Tracking intergenerational progress for immigrant groups: The problem of ethnic attrition

  title={Tracking intergenerational progress for immigrant groups: The problem of ethnic attrition},
  author={Brian Duncan and Stephen J. Trejo},
  journal={The American Economic Review},
In tracking the later-generation descendants of immigrants, measurement biases can arise from "ethnic attrition" (e.g., US-born individuals who do not self-identify as Mexican despite having ancestors who immigrated from Mexico). We present evidence that such ethnic attrition is sizeable and selective for the third-generation populations of key Hispanic and Asian immigrant groups. In addition, our results suggest that ethnic attrition generates biases that vary across national origin groups in… 

Tables from this paper

Ethnic Attrition, Assimilation, and the Measured Health Outcomes of Mexican Americans

The literature on immigrant assimilation and intergenerational progress has sometimes reached surprising conclusions, such as the puzzle of immigrant advantage which finds that Hispanic immigrants

Intergenerational Mobility of the Mexican-Origin Population in California and Texas Relative to a Changing Regional Mainstream

It is found that selective in-migration of more highly-educated whites has raised the bar on some, not all, measures of attainment, and poses a challenge to studies of assimilation that do not compare grown-children to their fellow natives of a state.

Feminized Intergenerational Mobility Without Assimilation? Post-1965 U.S. Immigrants and the Gender Revolution

It is found that second- generation women experience greater status attainment than both their mothers and their male counterparts, but the earnings of second-generation women lag behind those of men.

Defining difference: the role of immigrant generation and race in American and British immigration studies

Abstract This article reviews the ways in which Britain and the USA classify and analyse the integration of immigrants and their descendants. While both societies recognize racial differences in

Intermarriage and the Unhealthy Assimilation of Immigrant Descendants

The results do not appear to be driven by father's selectivity nor by individual unobservable characteristics associated with intermarriage, and the children of intermarried natives do not receive the same "health penalty", nor do Hispanics intermarried to other ethnic groups.

Employment Among US Hispanics: a Tale of Three Generations

Immigrants’ descendants typically assimilate toward mainstream social and economic outcomes across generations. Hispanics in the USA are a possible exception to this pattern. Although there is a

Hispanics in the U.S. Labor Market: A Tale of Three Generations

Immigrants? descendants typically assimilate toward mainstream social and economic outcomes across generations. Hispanics in the United States are a possible exception to this pattern. Although there

Ethnicity differentials in academic achievements: the role of time investments

Children of Asian immigrants in most English-speaking destinations have better academic outcomes, yet the underlying causes of their advantages are under-studied. We employ panel time-use diaries by

Hardship Among Immigrants and the Native-born in the United States.

Overall, these findings suggest that immigrants are not particularly prone to hardship, especially when other characteristics are controlled for, and the lower likelihood of some hardships among foreign-born citizens suggests that they are positively selected: they may have unobserved characteristics that are protective, such as better health, stronger social networks, or money management skills.

Parental Background and Union Formation Behavior of Native Born Individuals in Sweden with a Foreign Background

Social cohesion in destination countries is an increasingly important issue due to the multiethnic structures in these countries and due to ongoing international migration. Union formation of



Intermarriage and the Intergenerational Transmission of Ethnic Identity and Human Capital for Mexican Americans

It is shown that ethnic attrition is substantial and could produce significant downward bias in standard measures of attainment that rely on ethnic self-identification.

Immigrants and the Labor Market

This article examines skill gaps between immigrants and native‐born Americans and generational progress achieved by different immigrant ethnic groups. Evidence of a widening skill gap is not strong.

The Case of the Disappearing Mexican Americans: An Ethnic-Identity Mystery

We examine the issue of identification stability for U.S.-born Mexican Americans, by far the largest of the ethnic groups growing as a result of contemporary immigration. We demonstrate a significant

Ethnic Identification, Intermarriage, and Unmeasured Progress by Mexican Americans

Using Census and CPS data, we show that U.S.-born Mexican Americans who marry non-Mexicans are substantially more educated and English proficient, on average, than are Mexican Americans who marry

Human Capital and Interethnic Marriage Decisions

If education distributions differ by ethnicity, then spouse-searchers may trade similarities in ethnicity for similarities in education when choosing spouses, and U.S. Census data on second-generation immigrants provide strong support for the assortative matching mechanism.

Ages, Life Stages, and Generational Cohorts: Decomposing the Immigrant First and Second Generations in the United States 1

This article focuses on problems with the definition and empirical identification of immigrant “first” and “second” generations in the United States. These loosely conceived aggregates are decomposed

Ancestry versus Ethnicity: The Complexity and Selectivity of Mexican Identification in the United States

Using microdata from the 2000 US Census, we analyze the responses of Mexican Americans to questions that independently elicit their “ethnicity” (or Hispanic origin) and their “ancestry.” We

The Changing Racial and Ethnic Composition of the US Population: Emerging American Identities.

An in-depth examination of the racial and ethnic reporting by whites, blacks, Asians, and Hispanics in the 2000 census shows the emerging pattern, labeled here as the "Americanization" ofracial and ethnic identities, is of simplified racial identities with little acknowledgment of complex ancestries.

Who Are We?: The Challenges to America's National Identity

In his seminal work "The Clash of Civilizations" and the "Remaking of World Order," Samuel Huntington argued provocatively and presciently that with the end of the cold war, "civilizations" were

Italians Then, Mexicans Now: Immigrant Origins and Second-Generation Progress

system. Indeed, as Karen Roberts states in the introduction (p. 1), the aim is to provide both a detailed introduction to workers' compensation for novices and fresh insights for the fully initiated.