Why does relativity allow quantum tunnelling to ‘take no time’?

  title={Why does relativity allow quantum tunnelling to ‘take no time’?},
  author={Dmitri Sokolovski},
  journal={Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences},
  pages={499 - 506}
  • D. Sokolovski
  • Published 8 February 2004
  • Physics
  • Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
In quantum tunnelling, what appears to be an infinitely fast barrier traversal can be explained in terms of an Aharonov–like weak measurement of the tunnelling time, in which the role of the pointer is played by the particle's own coordinate. A relativistic wave packet is shown to be reshaped through a series of subluminal shifts which together produce an anomalous ‘superluminal’ result. 

Figures from this paper

'Superluminal' tunneling as a weak measurement effect
We exploit the analogy between the transfer of a pulse across a scattering medium and Aharonov's weak measurements to resolve the long standing paradox between the impossibility to exceed the speed
Klein paradox for bosons, wave packets and negative tunnelling times
We analyse a little known aspect of the Klein paradox. A Klein–Gordon boson appears to be able to cross a supercritical rectangular barrier without being reflected, while spending there a negative
Quantum tunneling in low-dimensional semiconductors mediated by virtual photons
Quantum tunneling, a phenomenon that has no counterpart in classical physics, is the quantum-mechanical process by which a microscopic particle can transition through a potential barrier even when
Path summation and von Neumann-like quantum measurements (10 pages)
We demonstrate how a general von Neumann\char21{}like measurement can be analyzed in terms of histories (paths) constructed for the measured variable $A$. The Schr\"odinger state of a system in a
Relativity and the Tunneling Problem in a “Reduced” Waveguide
Wave packets are considered as solutions of the Maxwell equations in a reduced waveguide exhibiting tunneling due to a stepwise change of the index of refraction. We discuss several concepts of
A strange weak value in spontaneous pair productions via a supercritical step potential
We consider a case when a weak value is introduced as a physical quantity rather than as an average of weak measurements. The case we treat is a time evolution of a particle by the 1 + 1-dimensional
Relativistic tunnelling time for electronic wave packets
We have analyzed the influence of the wave packet size in the relativistic tunnelling time τ and its uncertainty Δτ when it traverses a given potential barrier. The analytical expressions obtained
Speed-up and slow-down of a quantum particle
We study non-relativistic propagation of Gaussian wave packets in one-dimensional Eckart potential, a barrier, or a well. In the picture used, the transmitted wave packet results from interference
Revising Whitehead’s Notion of Society in the Light of Contemporary Physics
Abstract This article argues that Joseph A. Bracken’s revisions of Alfred North Whitehead’s derivative notion of “society” are plausible in view of developments in physics since Whitehead. In
Materie in Auflösung – Die Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik
Als der grose alte Mann der britischen Physik, Lord Kelvin, im Jahr 1900 auf die Erkenntnisse der Physik aus dem vergangenen Jahrhundert zuruckblickte, sprach er von zwei Wolken, die uber den


How much time does a tunneling particle spend in the barrier region?
The question in the title may be answered by considering the outcome of a ``weak measurement'' in the sense of Aharonov, Albert, and Vaidman. Various properties of the resulting time are discussed,
Time in quantum mechanics
From the contents: Introduction Characteristic Times in Scattering Theory The Time Energy Uncertainty Relation Jump Time and Passage Time: The Duration of a Quantum Transition Bohm Trajectory
Conditional probabilities in quantum theory and the tunneling-time controversy.
  • Steinberg
  • Physics
    Physical review. A, Atomic, molecular, and optical physics
  • 1995
It is argued that there is a sensible way to define conditional probabilities in quantum mechanics, assuming only Bayes's theorem and standard quantum theory. These probabilities are equivalent to
How the result of a measurement of a component of the spin of a spin-1/2 particle can turn out to be 100.
We have found that the usual measuring procedure for preselected and postselected ensembles of quantum systems gives unusual results. Under some natural conditions of weakness of the measurement, its
Properties of a quantum system during the time interval between two measurements.
  • Aharonov, Vaidman
  • Physics
    Physical review. A, Atomic, molecular, and optical physics
  • 1990
A description of quantum systems at the time interval between two successive measurements is presented, and how this approach leads to a new concept: a weak value of an observable.
Superluminal tunnelling times as weak values
Abstract We consider the tunnelling particle as a pre- and post-selected system and prove that the tunnelling time is the expectation value of the position of a ‘clock’ degree of freedom weakly
Traversal-Time Distribution and the Uncertainty Principle in Quantum Tunneling.
  • Fertig
  • Mathematics
    Physical review letters
  • 1990
We derive the exact distribution of times spent in the classically forbidden region by a particle as it tunnels through a square barrier potential. We find that the integrated distribution has a
Barrier Penetration and Superluminal Velocity
Abstract We show rigorously in a causal theory that a gaussian wave packet, incident from the left on a potential barrier, turns up on the right side of the barrier at an earlier time than would
Superoscillations and tunneling times
It is proposed that superoscillations play an important role in the interferences that give rise to superluminal effects. To exemplify that, we consider a toy model that a wave packet to travel in
Mathematical Formulation of the Quantum Theory of Electromagnetic Interaction
The validity of the rules given in previous papers for the solution of problems in quantum electrodynamics is established. Starting with Fermi's formulation of the field as a set of harmonic