Using Credible Advice to Overcome Framing Effects

@article{Druckman2001UsingCA,
  title={Using Credible Advice to Overcome Framing Effects},
  author={James N. Druckman},
  journal={Journal of Law Economics \& Organization},
  year={2001},
  volume={17},
  pages={62-82}
}
  • J. Druckman
  • Published 1 April 2001
  • Economics
  • Journal of Law Economics & Organization
A framing effect occurs when different, but logically equivalent, words or phrases (e.g., 10% employment of 90% unemployment) cause individuals to alter their decisions. Demonstrations of framing effects challenge a fundamental tenet of rational choice theory and suggest that public opinion is so malleable that it cannot serve as a useful guide to policymakers. In this article I argue that most previous work overstates the ubiquity of framing effects because it forces experimental participants… 

Tables from this paper

The Implications of Framing Effects for Citizen Competence

Social scientists have documented framing effects in a wide range of contexts, including surveys, experiments, and actual political campaigns. Many view work on framing effects as evidence of citizen

Political Preference Formation: Competition, Deliberation, and the (Ir)relevance of Framing Effects

  • J. Druckman
  • Psychology
    American Political Science Review
  • 2004
One of the most contested questions in the social sciences is whether people behave rationally. A large body of work assumes that individuals do in fact make rational economic, political, and social

How Partisan Frames Affect Public Consideration of Policy Problems

In the paper, we use an experimental design to assess the effect that partisan framing of a policy problem has on individuals’ preferences for a policy solution. We combine key elements from work on

The Importance of Framing in Ballots: An Example

In 2000, two virtually identical popular initiatives, both demanding a decrease in the legal retirement in Switzerland, led to very difierent approval rates. Using community level and individual

Framing Effects in Political Decision Making: Evidence from a Natural Voting Experiment

This paper analyzes a recent ballot in which two virtually identical popular initiatives, both demanding a decrease in the legal age of retirement in Switzerland, led to differences in approval rates

Framing Effects in Success of Social Networks Based on Information System

Current study tries to describe outcomes of the framing effects (in domains of gain and loss). In this paper, first, some fundamental framing elements are discussed, then they are employed in the

Political Parties, Motivated Reasoning, and Issue Framing Effects

Issue framing is one of the most important means of elite influence on public opinion. However, we know almost nothing about how citizens respond to frames in what is possibly the most common

Transparency Diminishes Framing-Effects in Voting on Redistribution: Some Experimental Evidence

This study analyzes whether enabling people to get informed about redistributive consequences is an effective measure to prevent equivalence framing in the domain of voting on redistribution.

Framing Political Messages to Fit the Audience’s Regulatory Orientation: How to Improve the Efficacy of the Same Message Content

TLDR
Results of two studies show that regulatory fit increases the impact of a political message favoring nuclear energy on implicit attitudes of the target audience and induces a more positive evaluation of the political candidate who is delivering a message concerning immigration policies.

The Influence of Group and Outcome Cues on Perceptions of Governmental Spending

Previous research in issue framing has shown the importance of social groups in shaping opinion. When issues become tied to social groups through rhetoric, group sentiment becomes an important
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 69 REFERENCES

The Influence of Framing on Risky Decisions: A Meta-analysis.

  • Kühberger
  • Psychology
    Organizational behavior and human decision processes
  • 1998
TLDR
It is concluded that framing is a reliable phenomenon, but that outcome salience manipulations have to be distinguished from reference point manipulations and that procedural features of experimental settings have a considerable effect on effect sizes in framing experiments.

The Effects of Framing, Problem Variations, and Providing Rationale on Choice

Tversky and Kahneman reported a large effect of the framing of decision options on choice. When options were phrased positively in terms of gains, people chose the sure thing. But when options were

All Frames Are Not Created Equal: A Typology and Critical Analysis of Framing Effects.

TLDR
A broader perspective, focused on the cognitive and motivational consequences of valence-based encoding, opens the door to a deeper understanding of the causes and consequences of framing effects.

Media Framing of a Civil Liberties Conflict and Its Effect on Tolerance

Framing is the process by which a communication source, such as a news organization, defines and constructs a political issue or public controversy. Two experiments examined the effect of news frames

The Effects of Framing, Reflection, Probability, and Payoff on Risk Preference in Choice Tasks.

TLDR
A meta-analysis of Asian-disease-like studies is presented to identify the factors which determine risk preference, and it is shown that it is not probabilities or payoffs, but the framing condition, which explains most variance.

Reconceiving Decision-Making in Democratic Politics: Attention, Choice, and Public Policy

Most models of political decision-making maintain that individual preferences remain relatively constant. Why, then, are there often sudden abrupt changes in public opinion on political issues? Or

Framing Effects and Arenas of Choice: Your Money or Your Life?

Abstract This paper investigates the consistency of outcome framing effects on choice across two arenas of outcome: human life and money. Past research has yielded notable variability in the

Framing the framing effect: the impact of context cues on solutions to the ‘Asian disease’ problem

Participants were exposed to the "asian disease" problem (Tversky & Kahneman, 1981). When the problem was subtly framed as a medical decision problem previous findings replicated: Participants
...