Trouble with the Lorentz law of force: incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation.

@article{Mansuripur2012TroubleWT,
  title={Trouble with the Lorentz law of force: incompatibility with special relativity and momentum conservation.},
  author={Masud Mansuripur},
  journal={Physical review letters},
  year={2012},
  volume={108 19},
  pages={
          193901
        }
}
The Lorentz law of force is the fifth pillar of classical electrodynamics, the other four being Maxwell's macroscopic equations. The Lorentz law is the universal expression of the force exerted by electromagnetic fields on a volume containing a distribution of electrical charges and currents. If electric and magnetic dipoles also happen to be present in a material medium, they are traditionally treated by expressing the corresponding polarization and magnetization distributions in terms of… 

Figures from this paper

The force law of classical electrodynamics: Lorentz versus Einstein and Laub

  • M. Mansuripur
  • Physics
    Optics & Photonics - NanoScience + Engineering
  • 2013
The classical theory of electrodynamics is built upon Maxwell’s equations and the concepts of electromagnetic field, force, energy, and momentum, which are intimately tied together by Poynting’s

On the electrodynamics of moving permanent dipoles in external electromagnetic fields

  • M. Mansuripur
  • Physics
    Optics & Photonics - NanoScience + Engineering
  • 2014
The classical theory of electrodynamics is built upon Maxwell’s equations and the concepts of electromagnetic field, force, energy and momentum, which are intimately tied together by Poynting’s

On the foundational equations of the classical theory of electrodynamics

A close examination of the Maxwell-Lorentz theory of electrodynamics reveals that polarization and magnetization of material media need not be treated as local averages over small volumes — volumes

The Relativistic Electrodynamics of Classical Charged Particles

Maxwell’s equations and the Lorentz force equation form the foundation of classical electromagnetic theory and their discovery led to the development of special relativity. Despite this achievement,

Maxwell’s equations in material media, momentum balance equations and force densities associated with them

It is common to take the Lorentz force density as a postulate independent of Maxwell’s equations. Mansuripur (Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 193901 (2012)) does so, and applies it using the polarization

Does Lorentz Force Law Contradict the Principle and Theories of Relativity for Uniform Linear Motion

I show that no force or torque is generated in cases involving a charge and a magnet with their relative velocity zero, in any iner-tial frame of reference. A recent suspicion of an anomalous torque

The charge-magnet paradoxes of classical electrodynamics

  • M. Mansuripur
  • Physics
    Optics & Photonics - NanoScience + Engineering
  • 2014
A number of charge-magnet paradoxes have been discussed in the literature, beginning with Shockley’s famous 1967 paper, where he introduced the notion of hidden momentum in electromagnetic systems.

Lorentz Symmetry Group, Retardation and Energy Transformations in a Relativistic Engine

TLDR
This work gives a complete analysis of the exchange of energy between the mechanical part of the relativistic engine and the field part, the energy radiated from the relatvistic engine is also discussed and it is shown that the relativist engine effect on the energy is 4th-order in 1/c and no lower order relativist engine effecton the energy exist.

Biquaternion em Forces with Hidden Momentum and an Extended Lorentz Force Law, the Lorentz-Larmor Law

In this paper we apply our version of biquaternion math-phys to electrodynamics, especially to moving electromagnetic dipole moments. After a terminological introduction and applying the developed

Balance Equations of Electromagnetic Angular Momentum

We give theoretical foundation to torque densities proposed in the past, like the one used by Beth to study experimentally the action of circularly polarized radiation on a birefringent material, or
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 35 REFERENCES

Maxwell's macroscopic equations, the energy-momentum postulates, and the Lorentz law of force.

TLDR
It is argued that the classical theory of electromagnetism is based on Maxwell's macroscopic equations, an energy postulates, a momentum postulate, and a generalized form of the Lorentz law of force, thus eliminating the need for actual models of polarization P and magnetization M.

Energy, momentum, and force in classical electrodynamics: application to negative-index media

The classical theory of electromagnetism is based on Maxwell's macroscopic equations, an energy postulate, a momentum postulate, and a generalized form of the Lorentz law of force. These seven

Electromagnetic force and torque in ponderable media.

TLDR
This analysis demonstrates consistency with the conservation laws by showing that, when a beam of light enters a magnetic dielectric, a fraction of the incident linear momentum pours into the medium at a rate determined by the Abraham momentum density, E x H/c(2), and the group velocity V(g) of the electromagnetic field.

Resolution of the Abraham-Minkowski controversy

Radiation pressure and the linear momentum of the electromagnetic field in magnetic media.

TLDR
This work examines the force of the electromagnetic radiation on linear, isotropic, homogeneous media specified in terms of their permittivity epsilon and permeability mu and identifies an "intrinsic" mechanical momentum density, analogous to the electromagnetic momentum density.

Radiation pressure and the linear momentum of the electromagnetic field.

TLDR
This work derives the force of the electromagnetic radiation on material objects by a direct application of the Lorentz law of classical electrodynamics, and derives an expression for the momentum density of the light field inside dielectric media that contains both electromagnetic and mechanical terms.

Electromagnetic forces on point dipoles

  • A. Yaghjian
  • Physics
    IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium. 1999 Digest. Held in conjunction with: USNC/URSI National Radio Science Meeting (Cat. No.99CH37010)
  • 1999
The forces exerted on classical electric and magnetic dipoles by externally applied electromagnetic fields are derived from first principles. It is found, in accordance with Penfield and Haus (1967)

Theory of the radiation pressure on dielectric surfaces

The radiation pressures exerted by light beams incident normally on dielectric surfaces are calculated by evaluation of the quantum-mechanical Lorentz force. The free-space surface of an almost