Unethical and Inept? The Influence of Moral Information on Perceptions of Competence

@article{Stellar2018UnethicalAI,
  title={Unethical and Inept? The Influence of Moral Information on Perceptions of Competence},
  author={Jennifer E Stellar and Robb Willer},
  journal={Journal of Personality and Social Psychology},
  year={2018},
  volume={114},
  pages={195–210}
}
While moral character heavily influences global evaluations of others (Goodwin, Piazza, & Rozin, 2014), its causal effect on perceptions of others’ competence (i.e., one’s knowledge, skills, and abilities) is less clear. We found that people readily use information about another’s morality when judging their competence, despite holding folk intuitions that these domains are independent. Across 6 studies (n = 1,567), including 2 preregistered experiments, participants judged targets who… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Are talented people more virtuous in the eyes of others? Positive effects of competence on perceived morality.
Existing research on competence and morality focuses on their role in impression formation, overlooking their impact on each other. In five studies, we explored whether a target person's competence
Resurrecting the evil genius: examining the relationship between unethical behavior and perceived competence
PurposeUsing the stereotype content model (SCM) as a framework, the authors examine how the negative relationship between peoples’ unethical behavior and perceptions of their competence only holds
Impression formation stimuli: A corpus of behavior statements rated on morality, competence, informativeness, and believability
To investigate impression formation, researchers tend to rely on statements that describe a person’s behavior (e.g., “Alex ridicules people behind their backs”). These statements are presented to
Agents’ moral character shapes people’s moral evaluations of accidental harm transgressions
Previous research has documented that judging someone responsible for an accident mainly relies on considerations about the outcome endured by the victim and the intention to cause harm. Yet, we
Who Do I (Dis)Trust and Monitor for Ethical Misconduct? Status, Power, and the Structural Paradox
TLDR
This research explores the predictive role of a structural paradox between high power and low status in identifying the actors most likely to be distrusted and monitored for ethical misconduct and identifies the structural paradox associated with distrust-related judgments and behaviors.
Does virtue lead to status? Testing the moral virtue theory of status attainment.
TLDR
The authors perform one of the first empirical tests of the moral virtue theory of status attainment (MVT) and provide initial support for MVT arguing that virtue is a distinct, third route to status.
Consequences of Moral Transgressions: How Regulatory Focus Orientation Motivates or Hinders Moral Decoupling
How can firms mitigate the impact of moral violations on consumer evaluations? This question has pervaded the business ethics literature. Though prior research has identified decoupling as a moral
Lay beliefs in moral expertise
ABSTRACT Compared to expertise in other domains, moral expertise remains a controversial topic. The current research employs a folk-psychological approach to explore which characteristics laypeople
Impact of brand anthropomorphism on ethical judgment: the roles of failure type and loneliness
Purpose This paper aims to investigate whether anthropomorphized (i.e. humanized) brands are judged less negatively for competence failures than for moral lapses and how these ethical judgments
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 53 REFERENCES
Looking for honesty: The primary role of morality (vs. sociability and competence) in information gathering
Research on the two fundamental dimensions of social judgment, namely warmth and competence, has shown that warmth has a primary and a dominant role in information gathering about others. In two
The attribution of morality.
In two experiments, observers received information about a stimulus person and then attributed a given level of morality to that person. Attributions of morality based on the stimulus person's
Moral character predominates in person perception and evaluation.
TLDR
It is argued that moral character and social warmth traits are separable, and that across a wide variety of contexts, character is usually more important than warmth in impression formation.
Group virtue: the importance of morality (vs. competence and sociability) in the positive evaluation of in-groups.
TLDR
Experimental manipulations of morality and competence and morality and sociability showed that only in-group morality affected aspects of the group-level self-concept related to positive evaluation (i.e., pride in, or distancing from, the in-groups).
Morality and competence in person- and self-perception
Morality and competence are posited to constitute two basic kinds of content in person- and self-perception. Moral content dominates person-perception because it typically has a direct and
The Psychology of Moral Conviction
This paper reviews current theory and research that indicates that attitudes held with strong moral conviction (‘moral mandates’) represent something psychologically distinct from other constructs
Fundamental dimensions of social judgment: understanding the relations between judgments of competence and warmth.
TLDR
The authors report 4 studies that examine the dynamic relationship between these two dimensions, experimentally manipulating the location of a target of judgment on one and examining the consequences for the other, suggesting a negative dynamic relationship.
Moral typecasting: divergent perceptions of moral agents and moral patients.
  • Kurt Gray, D. Wegner
  • Psychology, Philosophy
    Journal of personality and social psychology
  • 2009
TLDR
The authors explored moral typecasting-an inverse relation between perceptions of moral agency and moral patiency, which explains curious effects such as people's willingness to inflict greater pain on people who do good than those who do nothing.
Negativity and positivity effects in person perception and inferences: the importance of morality.
The present paper deals with negativity and positivity effects in trait inferences and impression formation. In the first experiment we tested the suggestion of Skowronski and Carlston (1987) that in
Tip of the Hat, Wag of the Finger: How Moral Decoupling Enables Consumers to Admire and Admonish
What reasoning processes do consumers use to support public figures who act immorally? Existing research emphasizes moral rationalization, whereby people reconstrue improper behavior in order to
...
...