Why the "Death Panel" Myth Wouldn't Die: Misinformation in the Health Care Reform Debate

@article{Nyhan2010WhyT,
  title={Why the "Death Panel" Myth Wouldn't Die: Misinformation in the Health Care Reform Debate},
  author={Brendan Nyhan},
  journal={The Forum},
  year={2010},
  volume={8}
}
  • B. Nyhan
  • Published 27 April 2010
  • Political Science, Sociology
  • The Forum
Both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama struggled to overcome widespread and persistent myths about their proposals to reform the American health care system. Their difficulties highlight the influence of factual misinformation in national politics and the extent to which it correlates with citizens' political views. In this essay, I explain how greater elite polarization and the growth in media choice have reinforced the partisan divide in factual beliefs. To illustrate these points, I analyze… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

The Hazards of Correcting Myths About Health Care Reform

TLDR
An experiment to determine if more aggressive media fact-checking could correct the false belief that the Affordable Care Act would create “death panels” backfired among politically knowledgeable Palin supporters, who were more likely to believe in death panels and to strongly oppose reform if they received the correction.

The Exaggerated Life of Death Panels: The Limits of Framing Eects on Health Care Attitudes

Experiments demonstrate that framing can influence public opinion. Yet in practice, political elites employ frames in use by the public, making their causal effects unclear. The 2009-12 health care

Tea Party Health Narratives and Belief Polarization: the Journey to Killing Grandma

TLDR
It is argued that culturally driven healthcare narratives of the Tea Party have had a significant impact on right-wing public opinion and Republican politics regarding U.S. healthcare policy.

The Exaggerated Life of Death Panels? The Limited but Real Influence of Elite Rhetoric in the 2009-2010 Health Care Debate

Experiments demonstrate that elites can influence public opinion through framing. Yet outside laboratories or surveys, real-world constraints are likely to limit elites’ ability to reshape public

The Road to Somewhere: Why Health Reform Happened

  • J. Hacker
  • Political Science
    Perspectives on Politics
  • 2010
Why did comprehensive health care reform pass in 2010? Why did it take the form it did—a form that, while undeniably ambitious, was also more limited than many advocates wanted, than health policy

Rumors and Health Care Reform: Experiments in Political Misinformation

  • A. Berinsky
  • Political Science
    British Journal of Political Science
  • 2015
This article explores belief in political rumors surrounding the health care reforms enacted by Congress in 2010. Refuting rumors with statements from unlikely sources can, under certain

Debunking Sarah Palin: Mainstream news coverage of ‘death panels’

On 7 August 2009, Sarah Palin posted two words to her Facebook page that would come to define a summer of discord around health care reform. This study examines how traditional media reported on the

Facts and Myths about Misperceptions

  • B. Nyhan
  • Political Science
    Journal of Economic Perspectives
  • 2020
Misperceptions threaten to warp mass opinion and public policy on controversial issues in politics, science, and health. What explains the prevalence and persistence of these false and unsupported

The death panel myth among older adults: Political ideology, advance directives, and perceived discrimination on the basis of age

TLDR
Those who believed in the death panel myth had more conservative political ideology, lower perceived need for living wills, and higher perceived discrimination on the basis of age.

The Conspiracist Strategy: Lessons from American Alternative Health Promotions

  • Gad Yair
  • Political Science
    European journal of American studies
  • 2019
Hofstadter's classic essay "The Paranoid Style in American Politics" opened a floodgate of analyses of fear and conspiracy theories in American culture. The present paper adds to those studies by
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 113 REFERENCES

Bankrupt Rhetoric How Misleading Information Affects Knowledge about Social Security

Most citizens know little about politics. Scholars often attribute political ignorance to individual-level factors, but we concen- trate on the quality of the information environment. Employing a

The 1993-1994 Debate on Health Care Reform: Did the Polls Mislead The Policy Makers?

This work analyses whether the polls in 1993 and 1994 misled US policy makers about the urgency of health care reform. It reviews the attitudes of Americans about their own health care, their

Polarized America: The Dance of Ideology and Unequal Riches

The idea of America as politically polarized—that there is an unbridgeable divide between right and left, red and blue states—has become a cliche. What commentators miss, however, is that increasing

Media Use and Political Predispositions: Revisiting the Concept of Selective Exposure

Today, people have ample opportunity to engage in selective exposure, the selection of information matching their beliefs. Whether this is occurring, however, is a matter of debate. While some worry

Shaping Public Opinion: The 9/11-Iraq Connection in the Bush Administration's Rhetoric

We suggest that the 2003 war in Iraq received high levels of public support because the Bush administration successfully framed the conflict as an extension of the war on terror, which was a response

Misinformation and the Currency of Democratic Citizenship

Scholars have documented the deficiencies in political knowledge among American citizens. Another problem, misinformation, has received less attention. People are misinformed when they confidently

Motivated Skepticism in the Evaluation of Political Beliefs

We propose a model of motivated skepticism that helps explain when and why citizens are biased-information processors. Two experimental studies explore how citizens evaluate arguments about

All the President's Spin: George W. Bush, the Media, and the Truth

CONTENTS PREFACE INTRODUCTION 1 BUSH'S WHITE HOUSE: THE VANGUARD OF SPIN 2 FROM WATCHDOG TO LAPDOG: HOW BUSH HAS EXPLOITED THE PRESS 3 CAMPAIGN 2000: THE ORIGINS OF THE BUSH PLAYBOOK 4 TAX AND SPIN:

Misperceptions, the Media, and the Iraq War

The Iraq war and its aftermath have raised compelling questions about the capacity of the executive branch to elicit public consent for the use of military force and about the role the media plays in

Red Media, Blue Media: Evidence of Ideological Selectivity in Media Use

We show that the demand for news varies with the perceived affinity of the news organization to the consumer’s political preferences. In an experimental setting, conservatives and Republicans
...