Wise up: Clarifying the role of metacognition in the Dunning-Kruger effect.

@article{McIntosh2019WiseUC,
  title={Wise up: Clarifying the role of metacognition in the Dunning-Kruger effect.},
  author={Robert D. McIntosh and Elizabeth A. Fowler and Tian-hu Lyu and Sergio Della Sala},
  journal={Journal of experimental psychology. General},
  year={2019}
}
The Dunning-Kruger effect (DKE) is the finding that, across a wide range of tasks, poor performers greatly overestimate their ability, whereas top performers make more accurate self-assessments. The original account of the DKE involves the idea that metacognitive insight requires the same skills as task performance, so that unskilled people perform poorly and lack insight. However, global measures of self-assessment are prone to statistical and other biases that could explain the same pattern… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

The Dunning-Kruger effect revisited.
In one of the most highly replicable findings in social psychology, Kruger and Dunning1 showed that participants who performed worse in tests of humour, reasoning, and grammar were also more likely
Neural correlates of the Dunning–Kruger effect
TLDR
Episodic memory appears to play a contributory role in metacognitive judgements of illusory superiority, and over‐ and under‐estimators use differing cognitive processes when assessing their performance, such that under‐ESTimators may rely on recollection during memory while over-estimator may draw upon excess familiarity when over‐estimating their performance.
Dunning-Kruger Effect: Intuitive Errors Predict Overconfidence on the Cognitive Reflection Test
TLDR
Results taken together suggest that participants who perform poorly in the CRT and also those who score higher in intuitive thinking disposition are more susceptible to the influences of heuristic-based cues, such as answer fluency, when judging their performance.
Measures of relative metacognitive accuracy are confounded with task performance in tasks that permit guessing
This article investigates the concern that assessment of metacognitive resolution (or relative accuracy—often evaluated by gamma correlations or signal detection theoretic measures such as d a ) is
Presence or absence of Dunning-Kruger effect: Differences in narcissism, general self-efficacy and decision-making styles in young adults
The Dunning-Kruger effect is a cognitive bias in which individuals who are unskilled in certain domains overestimate their ability and are unaware of it. Past studies have focused on establishing the
Metacognitive Awareness Scale, Domain Specific (MCAS-DS): Assessing Metacognitive Awareness During Raven’s Progressive Matrices
TLDR
This study investigated the relationship between metacognitive awareness and intelligence via the design and use of a novel Meta-Cognitive Awareness Scale – Domain Specific (MCAS-DS) that encourages reflection of task strategy processes and shows promise for elucidating the relationship Between metacognition and intelligence using the task-specific scale.
Among the Two Kinds of Metacognitive Evaluation, Only One Is Predictive of Illusory Object Perception
TLDR
The relationship between expectation-induced hallucination proneness and self-confidence in performance was studied in a visual perception task, supporting the view that there is no unitary mechanism of metacognitive evaluations and extending this view to the domain of visual hallucinatory perception.
Assessing students' self-assessment ability in an interdisciplinary domain
TLDR
SSA can be valuable in predicting master's students' academic achievement when taking specific measures when designing the predictive module, and which attributes are mostly associated with the accuracy level of SSA in higher education.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES
Skilled or unskilled, but still unaware of it: how perceptions of difficulty drive miscalibration in relative comparisons.
TLDR
It is proposed that a noise-plus-bias model of judgment is sufficient to explain the relation between skill level and accuracy of judgments of relative standing, and that judges at all skill levels are subject to similar degrees of error.
Unskilled and unaware of it: how difficulties in recognizing one's own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments.
TLDR
Across 4 studies, the authors found that participants scoring in the bottom quartile on tests of humor, grammar, and logic grossly overestimated their test performance and ability.
Unskilled and unaware--but why? A reply to Krueger and Mueller (2002).
TLDR
The authors of the present article respectfully disagree with this proposal and suggest that any interpretation of J. Krueger and R. A. Mueller's results is hampered because those authors used unreliable tests and inappropriate measures of relevant mediating variables.
Estimating the Relationship between Skill and Overconfidence
How to measure metacognition
TLDR
Other measures based on signal detection theory and receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis that are “bias free,” are reviewed, and these quantities are related to the calibration and discrimination measures developed in the probability estimation literature.
Unskilled, unaware, or both? The better-than-average heuristic and statistical regression predict errors in estimates of own performance.
TLDR
High rather than low performers were more error prone in that they were more likely to neglect their own estimates of the performance of others when predicting how they themselves performed relative to the group.
Metacognitive control of action: Preparation for aiming reflects knowledge of Fitts’s law
TLDR
The findings suggest that metacognition applies to both perceptual-motor skills and intellectual skills, and that these two domains are more similar than traditionally assumed.
Unskilled and optimistic: Overconfident predictions despite calibrated knowledge of relative skill
  • D. Simons
  • Psychology
    Psychonomic bulletin & review
  • 2013
TLDR
The finding of a Dunning–Kruger effect despite knowledge of relative ability suggests that differential self-knowledge is not a necessary precondition for the Dunning-K Kruger effect.
The Dunning–Kruger Effect
...
...