Whigs and Stories: Herbert Butterfield and the Historiography of Science

  title={Whigs and Stories: Herbert Butterfield and the Historiography of Science},
  author={N. Jardine},
  journal={History of Science},
  pages={125 - 140}
  • N. Jardine
  • Published 1 June 2003
  • Art
  • History of Science
L'A. decrit l'historiographie de la science au XX e siecle et analyse l'usage des termes whigs et whiggish dans les ecrits de Butterfield (H.) pour signifier le triomphalisme d'un progres scientifique 
‘PROFESSIONAL HISTORIANS are not normally paid to think.’1 Some do, all the same. Few native practitioners pondered more profoundly on their craft during the twentieth century than Sir HerbertExpand
Hagiography, revisionism & blasphemy in Internet histories
ABSTRACT As a whole, existing histories of the Internet's creation and development are stories of success and triumph. In this respect, they resemble hagiographies, a literary genre that consists ofExpand
Butterfield’s nightmare: the history of science as Disney history
Historians of science and technology once worried about the anachronism that suffused their discipline. Today there is less patience for such critical self-reflection. There are however still certainExpand
Beyond the Whig history interpretation of history: lessons on ‘presentism’ from Hélène Metzger
Abstract During the second half of the twentieth century, historians of science have shown a considerable interest in ‘presentism’, a term first applied to the kind of history of science in whichExpand
Is the History of Science Essentially Whiggish?
1. THE STIGMATIC LABEL OF 'WHIGGISM'In his influential 1931 essay The Whig interpretation of history, Herbert Butterfield criticized what he called the "Whig history", the "study of the past for theExpand
A History of Universalism: Conceptions of the Internationality of Science from the Enlightenment to the Cold War
That science is fundamentally universal has been proclaimed innumerable times. But the precise geographical meaning of this universality has changed historically. This article examines conceptions ofExpand
Thinking about ‘Presentism’ from a Historian's Perspective: Herbert Butterfield and Hélène Metzger
Through an examination of the considerable bibliography of the concept of ‘presentism’, I have reached several conclusions concerning the different uses of this concept in the field of the history ofExpand
A Filosofia Mística e a Doutrina Newtoniana: uma discussão historiográfica
This paper brings a study ON the history of science. It points out, by means of a case study that an approach to the history of science implicitly hinges on the historian's view on how science isExpand
Portrait of the realist as a historian: On anti-whiggism in the history of international relations
In recent years, a revisionist history of international relations theory has generated a complex and nuanced picture of classical realism. In doing so, it has also contributed, more often than not,Expand
Considerations on the Current Usefulness of Interpreting the History of Eco- nomic Analysis from a Whig Perspective. This paper attempts to offer a brief overview of Paul Samuelsons proposal toExpand


Uses and Abuses of Anachronism in the History of the Sciences
L'A. demontre que les historiens ont tendance a decrire les actions et les travaux passes avec un certain anachronisme et suggere qu'il serait utile de donner des limites concernant lesExpand
Whig History and Present-centred History
Of the many books written by the late Herbert Butterfield, the most influential by far was The whig interpretation of history . The importance of that essay is not just that it attained the status ofExpand
The Historian and the History of Science
Students of European history have long known that they must concern themselves with a little art in the period of the Renaissance, with religion at the time of the Reformation, and with literature inExpand
Providence and method : Herbert Butterfield and the interpretation of history
This thesis presents an extended critical analysis of the methodological thought of the Cambridge historian Herbert Butterfield (1900-1979). It is based on the full range of his published works, asExpand
Present-Centred History and the Problem of Historical Knowledge
In a previous article, we examined Herbert Butterfield's identification of a certain pattern of anachronism in historical writing, in his classic book The whig interpretation of history (1931). InExpand
The ancient constitution and the feudal law : a study of English historical thought in the seventeenth century
Preface Preface to the first edition Part I. The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law: 1. Introductory: the French prelude to modern historiography 2. The common-law mind: custom and theExpand
The Scenes of Inquiry: On the Reality of Questions in the Sciences
Readership: Scholars and students of philosophy of science, history of science, and sociology of science scientists interested in the methodology and social role of science.
Origins of modern science
Reason, Experiment and Mysticism in the Scientific Revolution†. By M. L. Righini Bonelli and William R. Shea. Pp. 320. (Macmillan: London and Basingstoke; Science History: New York, 1975.) £13.00;Expand
A Hundred Years of the Teaching of History at Cambridge, 1873–1973
Before I start I would like to express my gratitude to the Faculty Board of History who have entrusted me with the very interesting task of delivering this lecture and to Mrs Lindsay for handing me aExpand
Essays in the History of Science
AbstractTHIS is the first volume of a new series intended to be supplementary to the well-known quarterly journal I sis, the organ of the History of Science Society and of the International AcademyExpand