Weismann Rules! OK? Epigenetics and the Lamarckian temptation

@article{Haig2007WeismannRO,
  title={Weismann Rules! OK? Epigenetics and the Lamarckian temptation},
  author={David Haig},
  journal={Biology \& Philosophy},
  year={2007},
  volume={22},
  pages={415-428}
}
  • D. Haig
  • Published 7 May 2007
  • Biology
  • Biology & Philosophy
August Weismann rejected the inheritance of acquired characters on the grounds that changes to the soma cannot produce the kind of changes to the germ-plasm that would result in the altered character being transmitted to subsequent generations. His intended distinction, between germ-plasm and soma, was closer to the modern distinction between genotype and phenotype than to the modern distinction between germ cells and somatic cells. Recently, systems of epigenetic inheritance have been claimed… 
Lamarckism and epigenetic inheritance: a clarification
TLDR
It is argued that two types of arguments allow to draw a clear distinction between the genuine Lamarckian concept of inheritance of acquired characters and transgenerational epigenetic inheritance and that given current knowledge, epigenetic mechanisms are not able to drive adaptive evolution by themselves.
Soma-to-germline RNA communication.
TLDR
Here, motivated by the centrality of small RNAs in paradigms of epigenetic inheritance, the myriad examples of intercellular RNA trafficking from nurse cells or somatic tissues to developing gametes are reviewed.
Historical perspective of transgenerational epigenetics
  • D. Ho
  • Biology
    Transgenerational Epigenetics
  • 2019
An introduction to epigenetics as the link between genotype and environment: a personal view.
TLDR
Epigenetics, or the study of heritable changes in gene activity that are not brought about by changes in the DNA sequence, can explain some types of ill health in offspring, which have been exposed to stressors during early development, when DNA is most susceptible to such epigenetic influences.
Epigenetics: from the past to the present
TLDR
The epigenome, as the bridge between the genome and the phenotype, is one of the most interesting current ideas in genetics and is so revolutionary that it may change present notions about inheritance and evolution.
Epigenetic inheritance and evolution: a historian's perspective
  • Laurent Loison
  • Biology
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B
  • 2021
TLDR
The view that epigenetic inheritance could be seen as vindicating a revival of (neo)Lamarckism is assessed and several differences between modern epigenetics and what Lamarckism was in the history of science are identified.
A Unified Approach to the Evolutionary Consequences of Genetic and Nongenetic Inheritance
TLDR
A unified theoretical framework based on the Price equation is proposed that can be used to model evolution under an expanded inheritance concept that combines the effects of genetic and nongenetic inheritance and can be applied to a variety of scenarios.
[Pangenesis, genes, epigenesis].
TLDR
The conclusion is that the theory of pangenesis was well-suited to its time, and additionally, reflections of this assumption can be found in work in new areas known as evolutionary biology of development (evo-devo) and epigenetics.
Epigenetic inheritance: a contributor to species differentiation?
TLDR
The possibility that epigenetic inheritance is responsible for some stable characteristics of species is discussed, focusing on a recent comparison of the human and chimpanzee methylomes which reveals that somaticmethylation states are related to methylation states in the germline.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 43 REFERENCES
Epigenetics and the renaissance of heresy.
TLDR
Evidence is accumulating that stably heritable phenotypes can also have an epigenetic basis, lending support to the long-discarded notion of inheritance of acquired traits.
Epigenetic Inheritance and Evolution: The Lamarckian Dimension
TLDR
This paperback edition of this controversial book contains a new Preface that sets out the major changes in the scientific world and in the authors' own thinking that have occurred since the book was published.
EPIGENETIC CONTROL SYSTEMS.
  • D. L. Nanney
  • Biology
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
  • 1958
TLDR
To simplify the discussion of these two types of systems, they will be referred to as "genetic systems" and "epigenetic systems.," to emphasize the reliance of these systems on the genetic systems and to underscore their significance in developmental processes.
An epigenetic mutation responsible for natural variation in floral symmetry
TLDR
It is shown that a naturally occurring mutant of Linaria vulgaris carries a defect in Lcyc, a homologue of the cycloidea gene which controls dorsoventral asymmetry in Antirrhinum, indicating that epigenetic mutations may play a more significant role in evolution than has hitherto been suspected.
Darwin's dangerous idea.
  • J. Launer
  • Education
    QJM : monthly journal of the Association of Physicians
  • 2002
TLDR
Most educated people nowadays know that the authors share over 98% of their DNA with chimpanzees, but many humans may experience a frisson on learning this fact, which gives some sense of the existential horror that Darwin's contemporaries had to deal with.
Age-associated activation of epigenetically repressed genes in the mouse.
TLDR
The hypothesis that epigenetic loss of gene repression occurs in normal tissues and may be a contributing factor in progressive physiological dysfunction seen during mammalian aging is supported.
Lamarckism versus Darwinism
WITH reference to the recent revival of what may be considered as “pure” Lamarckism, it appears to me of importance that those who have followed the course of biological work and thought in this
DNA methylation, imprinting and cancer
TLDR
Developing therapeutics based on restoring the normal methylation state to cancer-associated genes will require identifying loci undergoing methylation changes in cancer, understanding how their methylation influences tumorigenesis and identifying the mechanisms regulating the methylationState of the genome.
The Mutation Theory Experiments and Observations on the Origin of Species in the Vegetable Kingdom
TLDR
The publication of a translation of Hugo de Vries' larger “Die Muta-tionstheorie” will be valuable to students as containing the detailed arguments upon which it is based.
Epigenetic programming of differential gene expression in development and evolution.
  • M. Monk
  • Biology
    Developmental genetics
  • 1995
TLDR
A picture of the inheritance of methylation imprints and speculation on the significance of the Xist imprint in development is presented and an hypothesis of evolution by "adaptive epigenetic/genetic inheritance" is considered.
...
...