What Makes Characters’ Bad Behaviors Acceptable? The Effects of Character Motivation and Outcome on Perceptions, Character Liking, and Moral Disengagement

  title={What Makes Characters’ Bad Behaviors Acceptable? The Effects of Character Motivation and Outcome on Perceptions, Character Liking, and Moral Disengagement},
  author={K. Maja Krakowiak and Mina Tsay-Vogel},
  journal={Mass Communication and Society},
  pages={179 - 199}
Many characters in entertainment content behave in morally questionable ways at least some of the time. However, the negative effects of those behaviors on individuals’ judgments of the character may be diminished in some instances. This study examined the effects of character motivation and outcome in a written narrative on character perceptions and moral disengagement. The findings of a 2 (motivation: altruistic, selfish) × 2 (outcome: positive, negative) experiment (N = 123) revealed that… 
Are Good Characters Better for Us? The Effect of Morality Salience on Entertainment Selection and Recovery Outcomes
Two experiments examined whether one’s moral self-perception affects the selection of content (Study 1) and whether exposure to different character types results in any recovery benefits (Study 2).
Morality Predicts Enjoyment But Not Appreciation of Morally Ambiguous Characters
Understanding the role of morally ambiguous characters such as anti-heroes in entertainment experiences has become a central concern for media researchers. Some have argued that different character
The Dual Role of Morally Ambiguous Characters: Examining the Effect of Morality Salience on Narrative Responses
Using social comparison theory as a framework, 2 experiments examined the effects of a person's self-perception on responses to characters who display varying levels of morality. Study 1 found that
Beyond Heroes and Villains: Examining Explanatory Mechanisms Underlying Moral Disengagement
In recent years, theorizing regarding the role and importance of media entertainment in everyday life has garnered much serious attention by media effects scholars. The role of moral judgments,
Character morality, enjoyment, and appreciation: A replication of Eden, Daalmans, and Johnson (2017)
Character morality, enjoyment, and appreciation: A replication of Eden, Daalmans, and Johnson (2017) Koji Yoshimura Much research on media entertainment seeks to explain why viewers enjoy and
Perceptions of Moral Violations and Personality Traits Among Heroes and Villains
This study investigates disposition-formation processes in entertainment by predicting perceptions of media heroes and villains by their behavior in specific moral domains. Participants rated
Sensing Heroes and Villains: Character-Schema and the Disposition Formation Process
A schema-based theoretical expansion of Zillmann’s model, wherein moral judgments of characters and disposition formation—facilitated by the activation of character-schema (e.g., hero/villain)—might occur prior to the observation of behavior.
The virtues and vices of social comparisons: examining assimilative and contrastive emotional reactions to characters in a narrative
Based on social comparison theory, this study investigates how awareness of one’s morality and exposure to a character in a narrative affect emotions associated with four types of social
Affective Disposition Theory
Affective disposition theory refers to a set of explanations for why and how an audience member enjoys various media entertainment narratives. In simple terms, the theory predicts that enjoyment


The role of moral disengagement in the enjoyment of real and fictional characters
Findings indicate that character liking mediates the relationship betweenmoral disengagement and enjoyment and that moral disengagement is unaffected by the realness or fictionality of the narrative.
The impact of perceived character similarity and identification on moral disengagement
It is suggested that perceived similarity between the viewer and character mediates the relationship between identification and moral disengagement, which in turn leads to greater affective enjoyment of a narrative.
When Good Characters Do Bad Things: Examining the Effect of Moral Ambiguity on Enjoyment
Some of the most compelling characters are morally ambiguous, but little research has examined these characters. This study (N = 313) empirically tests the effects of good, bad, and morally ambiguous
Punishing Media Criminals and Moral Judgment: The Impact on Enjoyment
In this study, I investigated the relation between moral judgment and the enjoyment of crime dramas by varying the relative severity of punishment levied for a crime. One hundred fifty-one
It’s okay to shoot a character: Moral disengagement in violent video games
What makes virtual violence enjoyable rather than aversive? Two 2×2 experiments tested the assumption that moral disengagement cues provided by a violent video game’s narrative and game play lessen
Convergent and Divergent Social Cues
A study was conducted to assess the impact of consistently negative cues versus mixed negative and positive cues about a televised aggressor's motives and the consequences to him on children's
Children's use of motives and intentionality in person perception and moral judgment.
Preschool, second-, and fifth-grade children watched films and heard stories which portrayed an actor who intentionally or accidentally injured another for either good or bad motives. After each film
Moral Judgment as a Predictor of Enjoyment of Crime Drama
The goal of the study is to better understand the relationship between factors involved in moral judgment of entertainment and the enjoyment of crime drama. After completing numerous social-justice
Selective Moral Disengagement in the Exercise of Moral Agency
Moral agency has dual aspects manifested in both the power to refrain from behaving inhumanely and the proactive power to behave humanely. Moral agency is embedded in a broader socio-cognitive
Observational learning of motives and consequences for television aggression: a developmental study.
There was evidence for age-related improvement in the ability to infer connections between the actor's immediate and his superordinate goals and forage-related changes in knowledge of motives and motive-based evaluations.