Which of These Things Are Not Like the Others? Comparing the Rational, Emotional, and Moral Aspects of Reputation, Status, Celebrity, and Stigma

  title={Which of These Things Are Not Like the Others? Comparing the Rational, Emotional, and Moral Aspects of Reputation, Status, Celebrity, and Stigma},
  author={Timothy G. Pollock and Kisha Lashley and Violina P. Rindova and Jung Hoon Han},
  journal={Academy of Management Annals},
In this review of the literature on reputation, status, celebrity, and stigma we develop an overarching theoretical framework based on the rational, emotional, and moral aspects of each construct’s... 

Figures and Tables from this paper

EXPRESS: Professional Credibility under Threat: Responses to Negative Social Evaluations in Newly Contested Professions
How do professionals attempt to restore their credibility when it has been tarnished by crises or scandals? To address this issue, we examined how banking professionals who testified during a
Making Sense of Stigmatized Organizations: Labelling Contests and Power Dynamics in Social Evaluation Processes
How do social audiences negotiate and handle stigmatized organizations? What role do their heterogenous values, norms and power play in this process? Addressing these questions is important from a
The Impact of Contact and Fame on Changing the Public Stigma of Mental Illness
Self-disclosure stories from celebrity, Mariah Carey, or noncelebrity, Malia Fontecchio are examined to support hypotheses that noncelebrities would be viewed as more similar and likeable and therefore have greater effects on stigma change and MariahCarey was perceived as more famous, more dissimilar, and less likeable.
The Push and Pull of Attaining CEO Celebrity: A Media Routines Perspective
Why do some CEOs become celebrities, while others with seemingly equal accomplishments do not? After two decades of research, far more is known about the substantial consequences of CEO celebrity t...
The Role of Celebrity and Status in the Performance–Pay Relationship: Evidence from the ‘Big Five’ European Football Leagues
This study explores the reasons behind the existence of frequent mismatches between performance of individuals in organisations and their salary, with a specific focus on contexts where actors or
The Two Towers (or Somewhere in Between): The Behavioral Consequences of Positional Inconsistency across Status Hierarchies
We examine how actors react to status inconsistencies across multiple status hierarchies. We argue that pluralistic value systems create multiple status conferral mechanisms, and that hierarchies’ ...
Activist Hedge Fund Success: The Role of Reputation
The growing visibility and aggressive tactics by some activist hedge funds raises the question of what determines whether these activist campaigns are successful. We propose that the reputation of ...
Understanding the relationship between university characteristics and prestige
Purpose Being a prestigious institution depends on gaining respect in the eyes of various stakeholders with diverse expectations. Existing research is silent on how university characteristics affect
Futurescapes: Imagination and temporal reorganization in the design of strategic narratives
Recent work in organizational and strategy research increasingly accords centrality to narratives in developing and legitimating future-oriented strategies. Despite this growing interest in the use...
Vertical and horizontal inequality are status and power differences: applications to stereotyping by competence and warmth.
Distinguishing status and power differences broadens inequality's scope and creates competitive friction among the distrusted and dissimilar, which creates mutual cooperation of the warm, similar, and familiar.


Toward a Theory of Social Judgments of Organizations: The Case of Legitimacy, Reputation, and Status
The proposed theory extends research on cognitive and sociopolitical legitimacy, reputation, and status by advancing an evaluator's perspective on these concepts as forms of social judgment, each
Celebrity and Infamy? The Consequences of Media Narratives About Organizational Identity
Research on organizational celebrity is in its nascence, and our understanding of the process through which organizations gain, maintain, and lose this asset remains incomplete. We extend this rese...
The social structure of right and wrong
Introduces and illustrates Black's"pure sociology", a theoretical paradigm applicable to human behavior of various kinds. This work contains concepts and typologies applicable to partisan and
The Path Dependence of Organizational Reputation: How Social Judgment Influences Assessments of Capability and Character
It is suggested that stakeholders make distinctions between an organization’s capabilities and its character, and the manner in which judgment heuristics and biases manifest in the development of capability and character reputations is explained.
Stigma; Notes On The Management Of Spoiled Identity
CONTENTS 1. Stigma and Social Identity Preliminary Conceptions The Own and the Wise Moral Career 2. Information Control and Personal Identity The Discredited and the Discreditable Social Information
Being good or being known: An empirical examination of the dimensions, antecedents, and consequences of organizational reputation
We examined the extent to which organizations’ reputations encompass different types of stakeholders’ perceptions, which may have differential effects on economic outcomes. Specifically, we propose...
Celebrity Firms: The Social Construction Of Market Popularity
We extend the concept of celebrity from the individual to the firm level of analysis and argue that the high level of public attention and the positive emotional responses that define celebrity
Against all Odds: A Consideration of Core-Stigmatized Organizations
Studies of illegitimate organizations have failed to present consistent definitions and to recognize that illegitimate organizations persist. Drawing on the emerging organizational stigma literature,
A General Theory of Organizational Stigma
The purpose of this paper is to define the construct of organizational stigma and provide a general theory that explains the conditions under which organizational stigmas are likely to arise, how this process unfolds, and the initial effectsStigmas inflict on organizations.
Social Media and the Formation of Organizational Reputation
The rise of social media is changing how evaluative judgments about organizations are produced and disseminated in the public domain. In this article we discuss how these changes question tradition...