Toward a Unified Validation Framework in Mixed Methods Research

  title={Toward a Unified Validation Framework in Mixed Methods Research},
  author={Amy B. Dellinger and Nancy L. Leech},
  journal={Journal of Mixed Methods Research},
  pages={309 - 332}
  • A. Dellinger, N. Leech
  • Published 1 October 2007
  • Psychology, Business, Medicine
  • Journal of Mixed Methods Research
The primary purpose of this article is to further discussions of validity in mixed methods research by introducing a validation framework to guide thinking about validity in this area. To justify the use of this framework, the authors discuss traditional terminology and validity criteria for quantitative and qualitative research, as well as present recently published validity terminology for mixed methods research. The authors discuss the rationale for their framework and how it unifies… 

Figures from this paper

The Quality of ‘Good’ Mixed Methods Research: Development and Discussion of an Orientation Framework
  • M. Völcker
  • Business
    Triangulation und Mixed-Methods
  • 2019
Beyond entrenched methodological disputes, Mixed Methods attempt to promote a combination of qualitative and quantitative materialities in a single study, suitable to study the subject of research
A mixed method approach to clarify the construct validity of interprofessional collaboration: An empirical research illustration
It is argued that a combination of methodologies may be a feasible way to enhance the understanding of IPC, with a special focus on reliability and validity issues.
Evaluating Mixed Research Studies: A Mixed Methods Approach
Using the VF, three studies from education, health care, and counseling fields are evaluated and pragmatic researchers can use this tool to increase the quality of their evaluations of mixed research studies.
Validity in mixed methods research in education: the application of Habermas' critical theory
ABSTRACT Mixed methods approach has developed into the third methodological movement in educational research. Validity in mixed methods research as an important issue, however, has not been examined
A Preliminary Rubric Design to Evaluate Mixed Methods Research.
With the increase in frequency of the use of mixed methods, both in research publications and in externally funded grants there are increasing calls for a set of standards to assess the quality of
Promoting Quality of Mixed Methods Consultation Research: A Synergistic Participatory Framework
ABSTRACT The purpose of this article is to provide researchers with a framework for promoting high quality mixed methods school-based consultation research. Furthermore, this article is intended for
Threats to validity and reliability in mixed methods accounting research
A wide range of threats to the validity and reliability of mixed methods research in a range of categories are indicated, which indicates how the three perspectives described in this paper are linked and supplement each other.
From Mixed-Methods Research to a Journal Article
This chapter begins with the validity issues that need to be addressed when seamlessly merging research methods with distinctively different philosophies and methods and supports the reader in writing each component of a mixed methods research article.
A Mixed Methods Model of Scale Development and Validation Analysis
A hands-on model of using mixed methods to develop new scales and using multiple approaches to conduct validation analysis is proposed, which is practical and useful for researchers who desire to develop a reliable scale.
Validity in Qualitative Research: A Processual Approach
Validity and reliability of research and its results are important elements to provide evidence of the quality of research in the organizational field. However, validity is better evidenced in


Validity and Qualitative Research: An Oxymoron?
Although the importance of validity has long been accepted among quantitative researchers, this concept has been an issue of contention among qualitative researchers. Thus, the first purpose of the
The Validity Issue in Mixed Research
In quantitative research, the importance of validity has been long accepted. In qualitative research, discussions of validity have been more contentious and different typologies and terms have been
[Quality criteria for qualitative research].
Criteria for quality in qualitative research will be described, discussed, and compared with the usual criteria for quantitative research to support novice qualitative researchers and to stimulate further discussion.
Mixed Methods Research: A Research Paradigm Whose Time Has Come
The purposes of this article are to position mixed methods research (mixed research is a synonym) as the natural complement to traditional qualitative and quantitative research, to present pragmatism
Defining and Designing Mixed Research Synthesis Studies.
  • M. Sandelowski, C. Voils, J. Barroso
  • Sociology
    Research in the schools : a nationally refereed journal sponsored by the Mid-South Educational Research Association and the University of Alabama
  • 2006
Much work remains to be done before mixed research synthesis can secure its place in the repertoires of mixed methods research and systematic review, but the effort is well worth it as it has the potential to enhance both the significance and utility for practice of the many qualitative and quantitative studies constituting shared domains of research.
Meaning and Values in Test Validation: The Science and Ethics of Assessment
Because both score meaning and the value implications of scores as a basis for action are central issues in test validation, a unified view of validity is required that comprehends both the
Using Qualitative Methods for Causal Explanation
The view that qualitative research methods can be used to identify causal relationships and develop causal explanations is now accepted by a significant number of both qualitative and quantitative
Mixed Methodology: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches
This chapter discusses research design issues for Mixed Method and Mixed Model Studies, as well as applications, applications, and future directions of mixed model research.
A Historical Comparison of Validity Standards and Validity Practices
The present study examined the relationship between the validity theory of the past 50 years with actual validity practices. This process involved the comparison of validity requirements and theory
A Dialectic on Validity: Where We Have Been and Where We Are Going
Abstract It has been suggested that the primary issue in considerations of validity today is the discrepancy between currently accepted theory and the practice of validation. The reason for this