Varsity medical ethics debate 2018: constant health monitoring - the advance of technology into healthcare

  title={Varsity medical ethics debate 2018: constant health monitoring - the advance of technology into healthcare},
  author={Christopher G.S. Gilmartin and Edward H Arbe-Barnes and Michael Diamond and Sasha Fretwell and Euan Mcgivern and Myrto Vlazaki and Limeng Zhu},
  journal={Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine : PEHM},
The 2018 Varsity Medical Ethics debate convened upon the motion: “This house believes that the constant monitoring of our health does more harm than good”. This annual debate between students from the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge is now in its tenth year. This year’s debate was hosted at the Oxford Union on 8th of February 2018, with Oxford winning for the Opposition, and was the catalyst for the collation and expansion of ideas in this paper.New technological devices have the potential… 
Role of ruler or intruder? Patient’s right to autonomy in the age of innovation and technologies
It is argued, that one of the effective ways to ensure patient’s right to autonomy is implementation of legal instruments, such as informed consent, advance directives and Ulysses contracts, but with a potential of new technologies and artificial intelligence these legal instruments need to be reconsidered and transformed in more efficient and eligible model.
The Limits of Empowerment: How to Reframe the Role of mHealth Tools in the Healthcare Ecosystem
It is argued that mHealth technologies should instead be framed as digital companions, and that reframing the narrative cannot be the only means for avoiding harm caused to the NHS as a healthcare system by the introduction of mHealth tools.
Development and Presentation of an Ethical Framework for Health and Medical Apps
Debates on ethics and the use of health and medical apps should play a significant role in public discussion and the development of consistent guidelines and a framework for reflection of occurring ethical concerns are focused on.
Enhancing Surveillance: New Data, New Technologies, and New Actors
  • J. FrancisL. Francis
  • Medicine
    Sustaining Surveillance: The Importance of Information for Public Health
  • 2021
It is concluded that regulation is uneven at best and that increased oversight and transparency are imperative to avoid backlash and sustain trust in these novel forms of data use.
Medical Device Development Process, and Associated Risks and Legislative Aspects-Systematic Review
The crucial factor in healthcare safety is the stability of factors over a long production time; good manufacturing practices cannot be tested on individual batches of products; they must be inherently built into the manufacturing process.


The Ethical Implications of Personal Health Monitoring
It is concluded that a holistic understanding of the ethical issues surrounding PHM will help both researchers and practitioners in developing effective PHM implementations.
The anxious wait: assessing the impact of patient accessible EHRs for breast cancer patients
Results suggest that the use of this PHR may be of benefit for informing patients, and further research is required to investigate the impact on the patients experiences, their participation in their care, their relationships with the health care team, and their health outcomes.
Securing the Elderly Body: Dementia, Surveillance, and the Politics of "Aging in Place"
This paper will analyze surveillance technologies for the elderly with attention to issues of power and inequality, and how these dynamics may or may not be considered in technological design for the oldest populations.
Effect of telehealth on use of secondary care and mortality: findings from the Whole System Demonstrator cluster randomised trial
Telehealth is associated with lower mortality and emergency admission rates, and differences in emergency admissions were greatest at the beginning of the trial, during which the authors observed a particularly large increase for the control group.
Ethical issues and questions for researchers around informed consent; working with people who are cognitively impaired; surveillance and the passivity of monitoring; processes of care and using and linking lifestyle monitoring data are identified.
Self-management education for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
A large number of studies showed a significant reduction in the probability of at least one hospital admission among patients receiving self-management education compared to those receiving usual care, and there is an evident need for more large RCTs with long-term follow-up, before more conclusions can be drawn.
Privacy and senior willingness to adopt smart home information technology in residential care facilities.
  • K. Courtney
  • Education
    Methods of information in medicine
  • 2008
The findings from this study indicate that privacy can be a barrier for older adults' adoption of smart home IT; however their own perception of their need for the technology may override their privacy concerns.
The Effects of Web-Based Patient Access to Laboratory Results in British Columbia: A Patient Survey on Comprehension and Anxiety
While most patients who received their laboratory test results online reported little anxiety after receiving their results and were satisfied with the service, there may be opportunities to improve comprehension of results.
Measuring the Lifespace of People With Parkinson’s Disease Using Smartphones: Proof of Principle
Lifespace measured by GPS-enabled smartphones may be a useful concept to measure the progression of PD and the impact of various therapies and rehabilitation programs, suggesting a trend of decreasing Lifespace with increasing PD symptoms.