What is Originalism? The Evolution of Contemporary Originalist Theory

  title={What is Originalism? The Evolution of Contemporary Originalist Theory},
  author={Lawrence B. Solum},
Debates over “originalism” have been a central focus of contemporary constitutional theory for three decades. One of the features of this debate has been disagreement about what “originalism” is. More worrisome is the possibility that the arguments between contemporary originalists and their opponents, the “living constitutionalists”, are confused – with each side of the debate making erroneous assumptions about the content of their opponent’s theories.The aim of this chapter is to clarify… 
Why Constitutional Meaning is not Necessarily Fixed - A Reply to Solum
Abstract : In this paper, I show that certain parts of constitutional texts can plausibly be thought of as having a meaning that changes and evolves on its own. This idea is widely rejected,
Beyond Politics and Natural Law: The Anticipation of New Originalist Tenets in the Constitutional Thought of Frederick Douglass
Scholarship on Frederick Douglass has focused on his natural law and natural rights philosophy and on his statesmanship in breaking with Garrisonian abolitionists over the question of whether slavery
Interpretative theories as roadmaps to constitutional identity: The case of the United States
Abstract As long as the American Constitution serves as the focal point of American identity, many constitutional interpretative theories also serve as roadmaps to various visions of American
A Description of Originalism
The history of American constitutional interpretation has largely been an originalist one. At the Founding, the Framers and Ratifiers employed originalism when debating, drafting, and authorizing the
A Theory That Beats the Theory? Lineages, the Growth of Signs, and Dynamic Legal Interpretation
Legal philosophers distinguish between a static and a dynamic interpretation of law. The former assumes that the meaning of the words used in a legal text is set at the moment of its enactment and
Originalism and the Treaty of Waitangi
Originalism has long been used as a conceptual approach for interpreting the United States Constitution. Its premise is that the authoritative interpretation of constitutional documents is best
Common Law Constitutionalism and the Written Constitution
This paper is a contribution to the development of a common-law approach to constitutional interpretation. It provides an answer to the objection that drawing on common-law principles in the
Originalism Without Text
Originalism is not about the text. Though the theory is often treated as a way to read the Constitution's words, that conventional view is misleading. A society can be recognizably originalist
Justices as “Sacred Symbols”: Antonin Scalia and the Cultural Life of the Law
Abstract Perhaps no single judge in recent years has embodied the intricacies and difficulties of the cultural life of the law as much as American Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia. While common
The Arendtian Dread: Courts with Power
Hannah Arendt was fearful not only of a populist President speaking in the name of the people and unbound by legality. She was also concerned that the popular will could be harnessed to support those


Incorporation and Originalist Theory
Does the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution incorporate the Bill of Rights contained in the first eight amendments? And how should an originalist answer that question? This paper
The Meaning of Original Meaning
The view (most prominently advocated by Justice Scalia) that original meaning entails the constitutionality of original practices has strong intuitive appeal. Indeed, as indicated above, it is a
Spontaneous abortion is the loss of the infant naturally or accidentally, without the will of the mother, more commonly referred to as miscarriage.
The Supreme Court's Gun Showdown
  • Wall Street Journal
Alive and Kicking: Why No One Truly Believes in a Dead Constitution
  • Clarence Thomas's Originalism
3059 (Opinon of Thomas
  • J., concurring)
, “ The Constitution of the United States : Contemporary Ratification ” , 27 S
  • Tex . L . Rev .
  • 1986
Original Meaning