Why Machine-Information Metaphors are Bad for Science and Science Education

  title={Why Machine-Information Metaphors are Bad for Science and Science Education},
  author={Massimo Pigliucci and Maarten Boudry},
  journal={Science \& Education},
Genes are often described by biologists using metaphors derived from computational science: they are thought of as carriers of information, as being the equivalent of “blueprints” for the construction of organisms. Likewise, cells are often characterized as “factories” and organisms themselves become analogous to machines. Accordingly, when the human genome project was initially announced, the promise was that we would soon know how a human being is made, just as we know how to make airplanes… 
Living Machines: Metaphors We Live By
Within biology and in society, living creatures have long been described using metaphors of machinery and computation: ‘bioengineering’, ‘genes as code’ or ‘biological chassis’. This paper builds on
Intelligent Design and the Nature of Science: Philosophical and Pedagogical Points
This chapter offers a critique of intelligent design arguments against evolution and a philosophical discussion of the nature of science, drawing several lessons for the teaching of evolution and for
Metaphor and Meaning in the Teleological Language of Biology
It is concluded that, since teleological concepts cannot be abstracted away from biological explanations without loss of meaning and explanatory power, life is inherently teleological.
From Ends to Causes (and Back Again) by Metaphor: The Paradox of Natural Selection
Natural selection is one of the most famous metaphors in the history of science. Charles Darwin used the metaphor and the underlying analogy to frame his ideas about evolution and its main driving
Metabolism Instead of Machine: Towards an Ontology of Hybrids
It is argued that synthetic biology’s goal of creating efficient production vessels for industrial applications implies a set of ontological assumptions according to which living organisms are machines, and that the hybrids created by synthetic biology should be considered not as machines but as metabolic systems.
Engines of Creationism? Intelligent Design, Machine Metaphors and Visual Rhetoric
It is argued that science communicators could reduce the persuasive impact of ID visual rhetoric based on machine metaphors by emphasizing that self-assembly is fundamental to molecular complexes.
Engineering and Biology: Counsel for a Continued Relationship
This article clarifies and reconfigure the link between biology and engineering, arguing that critics operate with a narrow and incorrect notion of how engineering actually works, and of what the reliance on ideas from engineering entails.
Conceptual Change and the Rhetoric of Evolutionary Theory: ‘Force Talk’ as a Case Study and Challenge for Science Pedagogy
Darwinian theories vary. Some of the variation consists in differences in conceptual frames. These identify the entities and processes over which natural selection ranges. Different conceptual
Do we need a ‘theory’ of development?
Edited by Alessandro Minelli and Thomas Pradeu, Towards a Theory of Development gathers essays by biologists and philosophers, which display a diversity of theoretical perspectives. The discussions
Evolutionary and cognitive foundations of pseudosciences By
People believe the weirdest of things. Forty percent of the US population endorses the claim that Earth and all life on it has been created by God six to ten thousand years ago (Newport, 2010); three


Why intelligent design fails: A scientific critique of the new creationism
  • A. Menuge
  • Biology
    Politics and the Life Sciences
  • 2008
Why Intelligent Design Fails is a collection of 13 essays criticizing the central claims of ID, edited by two physicists, Matt Young and Taner Edis, and can be commended for engaging the actual views of ID's proponents.
God, the devil, and Darwin : a critique of intelligent design theory
In the last fifteen years a controversial new theory of the origins of biological complexity and the nature of the universe has been fomenting bitter debates in education and science policy across
Metaphors We Live by
People use metaphors every time they speak. Some of those metaphors are literary - devices for making thoughts more vivid or entertaining. But most are much more basic than that - they're "metaphors
Recipes or blueprints for our genes? How contexts selectively activate the multiple meanings of metaphors
In the 1990s, critics of public discourse about genetics urged the replacement of the “blueprint” metaphor with the “recipe” metaphor. The subsequent appearance of the “recipe” metaphor in the mass
Compositional pattern producing networks: A novel abstraction of development
Results produced with CPPNs through interactive evolution of two-dimensional images show that such an encoding can nevertheless produce structural motifs often attributed to more conventional developmental abstractions, suggesting that local interaction may not be essential to the desirable properties of natural encoding in the way that is usually assumed.
The Cell as a Collection Overview of Protein Machines: Preparing the Next Generation of Molecular Biologists
It is shown that nearly every major process in a cell is 10 RNA rearrangements as it removes an intron from an carried out by assemblies of 10 or more protein moleRNA transcript, and that protein assemmore elaborate and sophisticated than anything the authors stublies can be enormously complex.
An Extended Synthesis for Evolutionary Biology
  • M. Pigliucci
  • Philosophy
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
  • 2009
It is argued that evolutionary biology has never seen a paradigm shift, in the philosophical sense of the term, except when it moved from natural theology to empirical science in the middle of the 19th century, and the Extended Synthesis is an expansion of the Modern Synthesis of the 1930s and 1940s.
Science as Structured Imagination
This paper offers an analysis of scientific creativity based on theoretical models and experimental results of the cognitive sciences, and argues that distant analogies — where target and source domain differ widely — are especially useful in periods of intense conceptual change.
Preface A scientist is supposed to have a complete and thorough I of knowledge, at first hand, of some subjects and, therefore, is usually expected not to write on any topic of which he is not a
Evolution in Four Dimensions: Genetic, Epigenetic, Behavioral, and Symbolic Variation in the History of Life
In Evolution in Four Dimensions, Eva Jablonka and Marion Lamb argue that there is more to heredity than genes and offers a richer, more complex view of evolution than the gene-based, one-dimensional view held by many today.