When Freedom Is Not an Endless Meeting: A New Look at Efficiency in Consensus-Based Decision Making

@article{Leach2016WhenFI,
  title={When Freedom Is Not an Endless Meeting: A New Look at Efficiency in Consensus-Based Decision Making},
  author={Darcy K. Leach},
  journal={The Sociological Quarterly},
  year={2016},
  volume={57},
  pages={36 - 70}
}
  • Darcy K. Leach
  • Published 1 February 2016
  • Political Science
  • The Sociological Quarterly
It is axiomatic among scholars of participatory democracy that consensus-based decision making is inefficient, yet no study has systematically assessed that claim. This article examines the efficiency of consensus decision making in 12 social movement groups from the German autonomous and nonviolence movements. Data were analyzed from 62 semistructured interviews regarding how long it took each group to make a typical decision and what types of decisions were the easiest and most difficult to… 
View on Taylor & Francis
22 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
1
Background Citations
11

22 Citations

Creating Participatory Democratic Decision-Making in Local Organizations
Organizations at the local level that seek to resist hierarchy and conduct themselves along participatory democratic lines appeared so radical in the 1970s that they were called “alternative…
The Logic of A Co-Operative Economy and Democracy 2.0: Recovering the Possibilities for Autonomy, Creativity, Solidarity, and Common Purpose
Over the past 30 years, the collectivist-democratic form of organization has presented a growing alternative to the bureaucratic form, and it has proliferated, here and around the world. This form is…
Drawing Out Democracy: The Role of Sortition in Preventing and Overcoming Organizational Degeneration in Worker-Owned Firms
  • Simon Pek
  • Business
    Journal of Management Inquiry
  • 2019
Fostering sustainable worker ownership and control of their organizations has long been an aspiration for many. Yet, the growth of worker-owned firms (WOFs) is often accompanied by organizational…
Prefigurative politics and social change: a typology drawing on transition studies
ABSTRACT Recent years have seen a surge of interest in prefigurative politics, which refers to the political strategies that model a future society on a micro level and aim to instantiate radical…
Powered Down: The Microfoundations of Organizational Attempts to Redistribute Power
What types of interactions facilitate the redistribution of power across institutional roles? To answer this question, the author draws on ethnographic data from two organizations attempting to shift…
Diversity Regimes in Worker Cooperatives: Workplace Inequality under Conditions of Worker Control
Two major shifts in contemporary work organizations—“employee participation” and “diversity management”—have typically been studied in isolation from one another. Building on theoretical work by…
Emerging Technologies and Innovation—Hopes for and Obstacles to Inclusive Societal Co-Construction
Since the late twentieth century, the concept of emerging technologies, fields designated as such and their governance have received increasing attention in academia, the media and policymaking. This…
Peer Collaboration as a Relational Practice: Theorizing Affective Oscillation in Radical Democratic Organizing
Recently, radical democratic initiatives have been undertaken by freelancers and founders who come together in a range of alternative forms such as ethical entrepreneurial coalitions, urban coworking…
Contemporary anarchist and anarchistic movements
Sociology Compass. 2018;12:e12582. https://doi.org/10.1111/soc4.12582 wileyo Abstract Although the period of highest activity for anarchist movements peaked in the early 1990s, such movement…
Best Friends Forever: Relationship Schemas, Organizational Forms, and Institutional Change
Scholars have drawn on cultural concepts to demonstrate the capacity of organizational actors to transform existing institutional scripts and invent new ones. When it comes to accounting for the…
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 99 REFERENCES
How Participatory Democracy Became White: Culture and Organizational Choice
Why do activists choose the organizational forms they do? Social movement scholars have tended to focus on activists' instrumental assessments of organizational forms' costs and benefits or on…
Freedom is an endless meeting : democracy in American social movements
"Freedom Is an Endless Meeting" offers vivid portraits of American experiments in participatory democracy throughout the twentieth century. Drawing on meticulous research and more than one hundred…
Decisions Without Hierarchy: Feminist Interventions in Organization Theory and Practice
Decisions Without Hierarchy is based on a two-year examination of three feminist organizations: a peace group, health collective, and business women's group. From these case studies, Iannello…
Horizontalism : voices of popular power in Argentina
Are you fighting for change? Are you losing faith in your politicians? This book might be just what you need. Horizontalism: Voices of popular power in Argentina. Edited by Marina Sitriin AK Press,…
Occupying the Political
In this paper we compare the institutional and strategic decision making structures of the civil rights movement with the Occupy movement with special emphasis on the role of self-expression as a…
Community and Organization: The New Left and Michels' “Iron Law”
Most analysts of the new left fault it for having been Utopian, antiorganizational, and even antipolitical, suggesting that these characteristics were responsible for its failures. It is suggested in…
Ideology and the Clamshell Identity: Organizational Dilemmas in the Anti-Nuclear Power Movement
This ethnographic study examines the role of ideology in the development of organizational dilemmas in the Clamshell Alliance, an anti-nuclear protest group active in New England during the late…
Alternatives to Bureaucracy: Democratic Participation In The Economy
This article critically reviews and integrates the social science literature on "alternatives to bureaucracy," focusing particularly on democratic participation in the economy. First, it looks at the…
Creating a Just and Democratic Workplace: More Engagement, Less Hierarchy
JOYCE ROTHSCHILD Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University sons to support my deontological universalist position. At the same time, there are in addition important cultural differences in…
MEASURING THE GRASSROOTS: Puzzles of Cultivating the Grassroots from the Top Down
TLDR
In the U.S. youth civic engagement projects described here, the practice of accounting itself had an effect, regardless of funders' goals, and knowledge of it became a repressed institutional intuition.
...
...