What are critical features of science curriculum materials that impact student and teacher outcomes

  title={What are critical features of science curriculum materials that impact student and teacher outcomes},
  author={Natalie Pareja Roblin and Christian D. Schunn and Susan McKenney},
  journal={Science Education},
Large investments are made in curriculum materials with the goal of supporting science education reform. However, relatively little evidence is available about what features of curriculum materials really matter to impact student and teacher learning. To address this need, the current study examined curriculum features associated with student and teacher outcomes. We reviewed sample curriculum materials and documentation reporting on the instructional outcomes of 51 research-based K–12 science… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Curriculum materials are important resources for teachers to design and conduct teaching activities, which usually include textbooks, teacher’s guides, teaching videos, exercise books, and other
Connecting the Dots from Professional Development to Student Learning
Of the two distinct curricular implementation strategies, enacting a full unit produced significantly greater student learning than integrating neuroscience activities into existing biology units, and participation in neuroscience PD predicted improved student learning compared with control teachers.
Designing educative curriculum materials in interdisciplinary teams: designer processes and contributions
Educative curricula support teacher learning as well as the learning of students. High quality educative curricula contain features that help teachers customize learning opportunities and
Consequences of curricular adaptation strategies for implementation at scale
Examination of how developers designed two primary science curricula to support teacher adaptation and enable use of innovative materials at scale examines how these design stances informed materials developed to support teachers' content knowledge.
Work-Based Curriculum to Broaden Learners’ Participation in Science: Insights for Designers
Around the globe, science education during compulsory schooling is envisioned for all learners regardless of their educational and career aspirations, including learners bound to the workforce upon
Evaluating Digital Instructional Materials for K-12 Online and Blended Learning
The 4A Framework for evaluating online instructional materials is shared, organized around the premise that qualityOnline instructional materials are accessible, promote active engagement, advocate for inclusion, and are accountable for their relationships to standards and data privacy.
Exploring shifts in the characteristics of US government-funded science curriculum materials and their (unintended) consequences
Abstract Grant-funded curriculum development efforts can substantially impact practice and research in science education. Therefore, understanding the sometimes-unintended consequences of changes in
Collaborative Curriculum Design in Teacher Teams: Foundations
This chapter serves as an introduction to the book. History shows that the intentions and ambitions of many curriculum innovations failed because the complexity of the design and implementation
Examining the Representations of NOS in Educational Resources
Researchers have raised concerns about teachers’ ability to embed nature of science (NOS) in their science instruction, a complicated situation that is certainly impacted by the availability of
Teacher Video Coaching, From Design Features to Student Impacts: A Systematic Literature Review
Video and coaching as vehicles for teachers’ professional development have both received much attention in educational research. The combination of the two, video coaching, where teachers watch and


Investigating Teacher Learning Supports in High School Biology Curricular Programs to Inform the Design of Educative Curriculum Materials
Reform efforts have emphasized the need to support teachers' learning about reform-oriented practices. Educative curriculum materials are one potential vehicle for promoting teacher learning about
Teachers’ use of educative curriculum materials to engage students in science practices
ABSTRACT New reform documents underscore the importance of integrating science practices into the learning of science. This integration requires sophisticated teaching that does not often happen.
Examining student work for evidence of teacher uptake of educative curriculum materials
The purpose of this study was to identify evidence in student work of teachers' uptake of educative features in educative curriculum materials. These are features in curriculum materials designed
Supporting Science Teacher Learning: The Role of Educative Curriculum Materials
Science education is the focus of many reform efforts. Specifically, reformers are suggesting teachers utilized inquiry based, student centered instructional practices that will facilitate students’
An exploration of teacher learning from an educative reform‐oriented science curriculum: Case studies of teacher curriculum use
Educative curriculum materials provide teachers with authentic opportunities to learn new skills and practices. Yet, research shows teachers use curriculum in different ways for different reasons,
Examining the effect of teachers' adaptations of a middle school science inquiry-oriented curriculum unit on student learning
Reform based curriculum offer a promising avenue to support greater student achievement in science. Yet teachers frequently adapt innovative curriculum when they use them in their own classrooms. In
Opportunities for Teacher Learning During Enactment of Inquiry Science Curriculum Materials: Exploring the Potential for Teacher Educative Materials
The development of curriculum materials that are also educative for teachers has been proposed as a strategy to support teachers learning to teach inquiry science. In this study, one seventh-grade
The Benefits and Limitations of Educative Curriculum Materials
Educational researchers have argued that curriculum materials have the potential to promote teacher learning when intentionally designed to do so. Such materials have been referred to as ECMs (Ball &
Designing Educative Curriculum Materials to Promote Teacher Learning
Curriculum materials for Grades K–12 that are intended to promote teacher learning in addition to student learning have come to be called educative curriculum materials. How can K–12 curriculum