When genius errs: R.A. Fisher and the lung cancer controversy.

  title={When genius errs: R.A. Fisher and the lung cancer controversy.},
  author={Paul D. Stolley},
  journal={American journal of epidemiology},
  volume={133 5},
          416-25; discussion 426-8
  • P. Stolley
  • Published 1 March 1991
  • Medicine
  • American journal of epidemiology
R.A. Fisher's work on lung cancer and smoking is critically reviewed. The controversy is placed in the context of his career and personality. Although Fisher made invaluable contributions to the field of statistics, his analysis of the causal association between lung cancer and smoking was flawed by an unwillingness to examine the entire body of data available and prematurely drawn conclusions. His views may also have been influenced by personal and professional conflicts, by his work as a… 

Tables from this paper

Sir Austin Bradford Hill: A Personal View of His Contribution to Epidemiology
Bradford Hill set out for the first time the criteria required in the conduct of case-control and cohort studies if they were to provide reliable results and cause-and-effect relationships distinguished from those due to bias and confounding.
Lung Cancer, Chronic Disease Epidemiology, and Medicine, 1948-1964
A reexamination of the scientific controversy over smoking in the 1950s and early 1960s provides an important context for understanding the subsequent public relations battles between the tobacco industry and public health after 1964.
The making of an epidemiological theory of bias and confounding
The history of epidemiology, as the history of the emergence and formalisation of its methods, and Vineis and Vandenbroucke (2002) demonstrate convincingly how much epidemiology has borrowed from the social sciences and adapted methods and concepts to its own needs.
The 'weight of evidence' concerning tobacco harm: beliefs in mid-twentieth century America
A version of Chern et al.'s (1995) Bayesian model of `health risk belief' is presented to track the evolution of the `weight' of epidemiological evidence concerning tobacco harm that was in the possession of the T.I.R.C. and the U.S. Public Health Service and related groups during the 1950s and early 1960s.
Tobacco as a cause of lung cancer: some reflections.
  • E. Wynder
  • Medicine
    American journal of epidemiology
  • 1997
This is a historical review of the long effort to establish the link between cigarette smoking and lung cancer, focusing on the apathy of the health professionals concerned and their reasons for not accepting or promoting the evidence relating lung cancer to smoking.
Proof of Causality: Deduction from Epidemiological Observation
  • R. Doll
  • Medicine
    Perspectives in biology and medicine
  • 2002
A report of the use of pituitary gonadotropic hormone in the treatment of undescended testes in adolescent boys, which the authors said had a smaller percentage of failure than had been achieved by reliance on spontaneous descent (Spence and Scowen 1935).
Abe and Yak: The Interactions of Abraham M. Lilienfeld and Jacob Yerushalmy in the Development of Modern Epidemiology (1945–1973)
The relationship between 2 persons much involved in the development of modern epidemiology, Jacob Yerushalmy and Abraham M. Lilienfeld is described and the resulting influences by each individual on the other's professional work are discussed.
The Societal Factor, or How Social Dynamics Affect Science
  • J. Zimring
  • Psychology
    What Science Is and How It Really Works
  • 2019
R. A. Fisher was one of the most influential scientific thinkers of the twentieth century. He was mentioned earlier for his seminal contributions regarding accurate estimates of the likelihood of an
The 2014 Surgeon General's report: commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the 1964 Report of the Advisory Committee to the US Surgeon General and updating the evidence on the health consequences of cigarette smoking.
The 2014 Surgeon General's report commemorates the 50th anniversary of the 1964 report on smoking, which concluded that cigarette smoking was a cause of lung cancer in men and sufficient in scope that "remedial action" was warranted at the societal level.
Towards good epidemiological practices
As epidemiologists, the authors need to recognise that they do not only perform descriptive work but that, on the basis of translational research data coming from environmental chemistry, biochemistry, molecular biochemistry and from various clinical observations and data,they need to be equally involved in the application of preventive strategies and in monitoring the effects of intervention.


Smoking and Lung Cancer
During the years 1957 and 1958, Fisher became involved in a controversy over the issue of whether or not it had been established that smoking causes lung cancer. The seeds of the controversy were
Smoking, the Cancer Controversy: Some Attempts to Assess the Evidence
Smoking, the Cancer Controversy: Some Attempts to Assess the Evidence. By Sir Ronald A. Fisher, Sc.D., F.R.S.; 1959. Edinburgh and London: Oliver and Boyd. Adelaide: Rigby Limited. 8$″ × 5$″, pp. 48.
Cancer and Smoking
It would be possible to infer on exactly similar grounds that inhaling cigarette smoke was a practice of considerable prophylactic value in preventing the disease, for the practice of inhaling is rarer among patients with cancer of the lung than with others.
Lung Cancer and Cigarettes?
The association observable between the practice of cigarette smoking and the incidence of cancer of the lung and the Medical Research Council Statistical Unit has been interpreted almost as though it demonstrated a causal connexion between these variables.
R. A. Fisher, the Life of a Scientist
Smoking and mortality: a 21-year follow-up based on the Swedish Twin Registry.
The impact of smoking on mortality, CHD death and lung cancer is also valid among smoking discordant twins.
Statistical Methods for Research Workers
This book has done more than any other to popularize the use of modern statistical methods and maintains its place as the standard work on its subject for the ordinary scientific worker.
The Design of Experiments
  • J. I
  • Economics
  • 1936
AbstractREADERS of “Statistical Methods for Research Workers” will welcome Prof. Fisher's new book, which is partly devoted to a development of the logical ideas underlying the earlier volume and
Neyman from Life
It is spring in Berkeley. For Jerzy Neyman it is the eighty-fifth spring. As I enter his office on the fourth floor of Evans Hall at the University of California, he is studying a paper on cosmology
Ronald Aylmer Fisher, 1890-1962
Ronald Aylmer Fisher was born on 17 February 1890, in East Finchley. He and his twin brother, who died in infancy, were the youngest of eight children. His father, George Fisher, was a member of the