Who's Afraid of Reality Shows?

  title={Who's Afraid of Reality Shows?},
  author={Jonathan Cohen and Gabriel Weimann},
  journal={Communication Research},
  pages={382 - 397}
This study explores the dynamics of social concern over reality shows. Couched in the theory of the influence of presumed influence, it is argued that the degree of concern over the effects of media mediates between beliefs in media power and people's responses to such beliefs. Survey data show that perceived influence is distinct from concern over effects. Furthermore, the authors show that perceived influence predicts willingness to censor reality shows but that, in addition to this direct… 

Tables from this paper

The Effects of Media Effects

Prior research in the third-person effects domain has shown that people who believe in harmful media effects are more willing to engage in preventive or accommodative strategies, such as censorship.

Presumed Media Influences and Demands for Restrictions: Using Panel Data to Examine the Causal Direction

In line with theoretical approaches, such as the influence of presumed influence approach, many studies have shown that the stronger individuals perceive the media’s influence to be on others, the

On Medium Theory and the Third Person Effect

Although in the last three decades many works have been devoted to the study of Davison’s (1983) Third-Person Effect (TPE) for a great variety of media contents, as far as we know none of them has

Testing Causal Direction in the Influence of Presumed Media Influence

According to the influence of presumed media influence hypothesis, people estimate the potential effects of media on other people and change their attitudes or behaviors as a consequence. In recent

Third-Person Effect of ISIS's Recruitment Propaganda: Online Political Self-Efficacy and Social Media Activism

The global rise of ISIS has been attributed by many experts to the extremist group’s successful recruiting efforts online. Recognizing the need to curb the terror organization’s social media

Integrating Interpersonal Communication into the Influence of Presumed Media Influence Model: Understanding Intentions to Censor and Correct COVID-19 Misinformation on Social Media

ABSTRACT We extended the influence of presumed media influence model by taking interpersonal communication into account. Our survey (N = 642) results revealed that individuals’ attention to COVID-19

Incivility in Controversies: The Influence of Presumed Media Influence and Perceived Media Hostility on the Antagonists in the German Conflict Over Aircraft Noise

This study tests how hostile media perceptions and presumptions of media effects on the conflicting parties affect the antagonists’ acceptance of an uncivil and uncompromising style of public communication.

Framing Gaming

This study investigates the effects of media frames on attitudes toward video games, perceptions of their users, and consequences. Prior research has shown that gaming is a controversial issue, with

When Others’ Reactions to News Media Messages are Visible: The Influence of News User Comments on Presumed Media Influence

ABSTRACT The presumed media influence framework (IPI) theorizes how mass media influence perceptions and behaviors. The present study uses an online experiment to test the hypotheses deriving from

Direct and indirect eff ects of media coverage Exploring the eff ects of presumed media infl uence on judges, prosecutors, and defendants

: Based on survey data, the study explores the perceptual and behavioral effects on 271 prosecutors and 447 judges whose trials were covered by the media (direct effects) and on defendants (indirect



The Influence of Presumed Media Influence on Democratic Legitimacy

Testing of the notion that perceptions of strong influence of biased media coverage may indirectly lead to an increased willingness to resort to violent protest in Jewish settlers in the Gaza Strip finds that this idea is tested on a sample of Jewish settlers.

The Influence of Presumed Influence

Although direct influences of media have been the primary focus of mass communication research recent theoretical developments have suggested powerful and important indirect effects as well. Derived


The third person effect hypothesis, which states that individuals exposed to a mass media messaage will expect the communication to have a greater effect on others than on themselves, may help to

Rebelde Way in Israel: Parental Perceptions of Television Influence and Monitoring of Children's Social and Media Activities

This study examines parents' perceptions of the influence of a youth-targeted telenovela on their own versus other children using the framework of the third person effect. Survey data (N = 132)

Perceptions of Media Influence and Support for Censorship

Complaints about media coverage of presidential elections have raised concerns that the public may support restrictions on election campaign messages. This study, based on a nationwide telephone

Support for Censorship of Television Violence

This study examined predictors of support for censorship of television violence, including third-person effects (the belief that others are more affected by televised violence than oneself) and

Overrating the X‐Rating: The Third‐Person Perception and Support for Censorship of Pornography

Research has produced plentiful evidence of the third-person perception—the tendency for people to think others are more influenced by mass media than they are themselves. But until now there has

Support for Censorship of Violent and Misogynic Rap Lyrics

Recent calls for censorship of rap music have demonstrated the need to test the perceptual and especially the behavioral components of Davison's third-person effect hypothesis. The hypothesis states

The Truman Show: A Symptom of our Times? Or, a Cure for an Escape Attempt!

This essay argues from a Lacanian perspective as to why “reality television” has become so pervasive in postmodern consumerist society. Against the widely held claim that such reality programming is

The Third-Person Effect and its Influence on Behavioral Outcomes in a Product Advertising Context:

The study revealed that for DTC advertising, the third-person effect operates in a multidimensional fashion through four factors (Negative DTC Ad Effects, Learning and Involvement, Patient/Provider Interaction, and Distrust of D TC Ad Information) and that negative content-based third- person effects were greater than positive effects.