• Corpus ID: 107301574

Who's afraid of low support ratios? a UK response to the UN Population Division report on 'Replacement Migration'

  title={Who's afraid of low support ratios? a UK response to the UN Population Division report on 'Replacement Migration'},
  author={David A. Coleman},
The views expressed in the paper are those of the author and do not imply the expression of any opinion on the part of the United Nations Secretariat. Acknowledgements The projections in this paper were entirely the work of Mr Chris Shaw and Mr Adam Michaels of the UK Government Actuary's Department, without whose generous expert help this paper could not have been written. These projections will be developed further for publication under their authorship later in 2000. The interpretations… 

Development and Critique of the Concept of Replacement Migration

For the last few decades, decline in fertility and mortality have resulted in population ageing and have raised many concerns among demographers. Their uncertainty about the performance of certain

Replacement migration, or why everyone is going to have to live in Korea: a fable for our times from the United Nations.

  • D. Coleman
  • Economics
    Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences
  • 2002
There can be no 'solution' to population ageing, which is to a considerable degree unavoidable, but if the demographic regime of the United Kingdom continues to be relatively benign, future population ageing can be managed with tolerable inconvenience without recourse to increased immigration for 'demographic' purposes.

The United Kingdom State Pension System: Analysis of Proposed Reforms and the Viability of Immigration-Based Policies in Response to Demographic Ageing

  • K. Kotecha
  • Economics
    Annals of Actuarial Science
  • 2007
ABSTRACT This paper briefly examines the options for reform proposed by the Pensions Commission in 2004 to sustain the United Kingdom state pension system in response to an ageing population. It

Demographic Impact of Canadian Immigration Policy: A Replacement Migration Report

Policies related with immigration are becoming unavoidable matter among policy makers in the context of demographic pressure in Canada. To correct ageing and population decline, which are caused due

Labor Force Trends and Immigration in Europe 1

Labor force trends up to 2025 for the fifteen countries (before May 1, 2004) of the European Community are examined. Will demographic decline have an early effect on manpower volume? An estimation is

The UK State Pension System: Analyses of proposed reforms and the viability of immigration- based policies in response to ageing demographics

This paper briefly examines the options for reform proposed by the Pensions Commission in 2004 to sustain the UK state pension system in response to an ageing population. It further explores, under


1.1 Several questions, both theoretical and factual, are presently being raised concerning the interaction between demographic trends and the labour force. If interest is restricted to the

Causes of low fertility in Singapore

Results show that marriage is now seen as just a desirable life outcome, whereas it has traditionally been viewed as an important life stage for men and women alike, and some policy measures that may be useful in addressing lowest low fertility are reviewed.

Effect of Immigration on the Canadian Population: Replacement Migration?

Immigration has a substantial influence on the size and growth of the population and the labour force, and also considerable influence on the socio-cultural composition, as seen through ethnicity,

Labour Force Participation Scenarios for 27 European Countries, 2002–2052

This chapter presents assumptions about the future patterns of labour force participation for 27 European countries for the period 2002–2052. It is assumed that population ageing and, in some



The Welfare Crisis in an Ageing Population

The benefit reviews published in 1985 were proclaimed by their authors as the most fundamental reassessment of the welfare state since Beveridge. These claims were exaggerated; but not as exaggerated

How accurate are the United Nations world population projections

This paper investigates the accuracy of the UN world population forecasts of the age structure and crude birth and death rates in seven major regions of the world. Focus is on comparative accuracy

Royal Commission on Population

The scope of the Population (Statistics) Bill was restricted on account of the reception given it by the House of Commons and by certain sections of the Press, with the result that the facts at the disposal to-day are less comprehensive than they might have been.

UK immigration policy: ‘Firm but fair’, and failing?

Abstract This paper investigates the effectiveness of the UK immigration policy. For over two decades UK immigration policy has had clearly stated aims; to limit immigration for permanent settlement

Active Population Growth and Immigration Hypotheses in Western Europe

  • S. Feld
  • Economics
    European journal of population = Revue europeenne de demographie
  • 2000
It is asserted that there is no risk of a shortage of workers between now and the year 2020, and that an increasing supply of labour will render reliance on a greater influx of immigrant workers unnecessary.

Can Liberal States Control Unwanted Migration?

The commonly held view that liberal democracies cannot effectively control unwanted migration is unwarranted despite the intensification of migration pressures in recent years. To develop a more

Policy interventions in response to below-replacement fertility.

This paper discusses policy interventions in response to below-replacement fertility. It is noted that due to the rising concerns about very low fertility rates interest in policy proposals aimed at

Regulating the age structure of a population through immigration

This paper examines the consequences of a demographic policy which would use migration as a means to control the ratio of the working age population to the population of retirees. It is shown that if

State and the Family: A Comparative Analysis of Family Policies in Industrialized Countries.

In a number of industrialized countries, on the assumption that fertility remains at or close to present levels, populations will start to decline, in some cases quite rapidly in the near to medium

Averting the old age crisis

ConclusionAlthough the kind of reform that is needed will vary across countries, all countries should have a vision of where they are going in the long run. This vision should include separate