Two Failures to Replicate High-Performance-Goal Priming Effects

@article{Harris2013TwoFT,
  title={Two Failures to Replicate High-Performance-Goal Priming Effects},
  author={Christine R. Harris and Noriko Coburn and Doug Rohrer and Harold Pashler},
  journal={PLoS ONE},
  year={2013},
  volume={8}
}
Bargh et al. (2001) reported two experiments in which people were exposed to words related to achievement (e.g., strive, attain) or to neutral words, and then performed a demanding cognitive task. Performance on the task was enhanced after exposure to the achievement related words. Bargh and colleagues concluded that better performance was due to the achievement words having activated a "high-performance goal". Because the paper has been cited well over 1100 times, an attempt to replicate its… 

Figures from this paper

Publication bias and low power in field studies on goal priming
TLDR
It is concluded that the available evidence falls short of demonstrating goal priming effects in the workplace, and proposals for how future research can provide stronger tests are offered.
and Their Absence − − An Intersensory Interaction Account of Priming Effects
Psychological researchers have found that exposures to stimuli (primes) can subsequently influence people’s behavior by pathways that would seem to be quite remote. For example, people exposed to
Replicable effects of primes on human behavior.
TLDR
A within-subjects procedure for priming behavior, in which participants decide whether to bet or pass on each trial of a gambling game, provides evidence that primes can reliably affect behavior, under at least some conditions, without intention.
Priming autonomous and controlling motivation and effects on persistence
The present studies examined whether priming distinct motivational states influenced persistence at a task designed to promote repeated failure, and post-task plans for engaging in self-regulatory
An Intersensory Interaction Account of Priming Effects—and Their Absence
  • R. Klatzky, J. Creswell
  • Psychology
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2014
TLDR
A general model of intersensory interaction is described, in which two or more sources of information provide an estimate or “bid” on a property of the world, with the perceptual outcome being a weighted combination of the bids.
The Historical Origins of Priming as the Preparation of Behavioral Responses: Unconscious Carryover and Contextual Influences of Real-World Importance
TLDR
The initial priming demonstrations in experimental psychology were of carryover effects from one experimental task to another—the same priming paradigm commonly employed in social psychology since the pioneering study of Higgins, Rholes, and Jones (1977).
Exploring the effect of subliminal single-word and multiple-word primes on working memory performance
This PhD thesis focused on subliminal priming, that is, the presentation of information below conscious awareness (Vernon, 2009), which has been shown to influence both cognitive and affective
From primed concepts to action: A meta-analysis of the behavioral effects of incidentally presented words.
TLDR
The notion that goal activation contributes over and above perception-behavior in explaining priming effects is supported, as theorizing about the role of value and satisfaction in goal activation pointed to stronger effects of a behavior or goal concept on overt action.
Attempts to prime intellectual virtues for understanding of science: Failures to inspire intellectual effort
Abstract Strategies for effectively communicating scientific findings to the public are an important and growing area of study. Recognizing that some complex subjects require recipients of
Priming Effects on Behavior and Priming Behavioral Concepts: A Commentary on Sherman and Rivers (2020)
Several failures to replicate underpowered priming studies conducted by social psychologists in the 2000s have been used to argue that priming effects on behavior cannot be reproduced (Harris,
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 56 REFERENCES
Behavioral Priming: It's All in the Mind, but Whose Mind?
TLDR
It is concluded that unconscious behavioral priming is real, while real, involves mechanisms different from those typically assumed to cause the effect.
The automated will: nonconscious activation and pursuit of behavioral goals.
TLDR
Five experiments reported in which the goal either to perform well or to cooperate was activated, without the awareness of participants, through a priming manipulation demonstrated that action guided by nonconsciously activated goals effectively guide action, enabling adaptation to ongoing situational demands.
Priming Intelligent Behavior: An Elusive Phenomenon
TLDR
None of the experiments obtained the intelligence priming effect, although financial incentives did boost performance, and a Bayesian analysis reveals considerable evidential support for the null hypothesis.
Mechanisms of source confusion and discounting in short-term priming: 1. Effects of prime duration and prime recognition
TLDR
Conditions of prime processing that produce this pattern of results are explored, revealing that increased prime duration under passive viewing instructions produces the active priming pattern.
Additive and interactive effects in semantic priming: Isolating lexical and decision processes in the lexical decision task.
TLDR
The results indicate that for clear targets, priming was reflected by distributional shifting of comparable magnitude across different nonword types, and for degraded targets,Priming of degraded targets was reflecting by shifting and an increase in the tail of the distribution.
The relation between perception and behavior, or how to win a game of trivial pursuit.
TLDR
Results of the experiments revealed that prolonged priming leads to more pronounced behavioral effects and that there is no sign of decay of the effects for at least 15 min.
A bias interpretation of facilitation in perceptual identification.
TLDR
This article uses a forced choice procedure to show that prior presentation of an item biases the subject to choose that item but does not improve discriminability, and two models of word identification are examined in light of the bias effects.
...
...