Why reforms fail

  title={Why reforms fail},
  author={Wesley G. Skogan},
  journal={Policing and Society},
  pages={23 - 34}
  • W. Skogan
  • Published 16 January 2008
  • Political Science
  • Policing and Society
Police reform is risky and hard, and efforts to innovate in policing often fall short of expectations. This chapter examines sources of resistance to change in policing. Some are internal, including opposition to reform at virtually all levels of the organization and among special units. The position of unions vis-a-vis change is highly variable, particularly if proposals do not threaten working conditions and officer safety. Politicians and other potential opponents of change lurk in the… 

Change and continuity in the police: Introduction to the Special Issue

Over the past few decades police organizations in democratic countries all over the world have been confronted with a seemingly endless flow of minor and major changes and developments. These changes

Police Organization Continuity and Change: Into the Twenty‐first Century

American policing demonstrates both continuity and change. A high degree of decentralization persists, as do bureaucratic structures of larger police agencies. The structures and practices of the

Examining the Sustainability of Pattern or Practice Police Misconduct Reform

Section 14141 of the Violent Crime Act of 1994 fundamentally restructures the regulation of police behavior in the United States. Since the law’s passage, dozens of police departments have undergone

From discretion to standardization: Digitalization of the police organization

In this article, we aim to examine whether intelligence-led policing in police practice reinforces the control model of the police organization. We argue that digitalization of police working life

Police Leadership in Fostering Evidence-Based Agency Reform

Leading an evidence-based police agency is easier said than done. In policing, the rhetoric of being evidence-based far outstrips the reality. In this article, we examine the role of police leaders

Recommendations for Integrating Compstat and Community Policing

Community policing and Compstat are two of the most popular policing reforms in the USA and abroad, but little attention has been paid to how these reforms work together when implemented in the same

The challenges of change: Exploring the dynamics of police reform in Scotland

Despite a long tradition of pessimism regarding the scope for meaningful change in police practices, recent structural reforms to police organizations in several European countries suggest that

Leadership in problem-oriented policing

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to explore the role of leadership in problem‐oriented policing (POP).Design/methodology/approach – This paper uses interrupted time series models to isolate the

Beyond the Patten Report: The Governance of Security in Policing with the Community

Policing in stable, democratic societies is predominantly concerned with theimplementation and practice of the globally accepted philosophy of ‘communitypolicing’. This concept, while itself

Police reform in Scotland: What can we learn from the experiences of front-line officers?

Little is known about how front-line police officers navigate major structural reforms within their organization. The findings presented in this paper were collected as part of the first ever




Research Summary: This paper provides the first national description of Compstat programs, considered in the framework of strategic problem solving. Relying on a survey of American police

Police: Streetcorner Politicians.

"This book . . . examines the problem of police corruption . . . in such a way that the stereotype of the crude, greedy cop who is basically a grown-up delinquent, if not an out-and-out robber,

Police Innovation: Contrasting Perspectives

1. Introduction David Weisburd Part I. Community Policing: 2. The promise of community policing Wesley G. Skogan 3. Community policing: a skeptical view Stephen Mastrofski Part II. Broken Windows: 4.

Community Organizations and Crime

Community organizations that have crime problems on their agendas are common across the country. They originate as an anticipatory response to crime or as a consequence of local criminal activity;

Community Policing: The CPOP in New York

Introduction The Officer's Perception of the Role Implementing the CPO Role Evaluating the Performance of CPOs Supervision in the CPO Program CPOP in the Context of the Patrol Structure The

Drug Enforcement in Public Housing

Community Policing, Chicago Style

Police departments across the USA are busily "reinventing" themselves, adopting a new style known as "community policing". Police departments that succeed in adopting this new stance have an entirely