Understanding the Frauchiger–Renner Argument

  title={Understanding the Frauchiger–Renner Argument},
  author={Jeffrey Bub},
  journal={arXiv: Quantum Physics},
  • J. Bub
  • Published 19 August 2020
  • Philosophy
  • arXiv: Quantum Physics
In 2018, Daniela Frauchiger and Renato Renner published an article in Nature Communications entitled `Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself.' I clarify the significance of the result and point out a common and persistent misunderstanding of the argument, which has been attacked as flawed from a variety of interpretational perspectives. 

Comment on "Understanding the Frauchiger-Renner argument" by Jeffrey Bub

Bub has recently claimed that the Frauchiger-Renner argument does not require an assumption that the state vector undergoes projection after measurement. It is shown that this claim is not true, and

The Quantum Rashomon Effect: A Strengthened Frauchiger-Renner Argument

A state-independent Frauchiger-Renner scenario is exhibited, eliminating any necessity for entanglement and ensuring that the quantum Rashomon effect is thus a generic feature of the quantum world.

Quantum erasing the memory of Wigner's friend

It is argued that the three apparently incompatible properties used to question the consistency of quantum mechanics correspond to two logically distinct contexts: either assuming that Wigner has full control over his friends' lab, or conversely that some part of the labs remain unaffected byWigner's subsequent measurements.

On the paper"Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself"

In the paper “Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself” by D. Frauchiger and R. Renner an atempt is made at proving a “no-go theorem” that states that either quantum theory

Testing quantum theory with thought experiments

Quantum mechanics is one of our most successful physical theories; its predictions agree with experimental observations to an extremely high accuracy. However, the bare formalism of quantum theory

No-go theorem based on incomplete information of Wigner about his friend

The notion of measurements is central for many debates in quantum mechanics. One critical point is whether a measurement can be regarded as an absolute event, giving the same result for any observer

The Open Systems View

There is a deeply entrenched view in philosophy and physics, the closed systems view, according to which isolated systems are conceived of as fundamental. On this view, when a system is under the

Local Quantum Reality

Unperformed measurements have no results. Unobserved results can affect future measurements.

Agents governed by quantum mechanics can use it intersubjectively and consistently

A simple operational principle called superpositional solipsism is proposed to aid rational agents in making situational inferences and it is shown that the principle leads to sound inferences in all operationally-relevant instances.



Frauchiger-Renner argument and quantum histories

In this article we reconstruct the Frauchiger and Renner's argument [1] taking into account that the assertions of the argument are made at different times. In order to do that, we use a formalism

Wigner's convoluted friends

  • R. MucinoE. Okon
  • Philosophy
    Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics
  • 2020

Remarks on the Mind-Body Question

F. Dyson, in a very thoughtful article,1 points to the everbroadening scope of scientific inquiry. Whether or not the relation of mind to body will enter the realm of scientific inquiry in the near

Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself

A variant of Wigner’s friend Gedankenexperiment where each of the current interpretations of QM fails in giving a consistent description, indicating that quantum theory cannot be extrapolated to complex systems, at least not in a straightforward manner.

Quantum mechanics, local realistic theories, and Lorentz-invariant realistic theories.

  • Hardy
  • Physics, Mathematics
    Physical review letters
  • 1992
Bell's theorem is demonstrated, without using inequalities, for an experiment with two particles, and it is shown that, if realism and Lorentz-invariant observables are assumed, it can derive a contradiction with quantum mechanics.

Quantum Theory: Concepts and Methods

Preface. Part I: Gathering the Tools. 1. Introduction to Quantum Physics. 2. Quantum Tests. 3. Complex Vector Space. 4. Continuous Variables. Part II: Cryptodeterminism and Quantum Inseparability. 5.

Nonlocality for two particles without inequalities for almost all entangled states.

  • Hardy
  • Physics
    Physical review letters
  • 1993
It is shown that it is possible to demonstrate nonlocality for two particles without using inequalities for all entangled states except maximally entangled states such as the singlet state. The

Interpreting the Quantum World

Introduction 1. From classical to quantum mechanics 2. Bell's 'no-go' theorem 3. The Kochen and Specker 'no-go' theorem 4. The proof of interpretation 5. Quantum mechanics without observers: I 6.

Quantum Theory: Concepts and Methods (Springer: New York, 19950

  • 1995

  • 1961