What Becomes of a Causal Set?

@article{Wthrich2015WhatBO,
  title={What Becomes of a Causal Set?},
  author={Christian W{\"u}thrich and Craig Callender},
  journal={The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science},
  year={2015},
  volume={68},
  pages={907 - 925}
}
Unlike the relativity theory it seeks to replace, causal set theory (CST) has been interpreted to leave space for a substantive, though perhaps ‘localized’, form of ‘becoming’. The possibility of fundamental becoming is nourished by the fact that the analogue of Stein’s theorem from special relativity does not hold in CST. Despite this, we find that in many ways, the debate concerning becoming parallels the well-rehearsed lines it follows in the domain of relativity. We present, however, some… 

Spacetime from causality : causal set theory

Causal set theory attempts to formulate a quantum theory of gravity by assuming that the fundamental structure is a discrete set of basal events partially ordered by causality. In other words, it

On the Modal Aspects of Causal Sets

  • T. Placek
  • Philosophy
    Foundations of Physics
  • 2019
This paper interpret causal sets as multi-realisable objects, like states, which is undermined by an argument for the probabilistic constraint of general covariance, as it says that multiple paths along which a causal set is produced are not physically different.

On the Modal Aspects of Causal Sets

  • T. Placek
  • Philosophy
    Foundations of Physics
  • 2019
The possibility question concerns the status of possibilities: do they form an irreducible category of the external reality, or are they merely features of our cognitive framework? If fundamental

Spacetime as a causal set: Universe as a growing block?

The causal set programme towards a quantum theory of gravity is situated vis-à-vis the long-standing debate between eternalism (block theory) and past-presentism or possibilism (growing block theory)

A precipice below which lies absurdity? Theories without a spacetime and scientific understanding

While the relation between visualization and scientific understanding has been a topic of long-standing discussion, recent developments in physics have pushed the boundaries of this debate to new and

A precipice below which lies absurdity? Theories without a spacetime and scientific understanding

The contextual theory of scientific understanding is adapted to fit the novel challenges posed by physical theories without spacetime and it is argued that such physical theories can provide scientific understanding, and that such understanding does not require spacetimes of any sort.

If time had no beginning

General Relativity traces the evolution of our Universe back to a Big Bang singularity. To probe physics before the singularity—if indeed there is a “before”—we must turn to quantum gravity. The

The Inaccessibility of the Past is Not Statistical

It is an inescapable reality of the human condition that, no matter how hard we try, we cannot change the past. But in most discussions of this subject in the philosophy of physics, the

Symmetric and asymmetric theories of time

There is a feeling of dissatisfaction with the traditional way of defining the A-theories of time. One reason is that these definitions rest on an ontological question—‘Do the future and the past

When the Actual World Is Not Even Possible

  • C. Wuthrich
  • Philosophy, Art
    The Foundation of Reality
  • 2020
Approaches to quantum gravity often involve the disappearance of space and time at the fundamental level. The metaphysical consequences of this disappearance are profound, as is illustrated with

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 32 REFERENCES

The definability of objective becoming in Minkowski spacetime

It is shown that Stein's uniqueness proof can be extended in a natural way to cover this more general kind of becoming, provided one does not enrich standard Minkowski spacetime by privileging certain sets of worldlines over others in an unwarranted manner.

Spacetime as a causal set: Universe as a growing block?

The causal set programme towards a quantum theory of gravity is situated vis-à-vis the long-standing debate between eternalism (block theory) and past-presentism or possibilism (growing block theory)

Reassessing the Prospects for a Growing Block Model of the Universe

Although C. D. Broad’s notion of Becoming has received a fair amount of attention in the philosophy‐of‐time literature, there are no serious attempts to show how to replace the standard ‘block’

The birth of spacetime atoms as the passage of time

  • Fay Dowker
  • Philosophy
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
  • 2014
It is suggested that the reason there is no consensus on whether the passage of time is physical is that the current best theory of spacetime, general relativity, lacks the concept of passage, which means that the sense‐experience of passage cannot be properly expressed.

XVI—Relativity, the Open Future, and the Passage of Time

Is the objective passage of time compatible with relativistic physics? There are two easy routes to an affirmative answer: (1) provide a deflationary analysis of passage compatible with the block

Shedding Light on Time

Throughout this century many philosophers and physicists have gone for the 'big kill' regarding tenses. They have tried to show via McTaggart's paradox and special relativity that tenses are

The fate of presentism in modern physics

There has been a recent spate of essays defending presentism, the view in the metaphysics of time according to which all and only present events or entities exist. What is particularly striking about

On Relativity Theory and Openness of the Future

  • H. Stein
  • Philosophy
    Philosophy of Science
  • 1991
It has been repeatedly argued, most recently by Nicholas Maxwell, that the special theory of relativity is incompatible with the view that the future is in some degree undetermined; and Maxwell

Stochastic Einstein Locality Revisited

  • J. Butterfield
  • Physics
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 2007
I discuss various formulations of stochastic Einstein locality (SEL), which is a version of the idea of relativistic causality, that is, the idea that influences propagate at most as fast as light.

Classical sequential growth dynamics for causal sets

Starting from certain causality conditions and a discrete form of general covariance, we derive a very general family of classically stochastic, sequential growth dynamics for causal sets. The