Wide or Narrow Scope ?

  title={Wide or Narrow Scope ?},
  author={John Broome},
This paper is a response to ‘Why Be Rational?’ by Niko Kolodny. Kolodny argues that we have no reason to satisfy the requirements of rationality. His argument assumes that these requirements have a logically narrow scope. To see what the question of scope turns on, this comment provides a semantics for ‘requirement’. It shows that requirements of rationality have a wide scope, at least under one sense of ‘requirement’. Consequently Kolodny’s conclusion cannot be derived. 

From This Paper

Topics from this paper.


Publications citing this paper.


Publications referenced by this paper.
Showing 1-6 of 6 references

Egonsson (eds) 2007: Homage à Wlodek: Philosophical Papers Dedicated to Wlodek Rabinowicz, electronic festschrift: www.fil.lu.se/ HommageaWlodek

Rønnow-Rasmussen, Toni, Björn Petersson, Jonas Josefsson, Dan

Requirements’. In Rønnow-Rasmussen

Broome, John

Why Be Rational ?

Niko Kolodny

Values and the Heart’s Command

van Fraassen, Bas
Journal of Philosophy, • 1973

On the Logic of Attributions of SelfKnowledge to Others

Castañeda, Hector-Neri
Journal of Philosophy, • 1968

Similar Papers

Loading similar papers…