Universal Compulsory Service in Medical Research

  title={Universal Compulsory Service in Medical Research},
  author={Christopher Herrera},
  journal={Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics},
  • C. Herrera
  • Published 2003
  • Medicine
  • Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics
Despite the prominence of healthcare-relatedconcerns in public debate, the ground remainsinfertile for the idea of conscripting citizensinto medical research. Reluctance to entertainthe thought of a system where nearly everyonecould be selected for service might reflectuncertainty about what the project wouldinvolve. There might also be a fear that themore crucial issue is how to protect researchsubjects within current, voluntary systems. Nodoubt reluctance to explore a system ofuniversal… 

Privacy revisited? Old ideals, new realities, and their impact on biobank regimes

Ethical frameworks stressing the societal value of low-privacy expectations in order to secure biomedical research are discussed and it will turn out that neither utilitarian nor communitarian or classical libertarian ethics frameworks will help to serve both goals.

Participants’ responsibilities in clinical research

It is argued that competent adult participants are responsible for complying with study requirements and fulfilling other obligations they undertake when they make an informed choice to enrol in a study.

Biobanks and Our Common Good

This work aims to explore the obligations the authors have in relation to research biobanks and what they can expect and demand from them, and argues that biobank research can become part of the kind of society that provides the individual with the opportunity to realise his understanding of a good life.


Biobank-based genomic research is considered instrumental to realize Personalised Medicine and considerable benefits for diagnosis and therapy of many common complex diseases. It raises manifold

Do people have an ethical obligation to share their health information? Comparing narratives of altruism and health information sharing in a nationally representative sample

Investigation of whether altruism contributes to the belief that there is an ethical obligation to share information about one’s health as well as how other health care experiences, perceptions, and concerns might be related to belief in such an obligation finds general altruism is associated with a higher likelihood of belief in anethical obligation to allow one's health information to be used for research.

A Duty to Participate in Research: Does Social Context Matter?

Because of the important benefits that biomedical research offers to humans, some have argued that people have a general moral obligation to participate in research. Although the defense of such a

A Duty to Participate in Research: Does Social Context Matter?

By reflecting on the social context in which a presumed duty to participate in research will obtain, this article shows that decontextualized discussions of this putative moral obligation are problematic.

The re-emergence of the liberal-communitarian debate in bioethics: exercising self-determination and participation in biomedical research.

A richer concept of self-determination that encompasses both liberal and communitarian insights in order to make sense of the value the authors attach toSelf-determination is discussed.

The obligation to participate in biomedical research.

A novel public goods argument for an obligation to participate in biomedical research is proposed, which would be of great aid to the progress of biomedical research, eventually making society significantly healthier and longer lived.



Rights, Obligations, and the Special Importance of Health Care

The aim in this essay is to develop a more rigorous moral case than has hitherto been made for establishing a general right to a “decent minimum” or “adequate level” of health care based on the thesis that there is a general moral obligation to provide such care to those who cannot provide it for themselves, even if there is no general moral right to health care of any kind.

Medical Knowledge as a Social Product: Rights, Risks, and Responsibilities

Let me sketch the program of this paper at the outset. I will begin with some scene setting: a brief account of the crisis in medicine. Then I will pose a problem: the need for a theoretical model of

Justice and the Claims of Future Generations

Most ethical discussion of health care and justice, for example, has focused on the equitable distribution of present health care resources, especially the right of less–advantaged individuals to medical services.

Justice and Equality: Some Questions About Scope

Can a society be just if it ignores the plight of other societies? Does it matter whether those societies are contemporaries? Moral “purists” are likely to assume that the answer to these questions

The Survival Lottery

In such circumstances if two dying patients could be saved by organ transplants then, if surgeons have the requisite organs in stock and no other needy patients, but nevertheless allow their patients to die, the authors would be inclined to say, and be justified in saying, that the patients died because the doctors refused to save them.

The Just Society

Imminent liberalism: the politics of mutual consent Roderick T. Long Justice to charity Loren E. Lomasky Equality, sufficiency, and opportunity in the just society Alexander Rosenberg Justice and

Leaving therapy to chance.

It is concluded that randomization is incompatible with the ethical obligations of the physician patient relationship and strategies for resolving the dilemma are proposed, but are shown to be ethically flawed upon closer examination.

Philosophical Reflections on Experimenting with Human Subjects

Experimenting with human subjects is going on in many fields of scientific and technological progress. It is designed to replace the overall instruction by natural, occasional, and cumulative