Toward a net neutrality debate that conforms to the 2010s

  title={Toward a net neutrality debate that conforms to the 2010s},
  author={Patrick Maill{\'e} and Gwendal Simon and Bruno Tuffin},
  journal={IEEE Communications Magazine},
Network neutrality has been topic of discussion for the past 25 years, with current legislation/ regulation in the United States and Europe targeting the ISPs or “common carriers.” But the reality of the Internet in the 2010s is that various actors contribute to the delivery of data, with sometimes contradictory objectives. In this article, we highlight the fact that neutrality principles can be bypassed in many ways without violating the rules currently evoked in the debate; for example, via… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Impact of Heterogeneous Neutrality Rules with Competitive Content Providers
The results show that neutrality repeal may only favor the ISP in the differentiation-authorized zone, but no other actor, and that it can be worse off for everybody if the regulation procedures are very strict in the neutral area.
Non-neutrality with Users Deciding Differentiation: A Satisfying Option?
It is illustrated that, depending on network parameters, letting end users decide may end up as a fair and viable solution, and that non-neutrality imposed by ISPs is not necessarily bad for all actors.
Is zero rating the end of net neutrality and the open internet? An analysis of business practices and policy approaches
To answer the question if zero rating is going against net neutrality or if it enables net neutrality, five case studies were analysed and 18 experts interviewed.
Net Neutrality Under EU Law – a Hindrance to 5G Success
To what extent and how the 5G ideas can be applied under the EU law and whether something should be done about the law and in particular the Guidelines that have been published by the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) to clarify the implementation of the law are studied.
Neutral and Non-neutral Countries in a Global Internet: What Does It Imply?
The goal of this paper is to model and analyze the interactions of users, content providers, and Internet service providers located in countries with different rules.
Network Neutrality: Modeling and Challenges and Its Impact on Clouds
This talk introduces the elements of the debate and introduces how the problem can be modeled and analyzed through game theory and highlights how neutrality principles can be bypassed in various ways without violating the rules currently evoked in the debate.
Impact of the Net Neutrality Repeal on Communication Networks
The results show that the repeal of net neutrality can potentially increase ISPs profit by a factor of 8 with a pricing scheme that discriminates against data intensive content.
Monitoring Network Neutrality: A Survey on Traffic Differentiation Detection
This paper describes ways that can be used by an ISP to implement traffic differentiation, and defines the problem of differentiation detection, followed by a description of multiple existing strategies and tools.
Net neutrality in mobile broadband: A European study based on a large scale testbed
Analysis of a number of European mobile broadband operators in terms of neutrality shows that, despite EU regulations, some operators are not neutral, thus, highlighting the need for a monitoring system.
The Economics of CDNs and Their Impact on Service Fairness
A mathematical model is presented and it is shown that there exists a unique optimal revenue-maximizing policy for a CDN actor, in terms of dimensioning and allocation of its storage capacity, and depending on parameters such as prices for service/transport/storage.


How Neutral is a CDN? An economic approach
It is shown that there exists a unique optimal revenue-maximizing policy for a CDN actor-the dimensioning and allocation of its storage capacity-that depends on prices for service/transport/storage, and on the distribution of content popularity.
Net Neutrality or Net Neutering: Should Broadband Internet Services Be Regulated
Distribution, Vertical Integration and the Net Neutrality Debate.- Network Neutrality and Competition Policy: A Complex Relationship.- Are "Dumb Pipe" Mandates Smart Public Policy? Vertical
Federal Search Commission? Access, Fairness and Accountability in the Law of Search
Should search engines be subject to the types of regulation now applied to personal data collectors, cable networks, or phone books? In this article, we make the case for some regulation of the
Telecommunication Network Economics: From Theory to Applications
Presenting a balance of theory and practice, this up-to-date guide provides a comprehensive overview of the key issues in telecommunication network economics, as well as the mathematical models
Revenue-Maximizing Rankings for Online Platforms with Quality-Sensitive Consumers
Stochastic models are introduced and proposed effective solution methods that can be used to optimize the ranking considering long-term revenues and a key feature of the model is that customers are quality-sensitive and are attracted to the platform or driven away depending on the average relevance of the output.
Network Neutrality, Broadband Discrimination
  • Tim Wu
  • Economics
    J. Telecommun. High Technol. Law
  • 2003
The concept of network neutrality in telecommunications policy and its relationship to Darwinian theories of innovation are examined and the record of broadband discrimination practiced by broadband operators in the early 2000s is considered.
Video Stream Quality Impacts Viewer Behavior: Inferring Causality Using Quasi-Experimental Designs
This work is the first to establish a causal relationship between video quality and viewer behavior, taking a step beyond purely correlational studies and using Quasi-Experimental Designs, a novel technique adapted from the medical and social sciences.
Network Neutrality, Search Neutrality, and the Never-ending Conflict between Efficiency and Fairness in Markets
Historical precedents suggest that the basic issues underlying the debate about network neutrality, dealing with the balance between efficiency and fairness in markets, will never be resolved. Should
Netflix Performance on Verizon and Comcast Has Been Dropping for Months
  • Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council Laying Down Measures Concerning the European Single Market for Electronic Communications and to Achieve a Connected Continent , and Amending Directives
  • 2002