Why we should eliminate personal belief exemptions to vaccine mandates.

@article{Lantos2012WhyWS,
  title={Why we should eliminate personal belief exemptions to vaccine mandates.},
  author={John D. Lantos and M. A. Jackson and Christopher J. Harrison},
  journal={Journal of health politics, policy and law},
  year={2012},
  volume={37 1},
  pages={
          131-40
        }
}
We argue that personal belief exemptions to the mandate for childhood immunizations should not be allowed. Parents who choose not to immunize their children put both their own children and other children at risk. Other children are at risk because unimmunized children go to school or day care when they are contagious but asymptomatic, exposing many more children to potentially dangerous infections. The risks to children from disease are much higher than the risks of vaccines. There are, of… 

Personal Belief Exemptions for Vaccines: What Is Just?

Tension arises when parents, in the interest of preserving their individual freedom to decide what they believe to be best for their children, choose against the common good.

Deliberation on Childhood Vaccination in Canada: Public Input on Ethical Trade-Offs in Vaccination Policy

It is argued that conducting deliberative democratic processes on topics that are polarizing and controversial is viable and should be further developed and implemented to support democratically legitimate and trustworthy policy about childhood vaccination.

Faith-Based Medical Neglect: for Providers and Policymakers

  • R. Swan
  • Medicine, Political Science
    Journal of child & adolescent trauma
  • 2020
Religious exemptions from child health and safety laws should be repealed so that children have equal rights to medical care.

Considering a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for pediatric kidney transplant candidates

At present, it does not appear that pediatric kidney transplant centers are justified to institute a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for candidates, so an examination of relevant ethical principles, analogous cases of the use of mandates, differences between adult and Pediatrics kidney transplant candidates, and the role of gatekeeping in transplant vaccine mandates is sought.

An ethical analysis of mandatory influenza vaccination of health care personnel: implementing fairly and balancing benefits and burdens.

  • A. Antommaria
  • Medicine, Political Science
    The American journal of bioethics : AJOB
  • 2013
While mandatory vaccination programs are justifiable, greater attention should be paid to their implementation and the need to exclude all nonmedical exemptions is questioned.

Pediatric Care Provider Density and Personal Belief Exemptions From Vaccine Requirements in California Kindergartens.

Medical provider contexts are associated with PBEs, reflecting a combination of contextual effects and self-selection of families into schools and PCSAs that share their preferences.

Finding a way to address a wicked problem: vaccines, vaccination, and a shared understanding

New frameworks are needed to build a richer understanding of provider-parent conversations around vaccination and vaccine decision-making to enhance public trust and provider effectiveness in conversations between providers and parents.

Legal and Ethical Considerations in Allowing Parental Exemptions From Newborn Critical Congenital Heart Disease (CCHD) Screening

Although there are significant benefits to screening newborns for CCHD, when a parent refuses for religious or personal beliefs, in the case of CCHd screening, the parental decision should stand.

Nonmedical exemptions from school immunization requirements: a systematic review.

Findings from 42 studies suggest that exemption rates are increasing and occur in clusters; most exemptors questioned vaccine safety, although some exempted out of convenience and easier state-level exemption procedures increase exemption rates and both individual and community disease risk.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 20 REFERENCES

Measles outbreaks in religious groups exempt from immunization laws.

State immunization laws which exempt religious groups present difficult problems in disease control in measles epidemics, and public health officials are encouraged to be aware of the legal rights and obligations of religiously exempt groups so outbreaks in these groups can be effectively controlled.

The Association between Intentional Delay of Vaccine Administration and Timely Childhood Vaccination Coverage

Children whose parents delay vaccinations may be at increased risk of not receiving all recommended vaccine doses by 19 months of age and are more vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases.

Historical comparisons of morbidity and mortality for vaccine-preventable diseases in the United States.

The number of cases of most vaccine-preventable diseases is at an all-time low; hospitalizations and deaths have also shown striking decreases.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of a rotavirus immunization program for the United States.

A US rotavirus immunization program would be cost-effective from the perspectives of society and the health care system, although the cost of the immunizationprogram would not be fully offset by the reduction in health care cost of rotav virus diarrhea unless the price fell to $9 per dose.

Estimation of measles vaccine efficacy and critical vaccination coverage in a highly vaccinated population

Analysis of a large outbreak in a German public school to show how estimates of key epidemiological parameters such as the basic reproduction number (R0), vaccine efficacy (VES) and critical vaccination coverage (pc) can be obtained from partially observed outbreaks in highly vaccinated populations.

Ethics and immunization policy: promoting dialogue to sustain consensus.

A systematic examination of policy options to evaluate immunization policy options could facilitate the public dialogue necessary to continually recreate a broad consensus on immunization practices and enable us to choose policies most in accord with the authors' fundamental values.

The epidemiology of rotavirus diarrhea in the United States: surveillance and estimates of disease burden.

A rotavirus vaccine program will require improved surveillance, including the timely collection of data from sentinel hospitals, in which a diagnosis of rotav virus can be established or ruled out for all children hospitalized for diarrhea.

Haemophilus influenzae Type b disease among Amish children in Pennsylvania: reasons for persistent disease.

Investigation of recent cases, community surveys for Hib vaccination coverage and pharyngeal carriage, and a questionnaire assessing vaccination knowledge and attitudes among 2 Amish communities in Pennsylvania found undervaccinated communities still exist and allow circulation of Hib strains, resulting in disease among susceptible children.

The epidemiology of pertussis in England and Wales.

The hypothesis that vaccine-induced immunity has a serotype-specific component is supported by recent changes in serotype prevalence which have followed the increase in vaccine coverage, and the case for replacing whole-cell vaccine with a new acellular preparation will require careful evaluation.