What's Gender Got to Do with It? A Critique of RDA 9.7

  title={What's Gender Got to Do with It? A Critique of RDA 9.7},
  author={Amber M. Billey and Emily Drabinski and K. R. Roberto},
  journal={Cataloging \& Classification Quarterly},
  pages={412 - 421}
The Library of Congress (LC) and the Program for Cooperative Cataloging (PCC) interpretation of Resource Description and Access (RDA) 9.7 regarding gender when identifying persons reinforces regressive conceptions of gender identity. The rule instructs catalogers to record gender when identifying persons, and although RDA gives catalogers the flexibility to record more than two gender labels, LC limits Name Authority Cooperative Program (NACO) catalogers to a binary label: male, female, or not… 

Topics from this paper

More Than a Name: A Content Analysis of Name Authority Records for Authors Who Self-Identify as Trans
This analysis examined the 375 field for “gender,” the contents of that field, and other representations of (trans)gender identities throughout the record to ensure that an author’s agency to self-disclose their identities is respected.
Comparing the Cataloguing of Indigenous Scholarships: First Steps and Findings
This paper provides an analysis of data collected on the continued prevalence of outdated, marginalizing terms in contemporary cataloguing practices, stemming from the Library of Congress Subject
Records, Responsibility, and Power: An Overview of Cataloging Ethics
Abstract Ethics are principles which provide a framework for making decisions that best reflect a set of values. Cataloging carries power, so ethical decision-making is crucial. Because cataloging
Conceptualizing a Future for Library Classification
This paper traces the roots of the positivist epistemology of librarianship; its ideals of neutrality and access as they intersect in the classification and assignment of library subject headings;
The Critical Catalog: Library Information Systems, Tricksterism, and Social Justice
In this paper, we describe the Critical Catalog, a grant-funded research through design project intended to investigate metadata elements, values, and organizational structures necessary to
Applying Library of Congress Demographic Group Characteristics for Creators
Abstract This research project explores how to ethically, efficiently, and accurately add demographic terms for African American authors to catalog records. A Department of History graduate student
Engaging an Author in a Critical Reading of Subject Headings
Most practitioners of critical librarianship agree that subject description is both valuable and political. Subject headings can either reinforce or subvert hierarchies of social domination. Outside
Universalism : Conventional Values in Descriptive Catalog Codes
Every standard embodies a particular set of values. Some aspects are privileged while others are masked. Values embedded within knowledge organization standards have special import in that they are
Canadian Librarianship and the Politics of Recognition
Résumé Recent controversies in Canadian librarianship—the Toronto Public Library room rental to a “gender-critical feminist” group and the institution of “airport-style” security at the Winnipeg
Markup as Behavior toward Risk: Reforming the Metanarratives of Metadata through Susan Howe's Metafictive Poetics
Abstract:This essay explores the politics, poetics, and ethics of metadata in response to two frequent critiques of the digital humanities: the incompatibility between humanistic and computational


Inflexible Bodies: Metadata for Transgender Identities *
[T]he power relations that characterize any historically embedded society are never as transparently clear as the names we give to them imply.- Gordon, 1997, p. 3While librarians are strongly
Queering the Catalog: Queer Theory and the Politics of Correction
Critiques of hegemonic library classification structures and controlled vocabularies have a rich history in information studies. This project has pointed out the trouble with classification and
Minoritization vs. Universalization: Lesbianism and Male Homosexuality in LCSH and LCC
This article returns to Greenblatt’s LCSH study to see what progress has been made in the last two decades, then uses her study as a template to examine gayand lesbian-related terminology in LCC.
Queer theory and the creation of contextual subject access tools for gay and lesbian communities
Knowledge organization research has come to question the theoretical distinction between aboutness (a document's innate content) and meaning (the use to which a document is put). This distinction has
Prototype theory: An alternative concept theory for categorizing sex and gender?
Classical theories of classification and concepts, originating in ancient Greek logic, have been criticized by classificationists, feminists, and scholars of marginalized groups because of the
Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity
Preface (1999) Preface (1990) 1. Subjects of Sex/Gender/Desire I. 'Women' as the Subject of Feminism II. The Compulsory Order of Sex/Gender/Desire III. Gender: The Circular Ruins of Contemporary
Imagining Transgender: An Ethnography of a Category
Imagining Transgender is an ethnography of the emergence and institutionalization of transgender as a category of collective identity and political activism. Embraced by activists in the early 1990s
Tabulating Queer: Space, Perversion, and Belonging
Considering fields as diverse as the history of science, Internet studies, border studies, and coalition politics, the article gives an historical overview of how the knowledge around queer phe-
The International Standard Name Identifier (ISNI): The Evolving Future of Name Authority Control
The project to build the initial ISNI database by deploying the techniques used to develop the Virtual International Authority File is described, focusing particularly on the work of the OCLC team in transforming the VIAF “resource file” model of matched data into a robust, operational, and authoritative file of uniquely assigned ISNIs.
Evolving Landscape in Name Authority Control
A conceptual framework for library name authority control is presented, including methods for disambiguating agents that share the same name and for collocating works of agents who use multiple names.