Uncertainty Matters: Computer Models at the Science–Policy Interface

  title={Uncertainty Matters: Computer Models at the Science–Policy Interface},
  author={M. Brugnach and Andrew Tagg and F. Keil and Willem J. de Lange},
  journal={Water Resources Management},
The use of computer models offers a general and flexible framework that can help to deal with some of the complexities and difficulties associated with the development of water management plans as prescribed by the Water Framework Directive. However, despite the advantages modelling presents, the integration of information derived from models into policy is far away from being trivial or the norm. Part of the difficulties of this integration is rooted in the lack of confidence policy makers… 
The inadequacy of monitoring without modelling support.
Modelling can significantly improve the benefits of monitoring data; by quality assurance of data, interpolation and extrapolation in space and time, development of process understanding (conceptual models), and the assessment of impacts of pressures and effects of programmes of measures.
Use and Utility: Exploring the Diversity and Design of Water Models at the Science-Policy Interface
Effort to narrow the gap between the production and use of scientific knowledge for environmental decision-making is gaining traction, yet in practice, supply and demand remains largely unbalanced. A
Delineating the Model-Stakeholder Gap: Framing Perceptions to Analyse the Information Requirement in River Management
The framework described in this paper provides a structured approach to information analysis in policy processes that helps in dealing with different perceptions and actor backgrounds during this policy process because it allows a better match between the information needs and the tools or procedures that are applied.
Collaborative Modelling in Water Resources Management: Two approaches from the Netherlands
Water Resources Management (WRM) problems are now recognised for their complexity. Approaches for dealing with these problems must integrate a variety of interests, perspectives, values and knowledge
A broadened view on the role for models in natural resource management: Implications for model development
Models play a central tool in the development and implementation of management strategies. In this paper we identify four major modeling purposes that are important for understanding and managing
Towards a pragmatic approach for dealing with uncertainties in water management practice
Management of water resources is afflicted with uncertainties. Nowadays it is facing more and new uncertainties since pace and dimension of changes (e.g. climatic, demographic) are accelerating and
Improved modelling for urban sustainability assessment and strategic planning: local government planner and modeller perspectives on the key challenges
Many technical and modelling tools are available to support the strategic assessment of land-use and infrastructure policy proposals in local government. However, there remains a lack of guidance and


Approaches for performing uncertainty analysis in large-scale energy/economic policy models
A number of key policy insights have emerged from the application of large-scale economic/energy models, such as integrated assessment models for climate change. These insights have been particularly
Process level sensitivity analysis for complex ecological models
Conceptual Modeling for Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management in the Barycz Valley, Lower Silesia, Poland
Concept modeling is applied to increase communication, understanding and commitment in the project of seven NGOs “Sustainable Regional Development in the Odra Catchment” and establishes a broad basis for stakeholder-driven discussion that is articulated into goals, objectives, conceptual models, and indicators.
Techniques for estimating uncertainty in climate change scenarios and impact studies
Methodology for quantifying uncertainty in global climate change studies is reviewed. The focus is on recent developments in statistics, such as hierarchical modeling and Markov chain Monte Carlo
Developing principles of good practice in integrated environmental assessment
In integrated environmental assessment, unlike many other fields of quantitative social and environmental science, there is a keen awareness of the need for quality and assurance, and principles of
Towards the development of a decision support system for water resource management