When public recognition for charitable giving backfires: The role of independent self-construal

  title={When public recognition for charitable giving backfires: The role of independent self-construal},
  author={Bonnie J K Simpson and Katherine White and Juliano Laran},
  journal={Journal of Consumer Research},
This research examines the effectiveness of public recognition in encouraging charitable giving, demonstrating that public recognition can sometimes decrease donations. While previous work has largely shown that making donations visible to others can motivate donors, the present research shows that the effectiveness of public recognition depends on whether potential donors are under an independent (i.e., separate from others) or interdependent (i.e., connected with others) self-construal… Expand

Figures from this paper

When Public Recognition Inhibits Prosocial Behavior: The Case of Charitable Giving
Commonly regarded as an important driver of donation behavior, public recognition also can reduce donations. With three studies, this research manipulates whether donors receive public, private,Expand
Effects of Power and Implicit Theories on Donation
Charities have difficulty raising money to execute their plans, which are mainly focused on addressing social challenges. As a big proportion of donations come from individual consumers,Expand
No good deed goes unpunished: the social costs of prosocial behaviour
Abstract Abstract Performing costly helpful behaviours can allow individuals to improve their reputation. Those who gain a good reputation are often preferred as interaction partners and areExpand
“I” and “We” Give Differently: Examining the Impact of Self-Construal and the Time-Ask Effect
“I” AND “WE” GIVE DIFFERENTLY: EXAMINING THE INTERACTION OF SELF-CONSTRUAL AND THE TIME-ASK EFFECT Zuzanna Jurewicz University of Guelph, 2019 Advisor: Dr. Tanya Mark The objective of the presentExpand
Can Thoughts of Having Less Ever Promote Prosocial Preferences? The Relationship between Scarcity, Construal Level, and Sustainable Product Adoption
Although many individuals endorse prosocial causes, little is understood about the factors that determine when people’s desire to consume in ways that benefit society as a whole will exceed theirExpand
Having a secret reduces charitable giving
Secrecy involves the active concealment of information from others, which can cause undesirable consequences for cognitive, perceptual and health psychology, but empirical research linking secrecy toExpand
Every penny counts: The effect of holistic-analytic thinking style on donation decisions in the times of Covid-19
Abstract This research explores how individual differences in holistic-analytic thinking style affect people's donation intentions and decisions. Specifically, we find that individuals with a moreExpand
The impact of virtual presence on willingness to book: The moderating role of self-construal and gender
Abstract Although there is wide agreement that the mere presence of others influences one’s decision-making process, little research is conducted to understand whether the effect of the presence ofExpand
Consumer mindsets matter: Benefit framing and firm–cause fit in the persuasiveness of cause-related marketing campaigns
Abstract The current research investigates the factors associated with the efficacy of cause-related marketing campaigns. A pilot study and three experiments using different supported causesExpand
How Co-creation Increases Employee Corporate Social Responsibility and Organizational Engagement: The Moderating Role of Self-Construal
This research merges literature from organizational behavior and marketing to garner insight into how organizations can maximize the benefits of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) for enhanced CSRExpand


Warm Glow or Cold, Hard Cash? Social Identity Effects on Consumer Choice for Donation versus Discount Promotions
Across five studies, the authors investigate how social identification influences consumer preference for discount-based promotions (i.e., cents-off deals) versus donation-based promotions (in whichExpand
Committing Altruism under the Cloak of Self-Interest: The Exchange Fiction ☆ ☆☆
Two field studies tested the hypothesis that people's willingness to help a charitable organization is greater when the act is presented as an economic transaction than when it is presented as an actExpand
Self-Benefit versus Other-Benefit Marketing Appeals: Their Effectiveness in Generating Charitable Support
Despite the growing need, nonprofit organization marketers have not yet fully delineated the most effective ways to position charitable appeals. Across five experiments, the authors test theExpand
Hide the light or let it shine? Examining the factors influencing the effect of publicizing donations on donors’ happiness
Conflicting arguments exist for whether charities should publicize or ask donors to publicize their charitable contributions. The current research provides an initial examination of the psychologicalExpand
The Effects of Recognition and Group Need on Volunteerism: A Social Norm Perspective
The significance of volunteering for both individuals and society has lead to numerous studies on this behavior across the social sciences. However, virtually no prior research has evaluated how andExpand
Prosocial Behavior in Intergroup Relations: How Donor Self-Construal and Recipient Group-Membership Shape Generosity
This research examines the interplay of self-construal orientation and victim group-membership on prosocial behavior. Whereas consumers primed with an independent self-construal demonstrate similarExpand
In Pursuit of Good Karma: When Charitable Appeals to Do Right Go Wrong
This research examines the implications of consumers’ belief in karma—the belief that the universe bestows rewards for doing right and exacts punishments for doing wrong—in the context of prosocialExpand
How Construals of Money versus Time Impact Consumer Charitable Giving
While past research has suggested that consumers have fundamentally different responses to thinking about money versus time, the current work clarifies an important nuance in terms of how consumersExpand
Hey Look at Me: The Effect of Giving Circles on Giving
Theories abound for why individuals give to charity. We conduct a field experiment with donors to a Yale University service club to test the impact of a promise of public recognition on giving. SomeExpand
The Nature of Slacktivism: How the Social Observability of an Initial Act of Token Support Affects Subsequent Prosocial Action
Prior research offers competing predictions regarding whether an initial token display of support for a cause (such as wearing a ribbon, signing a petition, or joining a Facebook group) subsequentlyExpand