Europe? While most scholars have pointed to the impact of military or capitalist revolutions, Philip S. Gorski argues instead for the

Support and redeem: charity and poor relief in Italian cities from the fourteenth to the seventeenth century

Dans les quatre grandes villes italiennes de Florence, Gênes, Rome et Venise, le développement de la charité officielle et organisée au cours de la période du quatorzième au dix-septième siècles

From charity to client-oriented social service production: A social profile of religious welfare associations in Western European comparison

The social profile of Western European religious welfare associations has never been studied in empirical detail. It is the aim of a Mannheim comparative project to systematically collect data on the

The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism

This paper examines the development of medical technology in terms of Max Weber's theory of rationalization. It argues that medical technology is a part of the general process of social, political

The Evolution of the British Welfare State: A History of Social Policy since the Industrial Revolution

List of Tables - Preface - Preface to the Second Edition - Preface to the Third Edition - Acknowledgements - Select Time Chart - Foreword: Perspectives on the History of Welfare - Introduction - The

Health care and poor relief in Counter-Reformation Europe

Brian Pullan, Manchester University, The Counter-Reformation, Medical Care and Poor Relief Jonathan Israel, University College London, Counter-Reformation, Economic Decline, and the Delayed Impact of