WHICH MIXED-MEMBER PROPORTIONAL ELECTORAL FORMULA FITS YOU BEST? ASSESSING THE PROPORTIONALITY PRINCIPLE OF POSITIVE VOTE TRANSFER SYSTEMS

@article{Bochsler2014WHICHMP,
  title={WHICH MIXED-MEMBER PROPORTIONAL ELECTORAL FORMULA FITS YOU BEST? ASSESSING THE PROPORTIONALITY PRINCIPLE OF POSITIVE VOTE TRANSFER SYSTEMS},
  author={Daniel Bochsler},
  journal={Representation},
  year={2014},
  volume={50},
  pages={113 - 127}
}
  • D. Bochsler
  • Published 2 January 2014
  • Political Science
  • Representation
Mixed-member proportional systems (MMP) are a family of electoral systems which combine district-based elections with a proportional seat allocation. Positive vote transfer systems belong to this family. This article explains why they might be better than their siblings, and examines under which conditions full proportionality is reached. A formal model shows that full proportionality depends on the number of compensation mandates available, and on the degree of coordination among voters and… Expand
Mixed-member proportional electoral systems – the best of both worlds?
ABSTRACT Mixed electoral systems are often associated with the hope of combining proportional election outcomes with a concentrated party system, and thus achieving the best of both worlds inExpand
Between plurality and proportionality: an analysis of vote transfer systems
  • L. Csató
  • Economics, Computer Science
  • ArXiv
  • 2015
The paper considers a general model of electoral systems combining district-based elections with a compensatory mechanism in order to implement any outcome between strictly majoritarian and purelyExpand
WHEN IT PAYS TO LOSE: THE FUNDAMENTAL FLAW OF THE POSITIVE VOTE TRANSFER ELECTORAL SYSTEM
This comment shows that the positive vote transfer (PVT) system—deemed a preferable alternative to the mixed-member proportional electoral system—suffers from a fundamental flaw. The problem withExpand
BENDING THE RULES: ELECTORAL STRATEGIES UNDER MIXED ELECTORAL SYSTEMS
Mixed electoral systems with compensatory mandates such as the mixed-member proportional electoral system, the positive or the negative vote transfer system allow for various types of electoralExpand
A mathematical evaluation of vote transfer systems
  • L. Csató
  • Computer Science, Mathematics
  • ArXiv
  • 2016
TLDR
The trade-off between vote transfer formulas and the number of list mandates reveals that the majority party should use an appropriately calibrated NVT system if it focuses on these two variables. Expand
CONSTITUTIONAL REFORMS ON ELECTORAL SYSTEM FOR CONSOLIDATION OF PARLIAMENTARY DEMOCRACY IN GEORGIA
The article presented deals with the analysis of electoral reform in Georgia. As a result of the 2017–2018 constitutional reform Georgia has fully shifted to parliamentary system of government, andExpand

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 41 REFERENCES
How Proportional are Mixed Compensatory Electoral Systems? Determining the Necessary Share of Compensation Mandates in Mixed Systems
Mixed compensatory systems (some call them “mixed-member proportional systems”), are praised for combining the best of both worlds.” Yet, we know fairly little about their outcomes in practice. WeExpand
A quasi-proportional electoral system ‘only for honest men’? The hidden potential for manipulating mixed compensatory electoral systems
Mixed compensatory systems have risen in popularity in recent years. Under such systems, single-seat districts elect only the leader of the local suffrage, but the systems nevertheless produceExpand
Going It Alone? Strategic Entry under Mixed Electoral Rules
Recent studies on strategic voting and entry in elections that combine plurality or majority and proportional representation (PR) have found candidate placement in single-member district (SMD) racesExpand
Interaction Effects in Mixed-Member Electoral Systems
The past decade has witnessed a surprising growth in the popularity of mixed-member electoral systems. Under these systems, voters choose representatives simultaneously under both proportionalExpand
PROPORTIONALITY PROFILES OF WEST EUROPEAN ELECTORAL SYSTEMS
Author(s): TAAGEPERA, R; LAAKSO, M | Abstract: How proportional are the results of electoral systems designed to ensure proportional representation? How large is the deviation from proportionalityExpand
A House Divided
Mixed-member electoral systems embrace two views of representation by electing some legislators in single-member district elections and others in a proportional representation election. This canExpand
Hungary: holding back the tiers
Hungary has a particularly complicated electoral system: a type of mixed system that incorporates three tiers of seat allocation, the use of a proportional allocation formula, and the allocation of aExpand
Proportionality, disproportionality and electoral systems
Abstract Different PR methods should be seen not as being more proportional or less proportional than each other but as embodying different ideas as to what maximizing proportionality means and, byExpand
Mixed electoral systems and electoral system effects: controlled comparison and cross-national analysis
Utilizing data from 15 countries that employ mixed electoral systems, we provide a crossnational analysis of the defining elements and potentially constraining effects of such systems. Using districtExpand
The Strategy and History of Electoral System Choice
It is on account of the importance of the consequences of the electoral system, especially on the number of political parties and the political composition of assemblies and governments, that theExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...