Visualizing Geospatial Information Uncertainty: What We Know and What We Need to Know

  title={Visualizing Geospatial Information Uncertainty: What We Know and What We Need to Know},
  author={Alan M. MacEachren and Anthony C. Robinson and S. Waheeta Hopper and Steven Gardner and Robert Murray and Mark Gahegan and Elizabeth G. Hetzler},
  journal={Cartography and Geographic Information Science},
  pages={139 - 160}
Developing reliable methods for representing and managing information uncertainty remains a persistent and relevant challenge to GIScience. Information uncertainty is an intricate idea, and recent examinations of this concept have generated many perspectives on its representation and visualization, with perspectives emerging from a wide range of disciplines and application contexts. In this paper, we review and assess progress toward visual tools and methods to help analysts manage and… 

Visual Analytics and Uncertainty: Its Not About the Data

This short paper sketches elements of what the authors know and outlines some key challenges for developing visual analytics methods and tools that enable users to cope with uncertainty throughout the processes of sensemaking, decision-making, and action-taking.

How to Assess Visual Communication of Uncertainty? A Systematic Review of Geospatial Uncertainty Visualisation User Studies

A systematic review of past user studies of uncertainty visualisation, focusing on the field of geographic visualisation and cartography and thus on displays containing geospatial uncertainty, highlights the importance of user tasks for successful solutions and recommends moving towards task-centered typologies to support systematic evaluation.

Evaluating the effect of visually represented geodata uncertainty on decision-making: systematic review, lessons learned, and recommendations

This paper presents a comprehensive review of uncertainty visualization assessments from geovisualization and related fields, and presents a categorization of research foci related to evaluating the effects of uncertainty visualize on decision-making.

Beyond the Surface: Current Issues and Future Directions in Uncertainty Visualization Research

It is argued for a shift in attention towards assessing higher-level cognitive processes by keeping the focus on the user from the onset of visualization design to the final uncertainty visualization output, and identifying appropriate levels of precision when visualizing uncertainty and supporting a deeper comprehension of uncertainty.

A Spreadsheet Approach to Facilitate Visualization of Uncertainty in Information

This paper extends the spreadsheet paradigm to encapsulate uncertainty details within cells to create an inherent awareness of the uncertainty associated with each variable and enables mapping the encapsulated uncertainty to visual elements via the formula language and a visualization sheet.

Revealing Uncertainty for Information Visualization

This work reviewed existing work from several domains on uncertainty and created a classification of uncertainty based on the literature, finding commonalities in uncertainty across domains and believe this refined classification will help in developing appropriate visualizations for each category of uncertainty.

Special issue introduction: Approaching spatial uncertainty visualization to support reasoning and decision making

A visual summary graphic is presented to provide an overview of each article in this special issue of Uncertainty Visualizations to support reasoning and decision-making.

The Visualization of Uncertainty

This dissertation seeks to advance approaches for uncertainty visualization by exploring techniques from scientific and information visualization, creating new visual devices to handle the complexities of uncertainty data, and combining the most effective display methods into the Ensemble-Vis framework for visual data analysis.

Domains of uncertainty visualization research: a visual summary approach

This visual summary extends current existing approaches to taxonomies by allowing users a quick visual overview of relevant topics in a research area at a glance, and ensures that the visual summary approach and the corresponding domains developed in this article can be used reliably.

In Pursuit of Error: A Survey of Uncertainty Visualization Evaluation

A taxonomy for characterizing decisions made in designing an evaluation of an uncertainty visualization is presented and a concrete set of recommendations for evaluators designed to reduce the mismatch between the conceptualization of uncertainty in visualization versus other fields is concluded.




The difference between data quality and uncertainty, the application of Berlin's graphic variables to the representation of uncertainty, conceptual models of spatial uncertainty as they relate to kinds of cartographic symbolization, and categories of user interfaces suited to presenting data and uncertainty about that data are addressed.

A typology for visualizing uncertainty

An expanded typology for uncertainty is proposed, drawing from past frameworks targeted at scientific computing, that provides general categories for analytic uncertainty, a framework for creating task-specific refinements to those categories, and examples drawn from the national security field.

The Certainty of Uncertainty: GIS and the Limits of Geographic Knowledge

The paper argues that uncertainty is an intrinsic property of complex knowledge and not just a flaw that needs to be excised, and distinguishes three different modes or forms of geospatial knowledge production, and argues that each has built–in imperfections.

Procedural annotation of uncertain information

This work has developed a method for showing the uncertainty information together with data with minimal distraction that uses procedurally generated annotations which are deformed according to the uncertaintyInformation.

Visualizing Uncertainty in Geo-spatial Data

This paper highlights some of the visualization challenges in visualizing uncertainty associated with geo-spatial data and presents some possible approaches and further challenges using two illustrative application domains.

Testing Popular Visualization Techniques for Representing Model Uncertainty

Many land allocation issues, such as land-use planning, require input from extensive spatial databases and involve complex decision-making. Spatial decision support systems (SDSS) are designed to

The Nature of Uncertainty in Historical Geographic Information

The nature and form of uncertainty is remarkably consistent across various situations, and is approximately equivalent in the three aspects, which will enable consistent solutions for representation and processing of spatiotemporal data.

Visual access to data quality in geographic information systems

Visualization encompasses the display of quantities or qualities of visible or invisible phenomena through the combined use of points, lines, a coordinate system, numbers, symbols, words, shading,

Evaluating the Perception of Uncertainty in Alternative Visualization Strategies

Both relatively expert and novice users are highly successful at determining classification uncertainty among pixels when shown in greyscale images and histograms, as well as having moderate success with random animations.

Approaches to uncertainty visualization

These uncertainty visualization techniques present data in such a manner that users are made aware of the locations and degree of uncertainties in their data so as to make more informed analyses and decisions.