Your Liberty or Your Life: Reciprocity in the Use of Restrictive Measures in Contexts of Contagion

  title={Your Liberty or Your Life: Reciprocity in the Use of Restrictive Measures in Contexts of Contagion},
  author={A. M. Viens and C{\'e}cile M. Bensimon and Ross E. G. Upshur},
  journal={Journal of Bioethical Inquiry},
In this paper, we explore the role of reciprocity in the employment of restrictive measures in contexts of contagion. Reciprocity should be understood as a substantive value that governs the use, level and extent of restrictive measures. We also argue that independent of the role reciprocity plays in the legitimisation the use of restrictive measures, reciprocity can also motivate support and compliance with legitimate restrictive measures. The importance of reciprocity has implications for how… Expand
Reciprocity and Ethical Tuberculosis Treatment and Control
It is argued that reciprocity can function as a mid-level principle in public health, and generally, captures a core social obligation arising once an individual or group is burdened as a result of acting for the benefit of others (even if they derive a benefit themselves). Expand
Limiting Rights and Freedoms in the Context of Ebola and Other Public Health Emergencies: How the Principle of Reciprocity Can Enrich the Application of the Siracusa Principles.
CESCR General Comment No. 14, paragraph 16 maintains that a right to health also includes the right to control the spread of infectious diseases via a variety of control measures, some of which are restrictive. Expand
Ethics of selective restriction of liberty in a pandemic
If and when it may be ethically acceptable to impose selective liberty-restricting measures in order to reduce the negative impacts of a pandemic by preventing particularly vulnerable groups of the community from contracting the disease is considered. Expand
Advancing Global Health Equity in the COVID-19 Response: Beyond Solidarity
It is argued that achieving global health equity in the context of COVID-19 will require that notions of reciprocity and relational equity are introduced to the response. Expand
Restrictive Measures in an Influenza Pandemic: A Qualitative Study of Public Perspectives
This study solicits perspectives from Canadians on the ethical considerations of using restrictive measures in response to influenza pandemics and uses public views to contribute to a better understanding of what is considered to be the justifiable use of restrictive measures. Expand
Does Population Health Have an Intrinsically Distributional Dimension
Verweij and Dawson claim that population health has a distributive dimension; Coggon argues that this presupposes a normative commitment to equity in the very definition of population health, whichExpand
A Code of Ethics for Social Marketing? Bridging Procedural Ethics and Ethics-in-Practice
ABSTRACT We consider the role of codes of ethics in social marketing, distinguishing between “procedural ethics” and “ethics-in-practice” (after Guillemin & Gillam, 2004). We review foundations forExpand
Moral Philosophy and Politics
Public health policies often require individuals tomake personal sacrifices for the sake of protecting other individuals or the community at large. Such requirements can be more or less demanding forExpand
Smoking Bans and Persons with Schizophrenia: A Straightforward Use of the Harm Principle?
The article concludes by arguing that the possible benefits of smoking for persons with schizophrenia creates a rightful interest that cannot be ignored even if one applies the harm principle to protect others from the negative effects of second-hand smoke. Expand
Screening for infectious diseases of asylum seekers upon arrival: the necessity of the moral principle of reciprocity
The authors argue that the reciprocity principle leads to a stronger ethical justification of screening programmes and help achieve a balance between justifiable rights claims of the host population and the asylum seekers. Expand


The manner in which the concept of reciprocity is implicated in functional theory is explored, enabling a reanalysis of the concepts of "survival" and "exploitation." The need to distinguish betweenExpand
Beyond compassion: the central role of accountability in applying a human rights framework to health.
  • A. Yamin
  • Political Science, Medicine
  • Health and human rights
  • 2008
It is argued that donor states and other actors have parallel obligations, and there are three aspects of accountability with which a human rights approach to health as a social policy and development issue should be concerned. Expand
Is there a moral obligation not to infect others?
The emergence of HIV infection and AIDS has refocused concern on the obligations surrounding the carrying and transmission of communicable diseases. This article asks three related questions: IsExpand
From Chaos to Coercion: Detention and the Control of Tuberculosis
This is a fascinating book. It uses tuberculosis to look at the balance between individual liberty and the public good: the tensions created between personal liberty and social responsibility, aExpand
Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History
Abstract We designed an experiment to study trust and reciprocity in an investment setting. This design controls for alternative explanations of behavior including repeat game reputation effects,Expand
A Relational Account of Public Health Ethics
It is argued that pandemic planning must be squarely situated in the larger realm of public health and that an ethics framework for public health will be one that recognizes the need to pay particular attention to the vulnerability of subpopulations lacking in social and economic power. Expand
A Guilt-Based Explanation of the Door-in-the-Face Influence Strategy
A new explanation is proposed for the accumulated research findings concerning the door-in-the-face (DITF) influence strategy. The explanation treats successful DITF implementations as based onExpand
Justification and Legitimacy
In this essay I will discuss the relationship between two of the most basic ideas in political and legal philosophy: the justification of the state and state legitimacy. I plainly cannot aspire hereExpand
Ethics, Tuberculosis and Globalization
It is argued that tuberculosis is one of the most important neglected topics in bioethics and examines a range of the more challenging ethical issues associated with tuberculosis: individual obligations to avoid infecting others, coercive social distancing measures, third-party notification, health workers' duty to treat contagious patients, and international justice. Expand
Communitarianism : a new public ethics
Liberal-communitarian debate: history of the debate Individualism and socially embedded self The problem of pluralism. The communitarian proposal: the scope of community. The problem of community -Expand