Transrectal Ultrasound versus Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Estimation of Prostate Volume as Compared with Radical Prostatectomy Specimens

@article{Lee2007TransrectalUV,
  title={Transrectal Ultrasound versus Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Estimation of Prostate Volume as Compared with Radical Prostatectomy Specimens},
  author={Jae Seok Lee and Byung Ha Chung},
  journal={Urologia Internationalis},
  year={2007},
  volume={78},
  pages={323 - 327}
}
Introduction: There are relatively few studies that compare the use of transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to estimate the prostate volume. In this study, we compared the prostate volumes measured with MRI and TRUS with a surgical specimen volume. Patients and Methods: Seventy-three patients underwent TRUS examination of the prostate prior to radical prostatectomy. All specimens were weighed and measured when freshly excised. The corresponding volume measurements… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Prostate volume estimations using magnetic resonance imaging and transrectal ultrasound compared to radical prostatectomy specimens.
TLDR
MRI demonstrated better correlation with prostatectomy specimen volume in most patients and may be better suited in cases where TRUS and MRI estimates are disparate, as well as consistent with pathological volumes along the prostate size spectrum.
Prostate volume measurement by multiparametric magnetic resonance and transrectal ultrasound: comparison with surgical specimen weight
TLDR
Prostate volume measured by multiparametric magnetic resonance imaging and transrectal ultrasound showed similar values, and excellent agreement with real prostate weight of the surgical specimens, and its value enables appropriate therapeutic planning and control of patients.
Prostate Volumetric Assessment by Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Transrectal Ultrasound: Impact of Variation in Calculated Prostate-Specific Antigen Density on Patient Eligibility for Active Surveillance Program
TLDR
Although clinically used TRUS reliably estimates PSAD, it may misclassify some patients who are not eligible for AS based on PSAD criteria, and magnetic resonance–based volumetry should be considered for a more reliable PSAD calculation.
Assessment of in vivo calculation with ultrasonography compared to physical sections in vitro: a stereological study of prostate volumes
TLDR
Three methods for the determination of prostate volume are compared: prostate volume measured via transrectal ultrasonography (TRUS), the Cavalieri method for measuring physical sections; and volume by displacement, and the classic ellipsoid formula is believed to be inadequate.
The Comparison of Imaging and Clinical Methods to Estimate Prostate Volume: A Single-Centre Retrospective Study
TLDR
The PV obtained by MRI has proven to correlate with the PV obtained via auto-segmentation software as well as actual SPW, while also being more cost-effective and time-efficient.
How Accurately Can Prostate Gland Imaging Measure the Prostate Gland Volume? Results of a Systematic Review
TLDR
The reported correlations were moderate to high in strength indicating that imaging is sufficiently accurate when quantitative measurements of prostate gland volume are required, and MRI was slightly more accurate than the other methods.
Fully automated prostate segmentation on MRI: comparison with manual segmentation methods and specimen volumes.
TLDR
Prostate volume estimates obtained with a fully automated 3D segmentation tool based on normalized gradient fields cross-correlation and graph-search refinement can yield highly accurate prostate volume estimates in a clinically relevant time of 10 seconds.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 20 REFERENCES
Comparison of transrectal ultrasound prostatic volume estimation with magnetic resonance imaging volume estimation and surgical specimen weight in patients with benign prostatic hyperplasia
TLDR
Because TRUS is cheap, user‐friendly, noninvasive, and equally as accurate as MRI, it should be the preferred modality in the follow‐up of BPH patients.
Determination of prostate gland volume by transrectal ultrasound: correlation with radical prostatectomy specimens.
TLDR
A modified prolate ellipse formula, using the factor of 0.70, appears to be a more reliable means of estimating gland volume with transrectal ultrasound than the original formula [Width x Height x Length) x 0.523.
Transrectal ultrasonography: why are estimates of prostate volume and dimension so inaccurate?
TLDR
This study confirms that to estimate accurately the volume of the prostate using the prolate ellipsoid formula, the current methodology needs to be changed.
The accuracy of transrectal ultrasound prostate volume estimation: Clinical correlations
TLDR
Transrectal ultrasound estimates of prostate volumes differ significantly from the volume of unfixed RRP specimens, and the direction and magnitude of TRUS‐V error is volume dependent.
Determination of prostate volume with transrectal US for cancer screening. Part II. Accuracy of in vitro and in vivo techniques.
TLDR
Although less accurate than planimetry, HWL is a rapid volume measurement technique that appears to be more accurate than ellipsoid software packages; its universal availability makes it practical for routine clinical use.
Assessment of volume measurement of the prostate using per-rectal ultrasonography.
TLDR
Estimation of the size of cancers unconfined to the gland was poor and measurement was not possible with 3 malignant prostates that had extended beyond the prostatic capsule so that the ultrasonic boundary could not be defined.
Reproducibility of prostate volume measurements from transrectal ultrasonography by an automated and a manual technique.
TLDR
The variability of computer outlining was slightly higher than expected theoretically and the within-session variability was higher than the variation caused by errors in outlining predefined contours, indicating that the interpretation of TRUS images differed with time.
Dynamic Magnetic Resonance Tomography and Proton Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy of Prostate Cancers in Rats Treated by Radiotherapy
TLDR
DCE MRI and 1H-MRS has potential to characterize orthotopic Dunning prostate cancer in rats, which is a promising model similar to human prostate carcinomas.
...
...