Visões da liberdade: republicanismo e liberalismo no debate teórico contemporâneo

  title={Vis{\~o}es da liberdade: republicanismo e liberalismo no debate te{\'o}rico contempor{\^a}neo},
  author={Ricardo Silva},
  journal={Lua Nova: Revista de Cultura e Pol{\'i}tica},
  • Ricardo Silva
  • Published 1 April 2015
  • History, Philosophy
  • Lua Nova: Revista de Cultura e Política
In recent decades, there has been a recovery of a strand of republicanism whose genesis dates back to the ideals and institutions of the ancient Roman Republic. Reconstructed by historians of political thought - and recently absorbed by theorists of analytical and normative persuasion - the "neo-Roman republicanism" revolves around a conception of freedom as non-domination, allegedly distinct from freedom as noninterference, predominant in contemporary liberalism. By understanding freedom as an… 
8 Citations

Republicanismo neorromano e liberalismo: para além das proximidades declaradas

O artigo detem-se nos argumentos do republicanismo neorromano a fim de explicitar proximidades com o liberalismo maiores que os proprios neorromanos estao dispostos a reconhecer. Para isso, centra-se


  • Ricardo Silva
  • Political Science
    Revista Brasileira de Ciências Sociais
  • 2018
O artigo elabora uma crítica da interpretação anti-institucionalista do republicanismo democrático de Maquiavel. Em oposição aos que atribuem ao florentino o compromisso com uma forma institucional


  • Ivo Coser
  • Philosophy
    Lua Nova: Revista de Cultura e Política
  • 2019
Resumo O artigo analisa a relação entre a ideia de lei e de liberdade no pluralismo de valores. A partir da obra de Isaiah Berlin são apresentadas três concepções de lei: a lei como intervenção

Desigualdade e Corrupção no Republicanismo de Maquiavel

RESUMO O artigo persegue dois objetivos inter-relacionados: 1) contribuir para a interpretação dos enunciados de Maquiavel sobre o papel da desigualdade na corrupção das repúblicas; 2) mostrar que os

Uma Reinterpretação das Liberdades Negativa, Positiva e de Escolha

RESUMO Este artigo apresenta uma reinterpretação dos conceitos de liberdade negativa, positiva e de escolha presentes na obra de Isaiah Berlin. Para efetuar tal operação apresentam-se duas hipóteses.



Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government

This is the first full-length presentation of a republican alternative to the liberal and communitarian theories that have dominated political philosophy in recent years. Professor Pettit's eloquent,

Liberdade e lei no neo-republicanismo de Skinner e Pettit

The article aims to analyze the interventions of Quentin Skinner and Philip Pettit in the current disputes on the meaning of the concept of liberty. It argues that despite differences of method and

The Concept of Liberty: the Polemic between the Neo-Republicans and Isaiah Berlin

This article offers an analysis of the polemic between neo-republicanism and Isaiah Berlin on the concept of liberty. Neo-republican theory argues that Berlin's concept of liberty allows arbitrary

Republicanism: the Career of a Concept

The concept of republicanism was one of the success stories of the 1980s. A generation ago the term-while not unknown-carried no more freight than scores of others in the historical vocabulary. First

The Republican Critique of Liberalism

  • Alan Patten
  • History
    British Journal of Political Science
  • 1996
A number of writers have drawn upon the republican tradition in political thought to criticize liberals like Rawls and Dworkin for neglecting the importance of public service and civic virtue. In

Liberty: One or Two Concepts Liberty

Isaiah Berlin’s distinction between “negative” and “positive” concepts of liberty has recently been defended on newand interesting grounds. Proponents of this dichotomy used to equate positive

Philosophy in History: The idea of negative liberty: philosophical and historical perspectives

My aim is to explore a possible means of enlarging our present understanding of the concepts we employ in social and political argument. The prevailing orthodoxy bids us proceed by consulting our

Slaves, Prisoners, and Republican Freedom

Philip Pettit’s republican conception of freedom is presented as an alternative both to negative and positive conceptions of freedom. The basic idea is to conceptualize freedom as non-domination, not

What's wrong with negative liberty

This is an attempt to resolve one of the issues that separate ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ theories of freedom, as these have been distinguished in Isaiah Berlin's seminal essay, ‘Two concepts of

Liberty and Leviathan

Hobbes made a distinctive contribution to the discussion of freedom on two fronts. He persuaded later, if not immediate, successors that it is only the exercise of a power of interference that