Unpacking the Mascot Debate: Native American Identification Predicts Opposition to Native Mascots

@article{Fryberg2020UnpackingTM,
  title={Unpacking the Mascot Debate: Native American Identification Predicts Opposition to Native Mascots},
  author={Stephanie A. Fryberg and Arianne E. Eason and Laura M. Brady and Nadia Jessop and Julisa J. Lopez},
  journal={Social Psychological and Personality Science},
  year={2020},
  volume={12},
  pages={3 - 13}
}
While major organizations representing Native Americans (e.g., National Congress of American Indians) contend that Native mascots are stereotypical and dehumanizing, sports teams with Native mascots cite polls claiming their mascots are not offensive to Native people. We conducted a large-scale, empirical study to provide a valid and generalizable understanding of Native Americans’ (N = 1,021) attitudes toward Native mascots. Building on the identity centrality literature, we examined how… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Discrimination and resentment: examining American attitudes about Native Americans

Abstract What shapes Americans' attitudes toward and about Native Americans? Public opinion research acknowledges that race and ethnicity are a factor in shaping US public opinion. Native Americans

The psychosocial effects of Native American mascots: a comprehensive review of empirical research findings

ABSTRACT Approximately 2,000 teams in the U.S. utilize Native American mascots, the majority of which are associated with schools. Across the nation there continue to be many intense conflicts over

Incivility and Washington’s NFL Franchise: Exploring Uncivil Discourse in Sports Blog Comment Sections

  • James Bingaman
  • Sociology
    International Journal of Sport Communication
  • 2022
The current study sought to explore the prevalence of uncivil discourse surrounding the Washington NFL team’s removal of offensive Native American imagery and later rebranding as the Washington

Perspectives on Native American Imagery from Students at a Premiere Tribal University

Haskell Indian Nations University is the sole 4-year intertribal university in America and their athletics department is called The Fightin’ Indians. Their logo and name seem to contradict most of

Twenty Years of Research into the Health Impacts of Native-themed Mascots: A Scoping Review.

The majority of research included in this review illustrates overall negative impacts of Native-themed mascots on health and its determinants that influence health and health disparities.

“If We Don’t Do It, Nobody Is Going to Talk About It”: Indigenous Students Disrupting Latinidad at Hispanic-Serving Institutions

Hispanic and Latinx are terms that conflate ethnicity, race, and nationality and complicate our ability to generalize what it means for Hispanic-serving institutions (HSIs) to serve such a diverse

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 59 REFERENCES

Symbols of pride or prejudice? Examining the impact of Native American sports mascots on stereotype application

Results indicated that the effect of Native American mascots was moderated by people’s racial attitudes toward Native people, and exposed people with a prejudiced attitude rated a Native American individual more stereotypically aggressive than those with a non-prejudiced attitude.

The psychology of engagement with indigenous identities: a cultural perspective.

In a questionnaire study among 124 students at Haskell Indian Nations University, the authors investigated the hypothesis that engagement with Indigenous identity--assessed along three dimensions including degree, content, and context--can serve as a psychological resource for well-being and liberation from oppression.

The Racial Formation of American Indians: Negotiating Legitimate Identities within Tribal and Federal Law

Michael Omi and Harold Winant define “racial formation” as the process by which individuals are divided, by historically mutable rules, into racial categories.1 American Indians differ from other

Social Identity Threat in Response to Stereotypic Film Portrayals: Effects on Self‐Conscious Emotion and Implicit Ingroup Attitudes

Disadvantaged ethnic groups are often portrayed stereotypically in film, but little is known about how such portrayals affect members of those groups. Two experiments examined the affective and

Ethnic Identity Moderates Perceptions of Prejudice: Judgments of Personal Versus Group Discrimination and Subtle Versus Blatant Bias

Two studies investigate the association between ethnic identity and perceptions of prejudice. Study 1 examined the relationship between ethnic identity and the personal-group discrimination

The Relationship Between African American Enculturation and Racial Identity

This study investigated how predictive the Cross Racial Identity Scale (CRIS; B. J. Vandiver, W. E. Cross, F. C. Worrell, & P. Fhagen-Smith, 2002), a measure of Black racial identity, was of African

The Destruction of Identity: Cultural Genocide and Indigenous Peoples

International law defines genocide in terms of violence committed “with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,” yet this approach fails to

Of Warrior Chiefs and Indian Princesses: The Psychological Consequences of American Indian Mascots

Four studies examined the consequences of American Indian mascots and other prevalent representations of American Indians on aspects of the self-concept for American Indian students. When exposed to

Being Authentically American Indian: Symbolic Identity Construction and Social Structure among Urban New Indians

This study investigates the individual and group level reconstruction of a racial-ethnic identity. Specifically, we investigate the experience of “new Indians,” or people who did not previously

Do American Indian mascots = American Indian people? Examining implicit bias towards American Indian people and American Indian mascots.

Examination of implicit attitudes of non-AI people towards AI mascots and the extent to which they are related to attitudes towards AI people found significant concordance was observed between negative bias toward AI mascot and AI people.
...