Why sociologists abandoned the sick role concept

@article{Burnham2014WhySA,
  title={Why sociologists abandoned the sick role concept},
  author={John C. Burnham},
  journal={History of the Human Sciences},
  year={2014},
  volume={27},
  pages={70 - 87}
}
  • J. Burnham
  • Published 1 February 2014
  • Sociology
  • History of the Human Sciences
The concept of the sick role entered sociology in 1951 when Talcott Parsons creatively separated the sick person out of the doctor–patient dyad. The idea became fundamental in the subdiscipline of medical sociology. By the 1990s, the concept had almost disappeared from the research literature. Beyond the generational and theoretical changes that explain how the sick role idea could become irrelevant or unnecessary to sociologists, there were two immediate factors: the negative politicization of… 
Subjectivity and illness narratives
Following Talcott Parsons’ (1951) introduction of the concept of the ‘‘sick role’’ in the early 1950s, the fields of social sciences, psychology and critical medical humanities have witnessed an
Debating Humanity: Towards a Philosophical Sociology
Debating Humanity explores sociological and philosophical efforts to delineate key features of humanity that identify us as members of the human species. After challenging the normative
Beyond Moralism in Medical Education: The Making of Physician-Anthropologists for the Study of Good Care in France
TLDR
The aim of this chapter is to describe how a local version of this moral economy of care organizes medical education in France to humanize physicians.
Wanting to work: managing the sick role in high-stake sickness insurance meetings.
TLDR
It is suggested that analysing psychological matters as they are oriented to by participants renders sick role theory relevant for a wide range of settings and respecifies criticism of the model.
The Rhetoric of the 'Passive Patient' in Indian Medical Negligence Cases.
TLDR
It is suggested that laws that adopt narratives that acknowledging the significance of patient engagement and the relevance of effective communication during clinical encounters would help cultivate a culture of patient-centred care, by moving beyond the rhetoric of 'passive patient' and the 'health/choice' dichotomy.
Legitimacy Work : Managing Sick Leave Legitimacy in Interaction
This thesis studies how sick leave legitimacy is managed in interaction and develops an empirically driven conceptualization of ‘legitimacy work’. The thesis applies an ethnomethodological framewor
The Dangers of Health and Safety: Marijuana Legalization as Frontier Capitalism
Abstract. In this article I explore how the legalization of marijuana in North America involves the racialized class appropriation of diverse material, social and cultural capitals borne of
Role theory and the practice of interprofessional education: A critical appraisal and a call to sociologists
TLDR
A sociological lens and the tenets of role theory are applied to identify and analyze the apparent tensions nested within IPE aims with respect to issues of role specificity and role blurring, and suggest discipline-specific qualities that sociologists bring to IPE research, and future directions and applications for sociologist interested in exploring elements of IPE.
Reactions to Discredit in Memory Consultation
TLDR
The author presents the main strategies that patients seem to develop when doctors place their credibility in doubt and concludes with some reflections about interpretive issues regarding the elderly patients’ behavior during medical assessment.
Dance to death: the aesthetic experience of dying
TLDR
This study explores the shared experience of one woman’s ovarian cancer, from diagnosis to death, using documentary materials from the Illness Period as a metaphor for the movement of the authors' bodies through that time.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 119 REFERENCES
Talcott Parsons, the Sick Role and Chronic Illness
TLDR
The precarious social position of chronic patients between being governed by and being consumers of medicine can only be adequately understood if one involves, as Parsons did, the moral economy surrounding health and illness.
From the Sick Role to Subject Positions: A New Approach to the Medical Encounter
While Parsons’ theory of the sick role has been widely criticized, the alternatives that have been proposed are inadequate. Here subject positions theory is put forward as a viable approach to
Parsons revisited: from the sick role to...?
TLDR
Parsons, despite his (many) critics and detractors, has much to contribute here, not simply in terms of past insights, but also with regard to the present and future.
Sick-Role Legitimization
The purpose of this chapter is to consider in detail the issue of sick-role legitimization. There are three major sections to the chapter. The first provides a brief review of the sick role in light
The Sociology of Deviance: An Obituary
Part 1 A new deal for degenerates? the sociology of social deviation 1895-1940: Durkheim, modernity and doubt the birth - immigration and the urban jungle social realism and the Godfather -
Time for creative integration in medical sociology.
  • S. Levine
  • Sociology
    Journal of health and social behavior
  • 1995
The burgeoning of medical sociology has sometimes been accompanied by unfortunate parochialism and the presence of opposing intellectual camps that ignore and even impugn each other's work. We have
Culture, the 'sick role' and the consumption of health.
  • C. Shilling
  • Medicine
    The British journal of sociology
  • 2002
TLDR
This paper revisits Parsons's conception of the 'sick role' and examines the relevance of his writings on the cultural understanding of sickness to the consumption of health in the contemporary era, and focuses on the development of pro-active approaches towards the healthy body, and the growth of 'information rich' consumers of health care.
Illness behaviour: a selective review and synthesis.
TLDR
It is shown that singular and segmented approaches to illness behaviour have not clearly elucidated the complexity of the phenomenon, and a more comprehensive and structured analysis of illness behaviour can be accomplished with mixed qualitative and hierarchical/structural quantitative techniques.
Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge
TLDR
Profession of Medicine is a sociological analysis of the professions in modern society and the fundamental nature of the professional claim, and the structure of professional institutions is examined.
The Sick Role: Assessment and Overview
Despite the growing criticisms of Parsons' original formulation (Parsons 1951), it is impossible to discuss the sick role without acknowledging his fundamental contribution in helping to bridge the
...
...