Voice identification by human listeners: On earwitness reliability

@article{Clifford1980VoiceIB,
  title={Voice identification by human listeners: On earwitness reliability},
  author={Brian R. Clifford},
  journal={Law and Human Behavior},
  year={1980},
  volume={4},
  pages={373-394}
}
  • B. Clifford
  • Published 1980
  • Psychology
  • Law and Human Behavior
This paper reviews what is currently known about voice identification by human listeners. Our own experimental data from a four-year research program into this topic is used to elucidate, support, and in some cases to contradict published work into the effects on voice identification of such factors as speech sample size and quality, voice disguise, delay in holding voice identification sessions, incidental as opposed to intentional memory for voices, the effects of the age of the witness… Expand
Relevance of Voice Identification Research to Criteria for Evaluating Reliability of an Identification
ABSTRACT We reviewed voice identification studies as they relate to the Neil v. Biggers (1972) criteria for evaluating reliability of an identification: witness' opportunity to listen, degree ofExpand
Earwitness memory: distortions for voice pitch and speaking rate
In two experiments, memory distortions for voice pitch and speaking rate were examined. In both experiments, a significant distortion effect for voice pitch was observed, with listeners biasedExpand
Aural-perceptual speaker identification: problems with noncontemporary samples
The degree to which speech and/or speech samples are noncontemporary is considered important to the speaker identification process. There are two dimensions to the problem; the first relates to theExpand
Typicality effects on memory for voice: Implications for earwitness testimony
The effects of voice typicality on voice recognition were examined. In an incidental task, participants were presented with consonant-vowel-consonant stimuli (with varying vowels) spoken by voicesExpand
Detection of imitated voices : who are reliable earwitnesses?
Factors affecting an individual's ability to identify people aurally are of forensic importance. This paper investigates how topic, dialect, gender, age, and hearing status affect detection of anExpand
Earwitness descriptions and speaker identification
Some 160 men and women selected from public locations agreed to participate in a voice identification experiment. Participants were instructed to listen carefully to the tape-recorded voice of aExpand
Speaker identification by non-native and naïve earwitnesses
TLDR
Untrained Chilean auditors and without knowledge of German must identify the voice of a German woman who previously spoke in Spanish with a delay of 2 hours, but inaccurately, by giving the highest score to the target voice above the others, reinforces the idea that hearing evidence should only have an indicative value. Expand
When is hearing believing: The effects of professional experience on voice identification accuracy
The purpose of the study was to examine differences in the accuracy of voice identification tasks between an experimental group (N = 56) consisting of security personal, and a control group (N = 44).Expand
Voice Identification
A study examined whether a person's ability to accurately identify a voice is influenced by factors similar to those proposed by the Supreme Court for eyewitness identification accuracy. InExpand
Speaker identification utilizing noncontemporary speech.
TLDR
It can be concluded that a listener's competency in identifying noncontemporary speech samples will show only modest decay over rather substantial periods of time and, hence, this factor should have only a minimal negative effect on the speaker identification process. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 62 REFERENCES
Speaker identification by speech spectrograms: a scientists' view of its reliability for legal purposes.
TLDR
The topics considered included the nature of speech information as it relates to speaker identification, a comparison of voice patterns and fingerprint patterns, experimental evidence on voice identification, and requirements for validation of such identification methods. Expand
Voice recognition by matching to sample
TLDR
Voice recognition was assessed by a matching to sample procedure in 30 right-handed adults with normal hearing, with recognition being most accurate when the matching voice was first and least accurate when it was third. Expand
Identification of the speaker's sex from voiceless fricatives.
  • F. Ingemann
  • Mathematics, Medicine
  • The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
  • 1968
TLDR
A speaker's sex was more easily identified when he produced [h,χ,x] than when heproduced [θ,f,ɸ]. Expand
Speaker sex identification from voiced, whispered, and filtered isolated vowels.
The purpose of this investigation was to determine the relative importance of the speaker’s laryngeal fundamental frequency and vocal tract resonance characteristics in speaker sex identificationExpand
On the Identification of Speakers by Voice
TLDR
One of the most effective factors for speaker identification was the duration of the speech signal, which appears to be important only insofar as it admits a smaller or larger statistical sampling of the speaker's speech repertoire. Expand
The Effect of Speaker's Voice on Word Recognition
Although it is generally believed that the representational characteristics of verbal stimuli (typescript or speaker's voice, for example) persist for a very brief time in sensory memory, some recentExpand
Effects of stimulus content and duration on talker identification.
Sixteen listeners attempted to identify the talker when listening to speech samples of varying duration and content. The samples, recorded by 10 different talkers, were of five types: excerptedExpand
Identification of speaker sex from isolated, voiceless fricatives.
  • M. F. Schwartz
  • Physics, Medicine
  • The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
  • 1968
TLDR
Investigation of the ability of listeners to identify speaker sex from isolated productions of /f/, /θ/, /s/, and /∫/. Expand
Predictors of Age in the Male Voice
Direct age estimates of 80 adult male speakers, chronologically 40–80 years of age, were made by 20 untrained listeners from recorded speech samples. Forty recordings were selected for furtherExpand
Speaker authentication and identification: a comparison of spectrographic and auditory presentations of speech material.
TLDR
The results for the closed tests indicate that, after about 4 h of exposure to the test situation, the percent error in identification of speakers from isolated speech samples (words or phrases) is about six percent for aural presentation and about 21% for visual presentation. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...