Trial and Error: Lawyers and Nonlawyer Advocates

  title={Trial and Error: Lawyers and Nonlawyer Advocates},
  author={Anna E. Carpenter and Alyx Mark and Colleen F. Shanahan},
  journal={Law \&\#x0026; Social Inquiry},
  pages={1023 - 1057}
Nonlawyer advocates are one proposed solution to the access to justice crisis. Theory and research suggest that nonlawyers might be effective, yet scholars know very little, empirically, about nonlawyer practice in the United States. Using data from more than 5,000 unemployment insurance appeal hearings and interviews with lawyers and nonlawyers who represent employers in these hearings, this article explores how both types of representatives develop expertise and what this means for… Expand
2 Citations
Producing Expertise in a Transitional Justice Setting: Judges at Rwanda’s Gacaca Courts
In the aftermath of the 1994 Genocide Against the Tutsi, the Government of Rwanda created courts to hold hundreds of thousands of suspected g enocidaires accountable. Faced with an unprecedentedExpand
Trois nuances de l’expertise stratégique : le rôle des avocats dans la procédure d’asile
Au cours de la dernière décennie, les juristes ont documenté de façon régulière les disparités dans les taux de reconnaissance du statut de réfugié, concluant que le facteur déterminant est moins leExpand


Elements of Professional Expertise: Understanding Relational and Substantive Expertise through Lawyers' Impact
Lawyers keep the gates of public justice institutions, particularly through their roles in formal procedures like hearings and trials. Yet, it is not clear what lawyers do in such quintessentiallyExpand
Attorney Expertise, Litigant Success, and Judicial Decisionmaking in the U.S. Courts of Appeals
In the U.S. legal system, litigants frequently retain counsel to represent their interest in civil cases, particularly when the stakes are high. Scholarly work and anecdotal evidence suggest thatExpand
In Pursuit of Justice? Case Outcomes and the Delivery of Unbundled Legal Services
In the United States today, an estimated eighty percent of the legal needs of the poor go unmet. The Supreme Court has repeatedly identified access to the courts as a fundamental constitutionalExpand
Legal Advocacy: Lawyers and Nonlawyers at Work
Legal Advocacy describes lawyers and nonlawyer advocates at work in four different legal settings: unemployment compensation claims appeals, Social Security disability appeals, state tax appeals, andExpand
Repeat Players in the Supreme Court: The Role of Experienced Lawyers in Litigation Success
How important are lawyers in the decision making of the U.S. Supreme Court? Although legal expertise has long been assumed to benefit certain litigants, the frequency with which lawyers appear beforeExpand
INSIGHTFUL OR WISHFUL: Lawyers' Ability to Predict Case Outcomes
Lawyers’ litigation forecasts play an integral role in the justice system. In the course of litigation, lawyers constantly make strategic decisions and/or advise their clients on the basis of theirExpand
The Plural of Anecdote is Not Data: Teaching Law Students Basic Survey Methodology to Improve Access to Justice in Unemployment Insurance Appeals
A large number of individuals who appear before the District of Columbia Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) are self-represented, and many of them would benefit from having legal representationExpand
Lawyers, Power, and Strategic Expertise
This empirical study analyzes the experience of the parties described above, specifically the power, representation, and strategic expertise they bring to a dispute. Our analysis of these factorsExpand
The Impact of Counsel: An Analysis of Empirical Evidence
In this article, I provide three lenses on empirical evidence about the American public’s experience with civil justice problems: the depth of public experience, the scope of public experience, andExpand
A National Study of Access to Counsel in Immigration Court
Although immigrants have a right to be represented by counsel in immigration court, it has long been the case that the government has no obligation to provide an attorney for those who are unable toExpand