Why We Should Reject ‘Nudge’

@article{Goodwin2012WhyWS,
  title={Why We Should Reject ‘Nudge’},
  author={Tom Lloyd Goodwin},
  journal={Politics},
  year={2012},
  volume={32},
  pages={85 - 92}
}
  • T. Goodwin
  • Published 1 June 2012
  • Political Science
  • Politics
This article argues that the use of ‘nudge’ tactics in UK policymaking ought to be rejected. Nudge contravenes the coalition government's aspirations to promote ideas such as empowerment, freedom and fairness. Moreover, it is not an effective strategy for bringing about the kind of behavioural changes required to solve society's ‘big problems’ – problems around climate change and public health, for example. The article mines political theory in a way that is distinctly absent from the current… 

Why Nudges Matter: A Reply to Goodwin

This article argues that, contrary to Goodwin's recent arguments, nudges are compatible with the coalition government's stated aspiration to further self-empowerment. This is because, despite its

Why a nudge is not enough: a social identity critique of governance by stealth

Policy makers can use four different modes of governance: 'hierarchy', 'markets', 'networks' and 'persuasion'. In this article, it is argued that 'nudging' represents a distinct (fifth) mode of

The birth of mindpolitics: understanding nudging in public health policy

TLDR
It is argued that to think in terms of biopolitics today means to think of its relation to a world in which public health is managed through architecture of choice and the way individuals are nudged into making better decisions.

A Review of Nudges: Definitions, Justifications, Effectiveness

In an influential book published in 2008, Thaler and Sunstein suggested a novel approach to policy making based on the notion of a ‘nudge.’ Roughly speaking, a nudge is defined as an aspect of the

HAPSc Policy Briefs Series

This paper presents a theoretical analysis of the use of nudge as a tool of governments in influencing people’s behaviour. It captures the emergence of nudge as a policy making tool and its meaning

Green Nudges: Do They Work? Are They Ethical?

Environmental policies are increasingly informed by behavioral economics insights. ‘Green nudges’ in particular have been suggested as a promising new tool to encourage consumers to act in an

Challenging the challenge: The Ethics of Early Intervention

Early intervention (EI) programs face severe and often condemnatory critique. Some common criticisms arising within the social science literature concern the burden of moral blame that EI programs

Nudging As a Public Policy Tool: Exploring the Relationship Between Nudge and the Ability of Citizens for Rational Thought and Choice

This paper presents a theoretical analysis of the use of nudge as a tool of governments in influencing people’s behaviour. It captures the emergence of nudge as a policy making tool and its meaning

Nudging as a new "soft" policy tool: An assessment of the definitional scope of nudges, practical implementation possibilities and their effectiveness

The idea of nudging has become increasingly popular in both academic and political circles. There are, however, many different interpretations of the term 'nudge' which blurs its scope. In this

The Power to Nudge

Nudging policies rely on behavioral science to improve people's decisions through small changes in the environments within which people make choices. This article first seeks to rebut a prominent
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 27 REFERENCES

Nudge nudge, think think: Two strategies for changing civic behaviour

This paper reviews two contrasting approaches governments use to engage the citizen to promote better public policy outcomes: nudging citizens using the insights of behavioural economics, as

The Geographies of Soft Paternalism in the UK: The Rise of the Avuncular State and Changing Behaviour after Neoliberalism

Soft paternalism or libertarian paternalism has emerged as a new rationality of governing in the UK under New Labour, denoting a style of governing which is aimed at both increasing choice and

Deliberative Democracy and Social Choice

The paper contrasts the liberal conception of democracy as the aggregation of individual preferences with the deliberative conception of democracy as a process of open discussion leading to an agreed

What's wrong with negative liberty

This is an attempt to resolve one of the issues that separate ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ theories of freedom, as these have been distinguished in Isaiah Berlin's seminal essay, ‘Two concepts of

A Theory of Justice

  • J. Rawls
  • Law
    Princeton Readings in Political Thought
  • 1971
John Rawls is Professor Emeritus at Harvard University. He is the author of the well-known and path breaking A Theory of Justice (Harvard, 1971) and the more recent work Political Liberalism

The new paternalism : supervisory approaches to poverty

If government tells dependent people how to live today, will we have a more self-reliant society tomorrow? That's the critical question as government increasingly seeks to supervise the lives of poor

Judging nudging: can nudging improve population health?

TLDR
Theresa Marteau and colleagues ask whether the concept of "nudging" stands up to scientific scrutiny.

The Coalition: our programme for government - potential implications for physical activity

  • Panwm
  • Political Science
  • 2010
The Coalition: Our Programme for Government document was published in May 2010, and provides an overview of the key policies that the new Coalition Government will take forward. The programme is set

THE CONSTITUTION OF LIBERTY

TLDR
Professor Hayek has now developed more fully a system of political and social thought dedicated to liberty and based on the thesis that only through liberty can the spirit of civilization survive.