Why Isn't There More Progress in Philosophy?1

@article{Chalmers2014WhyIT,
  title={Why Isn't There More Progress in Philosophy?1},
  author={D. Chalmers},
  journal={Philosophy},
  year={2014},
  volume={90},
  pages={3 - 31}
}
  • D. Chalmers
  • Published 3 November 2014
  • Philosophy
  • Philosophy
Abstract Is there progress in philosophy? A glass-half-full view is that there is some progress in philosophy. A glass-half-empty view is that there is not as much as we would like. I articulate a version of the glass-half-empty view, argue for it, and then address the crucial question of what explains it. 
View on Cambridge Press
consc.net
80 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
4
Background Citations
20
Methods Citations
1

80 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Is There Progress in Philosophy? The Case for Taking History Seriously
Abstract In response to widespread doubts among professional philosophers (Russell, Horwich, Dietrich, McGinn, Chalmers), Stoljar argues for a ‘reasonable optimism’ about progress in philosophy. He…
Introduction and Historical Overview
Philosophy is highly speculative. Yet not anything goes in philosophy: it is not a matter of thinking or saying whatever takes your fancy. Philosophers have standards to keep. They seek to evaluate…
Disagreement in Philosophy
Many philosophers (and nonphilosophers) think persistent disagreement is a characteristic feature of philosophy. This thought is central in much scepticism about philosophy as a discipline: Surely ,…
Method in the Service of Progress
There is a powerful three-step argument that philosophy has made no progress. The first step maintains that a field makes genuine progress to the extent that, over time, it provides true answers to…
MAKING PHILOSOPHICAL PROGRESS: THE BIG QUESTIONS, APPLIED PHILOSOPHY, AND THE PROFESSION*
Abstract: The debate over whether philosophy makes progress has focused on its failure to answer a core set of “big” questions. I argue that there are other kinds of philosophical progress which are…
Why the Method of Cases Doesn’t Work
In recent years, there has been increasing discussion of whether philosophy actually makes progress. This discussion has been prompted, in no small part, by the depth and persistence of disagreement…
Big Philosophical Questions: Why They Matter and Why They Are Still Around
Abstract Big philosophical questions—about the mind, the idea of the good, justice, beauty, knowledge—have been the prime interest of philosophers ever since Plato first raised them in his dialogues.…
Critical Theory's Philosophy
Critical Theory has an uneasy relationship to philosophy, and it is a complex question whether it constitutes a philosophical position at all: it both aims to leave philosophy behind and insists on…
How theoretical physics makes progress
1. “A weaker version of Hume’s problem [of induction]: When theories are accepted in science on the basis of empirical success, what are (or what ought to be) the precise methods employed to…
The ordinary and the experimental: Cook Wilson and Austin on method in philosophy
ABSTRACT To what extent was ordinary language philosophy a precursor to experimental philosophy? Since the conditions on pursuit of either project are at best unclear, and at worst protean, the…
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 25 REFERENCES
Progress in Philosophy
A great deal has been written about progress in ^"^ science; little has been written about progress in philosophy.1 Perhaps the very subject is some? thing of an embarrassment. What is to be avoided…
There Is No Progress in Philosophy
Except for a patina of twenty-first century modernity, in the form of logic and language, philosophy is exactly the same now as it ever was; it has made no progress whatsoever. We philosophers…
CAN THERE BE PROGRESS IN PHILOSOPHY
Whether there is, or even can be, progress in philosophy is problematic. There is progress in intellectual history for it is evident enough that human conceptual resources have expanded and developed…
Problems Of Philosophy
IN the following pages I have confined myself in the main to those problems of philosophy in regard to which I thought it possible to say something positive and constructive, since merely negative…
Future pasts : the analytic tradition in twentieth-century philosophy
This collection of previously unpublished essays presents a new approach to the history of analytic philosophy, one which does not assume at the outset a general characterization of the…
What do philosophers believe?
What are the philosophical views of contemporary professional philosophers? We surveyed many professional philosophers in order to help determine their views on 30 central philosophical issues. This…
Verbal Disputes
Is there a distinction between questions of fact and questions of language? Many philosophers have said no. But a version of the distinction is ubiquitous, in philosophy and elsewhere, in the notion…
The Philosophy of Logical Atomism
Introduction The Philosophy of Logical Atomism (1918) 1. Facts and Propositions 2. Particulars, Predicates, and Relations 3. Atomic and Molecular Propositions 4. Propositions and Facts with More than…
The Problem of Evil: The Gifford Lectures Delivered in the University of St. Andrews in 2003
Introduction 1. The Problem of Evil and the Argument from Evil 2. The Idea of God 3. Philosophical Failure 4. The Global Argument from Evil 5. The Global Argument Continued 6. The Local Argument from…
Freedom to Break the Laws
334 Philosophers are unable to agree about free will. Some are determinists 1 who deny free will, some determinists who affirm free will. Some philosophers think that free will is incompatible with…
...
...