Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching

@article{Kirschner2006WhyMG,
  title={Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching},
  author={Paul A. Kirschner and John Sweller and Richard E. Clark},
  journal={Educational Psychologist},
  year={2006},
  volume={41},
  pages={75 - 86}
}
Evidence for the superiority of guided instruction is explained in the context of our knowledge of human cognitive architecture, expert–novice differences, and cognitive load. Although unguided or minimally guided instructional approaches are very popular and intuitively appealing, the point is made that these approaches ignore both the structures that constitute human cognitive architecture and evidence from empirical studies over the past half-century that consistently indicate that minimally… 
Why Instructional Explanations Often Do Not Work: A Framework for Understanding the Effectiveness of Instructional Explanations
Although explanations are a common means of instruction, research shows that they often do not contribute to learning. To unravel the factors giving rise to the ineffectiveness of instructional
The Implications of Research on Expertise for Curriculum and Pedagogy
Instruction on problem solving in particular domains typically relies on explanations from experts about their strategies. However, research indicates that such self-reports often are incomplete or
When Wrong is Right: The Instructional Power of Multiple Conceptions
TLDR
A new theory, multiple conceptions theory, states that learners develop better conceptual knowledge when they are guided to compare multiple conceptions of a concept during instruction and proposes instructional design principles based on the mechanisms that were identified.
THE EFFECTS OF INSTRUCTIONAL METHOD ON PRESERVICE TEACHERS' LEARNING, COGNITIVE PROCESSES, AND DECISION-MAKING SKILLS
This dissertation is a study of case-based instruction in early childhood teacher preparation. I sought to determine if case-based instruction could be used effectively to develop theoretical
Cognitive Load Theory: What It Is, Why It's Important for Accounting Instruction and Research
ABSTRACT:  The purpose of this paper is to increase the awareness of accounting instructors, particularly those teaching introductory courses, of an important and relatively new development in
Student Perceptions of Cognitive Efficiency: Implications for Instruction
This study used a phenomenological approach with content analysis to create a model of how students perceive cognitive efficiency (CE), which is generally described as increases in the rate, amount,
The Impact of Students' Exploration Strategies in Discovery-Based Instructional Software
TLDR
This paper reports on a study of 158 university students who each used two instructional simulations and showed that when compared with the tutorial-based learning program systematic exploration resulted in learning benefits, while unsystematic exploration did not.
Guiding learners through technology-based instruction: The effects of adaptive guidance design and individual differences on learning over time.
Adaptive guidance is an instructional intervention that helps learners to make use of the control inherent in technology-based instruction. The present research investigated the interactive effects
Cognitive load theory vs. constructivist approaches: which best leads to efficient, deep learning?
TLDR
Investigating the relative utility of CLT and constructivist-based approaches for teaching complex skills using a military command and control task suggests that the acquisition of procedural, declarative, and conceptual knowledge, as well as decision-making skills, did not differ as a function of the type of instruction used.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 154 REFERENCES
Should there be a three-strikes rule against pure discovery learning? The case for guided methods of instruction.
  • R. Mayer
  • Psychology
    The American psychologist
  • 2004
TLDR
Overall, the constructivist view of learning may be best supported by methods of instruction that involve cognitive activity rather than behavioral activity, instructional guidance rather than pure discovery, and curricular focus rather than unstructured exploration.
The Equivalence of Learning Paths in Early Science Instruction
TLDR
It is found not only that many more children learned from direct instruction than from discovery learning, but also that when asked to make broader, richer scientific judgments, the many children who learned about experimental design from direct Instruction performed as well as those few children who discovered the method on their own.
Cognitive Architecture and Instructional Design
Cognitive load theory has been designed to provide guidelines intended to assist in the presentation of information in a manner that encourages learner activities that optimize intellectual
Cognitive Load Theory: Instructional Implications of the Interaction between Information Structures and Cognitive Architecture
TLDR
The basics of cognitive load theory are described, the origins of the instructional implications are sketched, the articles accepted for this special issue as a representative sample of current research in this area are introduced, and the overall results in the context of the theory are discussed.
Cognitive Load Theory and Instructional Design: Recent Developments
TLDR
Cognitive load theory (CLT) is a major theory providing a framework for investigations into cognitive processes and instructional design, and by simultaneously considering the structure of information and the cognitive architecture that allows learners to process that information, cognitive load theorists have been able to generate a unique variety of new and sometimes counterintuitive instructional designs and procedures.
The Expertise Reversal Effect
When new information is presented to learners, it must be processed in a severely limited working memory. Learning reduces working memory limitations by enabling the use of schemas, stored in
Antagonism Between Achievement and Enjoyment in ATI Studies
There is evidence that negative correlations between student achievement and their enjoyment of instructional methods exist under certain circumstances. In aptitude‐treatment interaction (ATI)
Problem‐based Learning: A Review of Literature on Its Outcomes and Implementation Issues
TLDR
It is recommended that caution be exercised in making comprehensive, curriculum‐wide conversions to PBL until more is learned about (1) the extent to which faculty should direct students throughout medical training, (2) PBL methods that are less costly, (3) cognitive‐processing weaknesses shown by PBL students, and (4) the apparent high resource utilization by P BL graduates.
The contributions of co-occurring forms of classroom discourse and academic activities to curriculum events and instruction.
How do academic activities and discourse work together in classrooms to shape learning and instruction? This complex question was answered in a case study of underachieving students in a Grade 8
Belief revision in children: the role of prior knowledge and strategies for generating evidence.
  • L. Schauble
  • Psychology
    Journal of experimental child psychology
  • 1990
...
...