• DOI:10.1017/S0020589300064423
• Corpus ID: 146580752

What is the Function of the Conseil D'etat in the Preparation of Legislation?

@article{Bell2000WhatIT,
  title={What is the Function of the Conseil D'etat in the Preparation of Legislation?},
  author={John F. Bell},
  journal={International and Comparative Law Quarterly},
  year={2000},
  volume={49},
  pages={661 - 672}
}

• J. Bell
• Published 1 July 2000
• Political Science
• International and Comparative Law Quarterly

Consideration of the Conseil d'Etat and its role in the preparation of legislation helps us in Britain to appreciate how our own legislative process might be improved. The Hansard Society Report1 suggested in 1992 that Britain needed to look beyond just improving the drafting of legislation and needed to reform the legislative process, both before a bill is presented to Parliament and in its passage through Parliament. My reflection on the French process is to suggest that this offers us a further focus of attention—the questions which should be asked during the scrutiny process. There are two areas where we need to ask questions—on fundamental rights and practical effectiveness. I think that the British trust too much to the political process to ensure that questions concerning respect for fundamental values and also administrative workability are addressed before a bill is passed by Parliament. This paper is influenced by observations made in 1986 of the Interior Section of the Conseil d'Etat in its scrutiny of a number of government bills at the beginning of the Chirac premiership.