What Makes Some People Think Astrology Is Scientific?

@article{Allum2011WhatMS,
  title={What Makes Some People Think Astrology Is Scientific?},
  author={Nick Allum},
  journal={Science Communication},
  year={2011},
  volume={33},
  pages={341 - 366}
}
  • N. Allum
  • Published 1 September 2011
  • Physics
  • Science Communication
Citizens in both North America and Europe are apt to read horoscope columns in newspapers and magazines. While some people read these casually and purely for entertainment, some believe that astrology has scientific status and can provide real insight into events and personality. Using data from a European survey, this article explores some of the reasons why some people think that astrology is scientific and how astrology is viewed in relation to other knowledge-producing practices. Three… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

AS PREDICTED
This study examines a recent eruption of news about astrology. For a theoretical lens, it uses contemporary research on how traditional news values might allow what some have labeled “mystical” ideas
A Secondary Tool for Demarcation Problem: Logical Fallacies
According to Thagard, the behavior of practitioners of a field may also be used for demarcation between science and pseudoscience due to its social dimension in addition to the epistemic one. I
Fixating on the future: An overview of increased astrology use
Background: Interest in astrology has surged recently, possibly due to the uncertain conditions in the world due to the Covid-19 pandemic. While belief in astrology is common and socially legitimized
The Trappings of Science
This study examines the influence of media messages about paranormal investigators on perceptions of how scientific and credible such investigators are, as well as on beliefs about paranormal
Education and support for scientists and elected officials in public policy decisions
This paper uses survey data from the United States to examine the relationship between education and public support for scientific experts and elected leaders in knowledge-intensive policy decisions.
The validity of astrological predictions on marriage and divorce: a longitudinal analysis of Swedish register data
This paper examines astrology, a concept that is considered unscientific by broad segments of the population in the western world. Despite this, astrology remains for some an important source for
Redefining Rationality: Paranormal Investigators' Humour in England
ABSTRACT In contemporary England, amateur paranormal investigators are actively engaged in attempts to produce objective knowledge about the ghostly and paranormal. Their project requires them to
Preservice Science Teachers' Discrimination Level of Science and Pseudoscience
This quantitative study aimed to examine Turkish pre-service science teachers’ beliefs regarding the demarcating between science and pseudoscience. Participants completed the Science and
Communicating astronomy with the public: perspectives of an international community of practice
Communities of practice in science communication can make important contributions to public engagement with science but are under-researched. In this article, we look at the perspectives of a
The growth and development analytical controversies in economic science: A reassessment for the post-Covid-19 era
Abstract. A repositioning of the theoretical instruments of development and growth in the context of economics and political economy that we have at our disposal to date seems necessary, especially
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 60 REFERENCES
The Fault is not in the Stars
Skeptics' and astrology believers acceptance of generalized personality descriptions of the self was explored. Descriptions were varied in two ways: (a) They were attributed to astrology or were said
Prophecy and Power: Astrology in Early Modern England
Part 1 Introduction: this book astrology in historical context astrological theory and terminology. Part 2 From heyday to crisis - 1642-1710: astrology in the interregnum - halcyon days, William
Popular Occultism and Critical Social Theory: Exploring Some Themes in Adorno's Critique of Astrology and the Occult
In recent years, the purveyors of the popular occult have flooded the marketplace with a plethora of books, magazines, movies, games and similar commodities, perhaps the most common of which is the
Public Understanding of, and Attitudes toward, Scientific Research: What We Know and What We Need to Know
Over the last four decades, a substantial body of national survey material has been collected in the US concerning the public understanding of science and technology. Using this body of research,
The Stars Down to Earth: The Los Angeles Times Astrology Column
The group of studies to which the content analysis of the Los Angeles Times astrology column belongs, sets as its aim the investigation of the nature and motivations of some large-scale social
Science knowledge and attitudes across cultures: a meta-analysis
The correlation between knowledge and attitudes has been the source of controversy in research on the public understanding of science (PUS). Although many studies, both quantitative and qualitative,
Science Versus the Stars: A Double-Blind Test of the Validity of the NEO Five-Factor Inventory and Computer-Generated Astrological Natal Charts
TLDR
The authors asked 52 college students to identify their personality summaries by using a computer-generated astrological natal chart when presented with 1 true summary and 1 bogus one, and observed a P. T. Barnum effect in the accuracy ratings of both psychological andAstrological measures.
Enforcing Social Conformity: A Theory of Authoritarianism
Fifty years after the publication of The Authoritarian Personality, the empirical literature on authoritarianism continues to grow even though there is no widely accepted theory to account for the
The measurement of civic scientific literacy
Building on two decades of national surveys in the United States and two Eurobarometer studies, the history, rationale, and structure of a measure of civic scientific literacy are described.
Motivation, cognition and pseudoscience.
  • M. Lindeman
  • Psychology
    Scandinavian journal of psychology
  • 1998
TLDR
A framework that views pseudoscientific beliefs as a joint function of the basic social motives and the default way of processing everyday information is proposed.
...
...