Tradition and Modernity: Misplaced Polarities in the Study of Social Change

@article{Gusfield1967TraditionAM,
  title={Tradition and Modernity: Misplaced Polarities in the Study of Social Change},
  author={Joseph R. Gusfield},
  journal={American Journal of Sociology},
  year={1967},
  volume={72},
  pages={351 - 362}
}
  • J. Gusfield
  • Published 1 January 1967
  • Medicine, Sociology
  • American Journal of Sociology
"Tradition" and "modernity" are widely used as polar opposites in a linear theory of social change. This theory is examined in the light of Indian and other materials on development. Seven fallacies in this contrast usage are presented. It is incorrect to view traditional societies as static, normatively consist, or structurally homogeneous. The relations between the traditional and the modern do not necessarily involve idsplacement, conflict, or exclusiveness. Modernity does not necessarily… Expand

Topics from this paper

Modernity, modernities and modernization: Tradition reappraised
The current discourse of modernity has produced many new terms to reflect the multiple conditions of social change. However, they do not automatically suggest a direct transition from the traditionalExpand
COSMOPOLITANISM AND THE USES OF TRADITION: ROBERT REDFIELD AND ALTERNATIVE VISIONS OF MODERNIZATION DURING THE COLD WAR*
The history of the rise and fall of “modernization theory” after World War II has been told as a story of Talcott Parsons, Walt Rostow, and other US social scientists who built a general theory in USExpand
Tradition vs. Modernity : The Continuing Dichotomy of Values in European Society
The modernisation theories developed in the 50s and 60s suggested that societies were converging toward modern values, gradually abandoning their traditional values. This convergence idea isExpand
Sociology and the study of non-western societies
This paper attacks parochialism, ethnocentrism, and universalism in Western sociology. Conceptual limitations of the discipline are discussed in light of the emergent transnational scene. The authorExpand
On The Decline of Contemporary Political Development Studies
This study argues that the self-described “malaise” in the study of political development theory is in part the product of the early attempt to strip judgments of value from those of fact in theExpand
Some Dilemmas of 'Modernisation'
THEORIES of ‘modernisation’ are in the main a phenomenon of the post-war social sciences, developed as a response to the characteristics of social change in the post-war world and especially, socialExpand
CONSENSUS, CONFLICT, AND INTERNATIONAL STRATIFICATION THEORIES OF MODERNIZATION:
This paper reviews two of the major sociological theories of modernization, the consensus and conflict perspectives. These two theories are used to analyze some aspects of the economic and politicalExpand
Industrial Modernization and Political Change: A Latin American Perspective
The rise of a new wave of authoritarian regimes in the economically more advanced countries of Latin America has stimulated new debate on the relationship between socioeconomic development andExpand
Tradition and modernity: an obsolete dichotomy? Binary thinking, indigenous peoples and normalisation
Abstract The debates over Indigenous peoples and development are often framed within the discussion on the shift towards modernity, the imposition of economic liberalism and resistance againstExpand
Germond-Duret, CV Tradition and Modernity: An Obsolete Dichotomy? Reflection on Binary Thinking and Indigenous Peoples
The debates over Indigenous peoples and development are often framed within the discussion on the shift towards modernity, the imposition of economic liberalism, and the resistance against externalExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-6 OF 6 REFERENCES
See the analysis of the Panchayats in my paper on Indian political community, cited above (n. 27); and in Reinhard Bendix
  • 1963
Swaraj for the People [Varanasi: Ahkhih Bharat Sarva Seva Sangh
  • 1961
Even in the Swatantra Party, a movement led by an antitraditionalist set of ideologies, its anti-Congress character has drawn to it strong forces of antimodernism (see Howard Erdman
  • Leadership and Political Institutions in India
  • 1960
This quest for an indigenous form of political democracy is marked in Narayan's writings, as well as in conversation (see Jaya Prakash Narayan, The Dual Revolution
  • 1959
Hindu Communal Groups in Indian Politics
    Witness the rise of self-conscious rediscovery of Hindi literary tradition. The linguistic and cultural renaissances in many parts of India are postindependence phenomena