When bodies are weapons: Masculinity and violence in Sport

  title={When bodies are weapons: Masculinity and violence in Sport},
  author={Michael A. Messner},
  journal={International Review for the Sociology of Sport},
  pages={203 - 220}
  • M. Messner
  • Published 1 September 1990
  • Sociology
  • International Review for the Sociology of Sport
This paper utilizes a feminist theoretical framework to explore the contemporary social meanings of sports violence. Two levels of meaning are explored: first, the broad, socio-cultural and ideological meanings of sports violence as mediated spectacle; second, the meanings which male athletes themselves construct. On the social/ideological level, the analysis draws on an emergent critical/feminist literature which theoretically and historically situates sports violence as a practice which helps… 
Snowboarding: The Construction of Gender in an Emerging Sport
Previous research has identified sport as a practice that creates and legitimizes notions of male dominance. However, gender is constructed and resisted differently within various sporting
Negotiating Masculinities via the Moral Problematization of Sport
Researchers have raised concerns about the construction of dangerous/problematic masculinities within sporting fratriarchies1. Yet little is known about how male sport enthusiasts—critical of
Recently, feminist work on sport and gender has begun to understand male tolerance of physical risk and injury as a constituting process that may enhance a particular brand of masculinization. For
“Some Women Are Born Fighters”: Discursive Constructions of a Fighter’s Identity by Female Finnish Judo Athletes
Martial arts and combat sports have been traditionally associated with masculinity, and a range of contradictory meanings have been attached to women’s engagement and experiences. The present study
Galtung, Violence, and Gender: The Case for a Peace Studies/Feminism Alliance
My paper argues for an incorporation of feminist theories into peace theories, by analyzing what is missing by not confronting feminist contributions to a theory on violence. I take Johan Galtung's
Sporting Masculinities in Prison
Sport plays a key role within discourses of masculinity in Western contemporary culture. Throughout mainstream prison research, the male offender is recognised (or perhaps unrecognised) as the
Men, sport, body performance and the maintenance of ‘exclusive masculinity’
Participation in sport remains an activity dominated by a particular form of masculinity based on competitiveness, aggression and elements of traditional understandings of the sporting male. At the
Fear and loathing on the sport field: masculinities, social transformation and creative teaching strategies
The apparent links between sport and masculinities have generated critical concern from a number of educationalists, feminists and sport sociologists. These concerns have inspired the development of
Gender as One’s Eligibility to Engage In Social Practices: Unpacking the Relationship between Masculinity and Intimate Partner Violence
Among men’s studies scholars, violence is a major focus of attention. Research findings of the past two decades indicate that violence is gendered, and can only be understood in the context of gender
The thrill of the fight : sensuous experiences of boxing : towards a sociology of violence
This thesis employs ethnographic methods to examine lived experiences of sports violence, particularly, the ways in which action in, and around, a boxing ring can be psychologically and physically


Sports and Male Domination: The Female Athlete as Contested Ideological Terrain
This paper explores the historical and ideological meanings of organized sports for the politics of gender relations. After outlining a theory for building a historically grounded understanding of
Sport and women's empowerment
Abstract This paper provides a discussion of the extension of Nancy Hartsock's work on feminism and power to sport. The paper first considers the conceptualization of power. In Western thought power
Changing the rules of the game: Reflections toward a feminist analysis of sport
Abstract Sport, play and games are institutionalized forms of activity used to help maintain male cultural hegemony. Despite reform which has improved access to sport for highly skilled females, the
Out of Bounds: Women, Sport and Sexuality
Feminist Helen Lenskyj presents an insightful examination of the links between women's participation in sports and the control of their reproductive capacity and sexuality. She identifies the female
This article examines the variety of men's responses to feminism in late nineteenthand early twentieth-century United States through texts that addressed the claims raised by the turn-of-the-century
Sport and the maintenance of masculine hegemony
Abstract Sport is a crucial arena in which masculine hegemony is constructed and reconstructed. The effects of sporting activity are usefully analyzed in terms of two major dimensions. Those that
Power and Authority: Moral Consensus and Conformity in Sport
This study examined the moral rationales of 109 male and female coaches, athletes and non- athletes. Subjects read a series of sport scenarios in which a conflict arose between an athlete and a
Hollywood's Prizefight Films: Violence or "Jock" Appeal?
Many psychological experiments on aggression use prizefight films as their stimuli. This paper questions the use of such films for studies of media agression. Examining prizefight films from 1939 to
Significant others' Influence on the Assaultive Behavior of Young Hockey Players
to be intensifying, curiously, it is not often depicted as a social problem. Observers rarely point out the correspondence between assault in an alley and assault on the playing field. The need for
Athletic Aggression: An Issue of Contextual Morality
The designation of an act as aggressive involves an implicit or explicit moral judgment. Consequently, research on aggression must address the value issues involved. The present article suggests that