What is science? Does it matter to distinguish it from pseudoscience? A reply to my commentators

@article{Bunge1991WhatIS,
  title={What is science? Does it matter to distinguish it from pseudoscience? A reply to my commentators},
  author={Mario Bunge},
  journal={New Ideas in Psychology},
  year={1991},
  volume={9},
  pages={245-283}
}
  • M. Bunge
  • Published 1991
  • Education, Physics
  • New Ideas in Psychology

Identifying Pseudoscience: A Social Process Criterion

Many philosophers have come to believe there is no single criterion by which one can distinguish between a science and a pseudoscience. But it need not follow that no distinction can be made: a

Identifying Pseudoscience: A Social Process Criterion

  • G. Dawes
  • Philosophy, Education
    Journal for General Philosophy of Science
  • 2018
Many philosophers have come to believe there is no single criterion by which one can distinguish between a science and a pseudoscience. But it need not follow that no distinction can be made: a

Understanding Replication in a Way That Is True to Science

  • B. Haig
  • Biology
    Review of General Psychology
  • 2020
It is maintained that viewing replication as just one element of the wide array of scientific endeavors leads to the conclusion that it is not as prominent in science as is often claimed.

On the Qualities of Science

We hear much of voodoo science or junk science or even scientific science, in this paper I seek to evaluate and understand how we might approach a description of the qualities of science. In this I

Controversy as a Blind Spot in Teaching Nature of Science

In this article, the argument is put forth that controversies about the scope and limits of science should be considered in Nature of Science (NOS) teaching. Reference disciplines for teaching NOS

Controversy as a Blind Spot in Teaching Nature of Science

In this article, the argument is put forth that controversies about the scope and limits of science should be considered in Nature of Science (NOS) teaching. Reference disciplines for teaching NOS

Realism and antirealism in social science

Up until recently social scientists took it for granted that their task was to account for the social world as objectively as possible: they were realists in practice if not always in their

Philosophy of Science and Technology: A Personal Report

This work in the general philosophy and methodology of science and technology, as well as in the philosophy of some of their various branches, is shown to be components of a new philosophical system hoped to be in harmony with contemporaryScience and technology and moreover one capable of stimulating their advancement.

Feng Shui as Pseudoscience

  • M. R. Matthews
  • Education
    Feng Shui: Teaching About Science and Pseudoscience
  • 2019
Given the extent of feng shui belief, and the personal, social, cultural, and economic impact that it has, everyone can benefit from judging its scientificity. Efforts to distinguish science from

From text to self : the interplay of criticism and response in the history of parapsychology

The thesis examines the history of criticism and response in scientific parapsychology by bringing together the tools of history, rhetoric of science, and discursive psychology to examine texts

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 101 REFERENCES

A Critical Examination of the New Sociology of Science Part 2

If there is no independent reality, if the entire world is a social construction, and if facts are statements of a certain kind, it stands to reason that there is no objective truth. In other words,

Seven Desiderata for Rationality

Many of us take pride in being rational animals, but only philosophers have attempted to find out what rationality is (or what “rationality” means). However, for better or for worse they have not

Emergence and the mind

Science and Supernature: A Critical Appraisal of Parapsychology

Is there more to our existence than modern science can measure? For more than a hundred years, parapsychology - the scientific study of paranormal phenomena - has tried to find the answer to this

Causality—The Place of the Causal Principle in Modern Science

By Mario Bunge Massachusetts : Harvard University Press, London ; Oxford University Press. Pp. xx + 380. Price 60s. The thesis of this book is that causality is one of several forms of determinism.

Is Scientific Metaphysics Possible

Metaphysics is back and doing rather well considering that it was pronounced defunct several times over the past two centuries. It comes in three different species: plain, exact, and scientific.

Thirteen Critical Points in Contemporary Economic Theory: An Interpretation

I am grateful for comments received from William Brock, M. D. Godfrey, K. P. Heiss, J. Laderman, E. Marchi, C. F. Morgenstern, A. Schotter, G. Schwodiauer, G. L. Thompson, and Kan Young. Special

Hermeneutics and Economics: A Criticism of Hermeneutical Thinking in the Social Sciences

Some representatives of Misesian economics in the United States try to develop neo-Austrian views by using hermeneutical insights. They neglect the important difference between the views of Max Weber

Philosophy of Psychology

This book is about some topical philosophical and methodological prob lems that arise in the study of behavior and mind, as well as in the treatment of behavioral and mental disorders. It deals with

STRIFE ABOUT COMPLEMENTARITY (I)*

  • M. Bunge
  • Physics
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 1955
UNTIL a few years ago only a few physicists questioned the usual interpretation of quantum theory. Their criticisms were doubtless useful, but remained mainly on the philosophical level; no
...