Trust in Testimony: Children's Use of True and False Statements

@article{Koenig2004TrustIT,
  title={Trust in Testimony: Children's Use of True and False Statements},
  author={Melissa Koenig and Fabrice Cl{\'e}ment and Paul L. Harris},
  journal={Psychological Science},
  year={2004},
  volume={15},
  pages={694 - 698}
}
The extent to which young children monitor and use the truth of assertions to gauge the reliability of subsequent testimony was examined. Three- and 4-year-old children were presented with two informants, an accurate labeler and an inaccurate labeler. They were then invited to learn names for novel objects from these informants. The children correctly monitored and identified the informants on the basis of the truth of their prior labeling. Furthermore, children who explicitly identified the… 

Tables from this paper

In the absence of conflicting testimony young children trust inaccurate informants.

TLDR
The results suggest that even though young children use prior history of accuracy to determine the relative reliability of informants, they are quite willing to trust the testimony of a single informant alone, regardless of whether that informant had previously been reliable.

The emergence of selective trust in early childhood

Children cannot check the veracity of many of the claims they hear. When told the name of an unfamiliar object, or presented with various historical, scientific or metaphysical claims, they typically

"I'm Better than You at Labeling!": Preschoolers Use Past Reliability when Accepting Unexpected Labels

TLDR
It is suggested that preschool-aged children selectively revise their own knowledge; they are more trusting toward sources proven accurate than inaccurate.

Influence of social closeness on children’s trust in testimony

I examined whether interpersonal similarity, an indicator of social closeness, influenced children’s epistemic trust in others’ testimony. Three- to 5-year-olds met two puppet informants, one of whom

Children assess informant reliability using bystanders' non-verbal cues.

Recent findings show that preschool children are selective with respect to whom they ask for information and whose claims they endorse. In particular, they monitor an informant's record of past

The Basis of Epistemic Trust: Reliable Testimony or Reliable Sources?

ABSTRACT What is the nature of children's trust in testimony? Is it based primarily on evidential correlations between statements and facts, as stated by Hume, or does it derive from an interest in

The Development and Understanding of Selective Trust in Preschool Children

The purpose of this dissertation was to investigate preschool children's selective trust and understanding of reliability. These experiments present new key findings in the area of selective trust.

Trust in testimony about strangers: young children prefer reliable informants who make positive attributions.

  • J. Boseovski
  • Psychology
    Journal of experimental child psychology
  • 2012

Children's trust in previously inaccurate informants who were well or poorly informed: when past errors can be excused.

TLDR
This study shows that children do not necessarily treat a previously inaccurate speaker as unreliable, rather, they appropriately excuse past inaccuracy arising from the speaker's limited information access.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 20 REFERENCES

The Ontogenesis of Trust

Psychologists have emphasized children's acquisition of information through first-hand observation. However, many beliefs are acquired from others' testimony. In two experiments, most 4-year-olds

Children's suggestibility in relation to their understanding about sources of knowledge.

TLDR
Three- to 4-year-olds were more accurate at reporting the knowledge source of the adult they believed than at deciding which suggestion was reliable, and decision making in this observation task may require reflective understanding akin to that required for explicit source judgments when the child participates in the task.

Knowing How You Know: Young Children's Ability to Identify and Remember the Sources of Their Beliefs.

GOPNIK, ALISON, and GRAF, PETER. Knowing How You Know: Young Children's Ability to Identify and Remember the Sources of Their Beliefs. CHILD DEVELOPMENT, 1988, 59, 1366-1371. Young children's

The influence of the imagination on reasoning by young children

Young children are often prone to an ‘empirical’ bias when asked to reason from premises that do not conform to their everyday knowledge. Experiment 1 identified three cues that help 4- and

Children's predictions of consistency in people's actions

Children's understanding of knowledge acquisition: the tendency for children to report that they have always known what they have just learned.

TLDR
4-year-olds in Experiment 4 were better able to distinguish novel and familiar color words when the teaching of the novel words was an explicit and salient part of the procedure.

Learning words from knowledgeable versus ignorant speakers: links between preschoolers' theory of mind and semantic development.

TLDR
Findings suggest that theory-of-mind developments impact word learning, and whether children consider speakers' knowledge states when establishing initial word-referent links is addressed.

Persisting effects of instruction on young children's syllogistic reasoning with incongruent and abstract premises

Studies of reasoning have often invoked a distinction between a natural or ordinary consideration of the premises, in which they are interpreted, and even distorted, in the light of empirical

The effect of make‐believe play on deductive reasoning

Under certain circumstances, a deductive or ‘theoretical’ mode of reasoning is revealed among young children, as well as among illiterate adults. In four experiments we asked whether 4-, 5- and